Skip to content 159: Gender Identity and the Risk Benefit Ratio | Joseph Figliolia & Garry Ingraham Apr 14 · 59 min ...more
159: Gender Identity and the Risk Benefit Ratio | Joseph Figliolia & Garry Ingraham
April 14, 2026 · 59 min
This week we meet with Joseph Figliolia, an unbiased policy analyst specializing in the critical debate between affirming care and psychological care. He sheds light on the medical, ethical and cultural implications often overlooked in mainstream conversations, and provides a clear look at what the data actually shows. We hope this message gives you a better understanding of gender-affirming care.
Series Love & Truth Network - Audio Edition April 14, 2026 · 59 min · Love & Truth Network - Audio Edition
This week we meet with Joseph Figliolia, an unbiased policy analyst specializing in the critical debate between affirming care and psychological care. He sheds light on the medical, ethical and cultural implications often overlooked in mainstream conversations, and provides a clear look at what the data actually shows. We hope this message gives you a better understanding of gender-affirming care. ...more Show the full description Show less This week we meet with Joseph Figliolia, an unbiased policy analyst specializing in the critical debate between affirming care and psychological care. He sheds light on the medical, ethical and cultural implications often overlooked in mainstream conversations, and provides a clear look at what the data actually shows. We hope this message gives you a better understanding of gender-affirming care.
Series Love & Truth Network - Audio Edition Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Support this leader
Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Give
Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
49.1K followers
Love & Truth Network equips pastors and local churches to restore relational & sexual wholeness and biblical identity. We accomplish this through our resources,
49.1K followers
In this video 0:00 Challenging Transgender Ideology and Personal Confusion21:20 Affirmation vs. Evidence-Based Care34:49 Debunking Suicide Myths and Comorbidities45:10 Stereotypes, Language, and Path ForwardComments No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Challenging Transgender Ideology and Personal Confusion 0:01 Transgender ideology, what it does is it tells anyone that isn't on the far left masculine pole and the far right feminine pole has to can't be a boy or a girl.0:13 The language I've often heard, and I'm sure you have too, of mental health providers or doctors that will say to parents, do you want a dead daughter or a live son?0:20 Anyone who knows anything about, like, child or adolescent psychology is not gonna be sort of, like, in the business of, like, crystallizing an identity early in development. James Lindsay,0:33 as 1 of the co authors of The Queering of the American Child, and just talking about, in that book, he writes about this idea of queering from their own words, the mothers and fathers of queer theory, that it's not about0:44 making someone gay or not. It's about the dismantling and the tearing down of all things, heteronormative. And and and it's really, more about kind of chaos and anarchy than anything else. The0:57 the kind of culture at large always telling you, like, this policy in this state that just says, hey, this medical practice doesn't work for this particular treatment is inherently discriminatory, and they want to erase1:09 you from the face of the earth. Obviously to a population that's really sensitive to this kind of perceived rejection, this kind of messaging also I think amplifies a lot of, this,1:21 this this catastrophic thinking that some people I think are already inclined to do.
1:25 You get these people who the that are down this road, double mastectomies or, other other medical interventions that have gone on and eventually realizing I don't know that I'm ever gonna get to where I
1:37 thought I could be, but I can never go back to who I once was either.
1:41 If that's the case, that this is non pathological, and the distress is not inherent to this this this way of being, then how can this also be simultaneous life saving or medically necessary?
1:52 Truth is like a lion. You don't need to defend it. You just need to let it loose. Welcome to the Love and Truth Network podcast, your guide for hope and healing in a hurting world searching for truth. Here, we explore
2:04 God's extraordinary design for biblical sexuality, identity, and authentic community. You'll be impacted by incredible stories of transformation, practical wisdom from pastors and counselors, and the power of God's grace
2:15 that changes lives. Hey, everybody. Thank you so much for joining us for another episode of the Love
2:27 and Truth Network podcast. We're glad that you're here today, and I have somebody who's with me. I I met not that long ago, in in a panel discussion that was being put on. I was reached out to by,
2:39 a group, Concepts of Truth International, and they're connected with the United Nations and, having working to have, an influence there, in in some of the,
2:51 committees and some of the presentations that are there. So on the commission for social development, this particular group is doing something on the so called, well, not so called, the mental health harms of so
3:03 called, gender affirming care for children, pediatric gender affirming care. And in that, panel discussion, I videotaped a session and I interviewed, Laura
3:15 Perry Smalls for that particular session. And Joseph Figliolio was actually there live, with some others, who were presenting on that. And, and it's the first experience I had of
3:27 getting to know him, and I thought, wow. I would love for you all to be able to hear, his wisdom on this and and and to be right up front. Joseph is not a Christian. He's not a believer. And, usually, I'm
3:39 interviewing people who, are speaking from that framework. But, frankly, I love the fact that Joseph is bringing a completely different, framework to this discussion. I I'm excited for you to hear about
3:50 this, but it's he's not bringing this from a biblical Christian worldview perspective. He's bringing simply science research data to talk about these issues of,
4:02 gender identity and, and particularly with regard to, surgeries of minors and those kinds of things. And how, and and, Joseph, feel free to push back if I misrepresent anything, but how our
4:14 many of our professional organizations that we look to, the medic, the American Medical Association, the American Psychological Association, and many others have really been, from my perspective, have been taken,
4:27 captive by an ideology first perspective that in many ways puts this ideology in front of genuine, science. And then there's, like, this shoehorning effect of trying to make science fit
4:39 with an ideology that that that doesn't even ultimately make sense. So, again, Joseph, if I've misrepresented you there, feel free to to to clarify any of that, but thanks for coming on our program.
4:50 Thank you so much for having me. I'm really excited to be here. And for the record, I may not be a, a true believer, but I'm I'm interested in, theology and, kind of religious metaphysics in general. So
5:02 That's great. That's great. Well, I'm glad you're here, and I'm glad you're speaking from the perspective, that you are. So in opening up, the conversation, the discussion, you know, I've shared a little bit for
5:13 myself, and I mentioned it, I think, even in the video that I sent over to for the purpose of this panel discussion, before the United Nations committee. And, and 1 of the things I talked about
5:25 is when I was a teen, an early teen, there there was a good maybe year and a half, 2 years where and I think even prior to that, I had some of these feelings, but I just felt like it didn't make sense that I was even in
5:37 this body. Like, somehow, everything about me seemed to relate better to girls. It seemed to, I I didn't feel comfortable with boys or I was oftentimes bullied and picked on, and and it didn't fit in with most,
5:49 most boys. There was a very narrow narrow caricature of what it looked like to be a boy or a girl in many ways. And and so I certainly experienced that. And for a long for, again, a good year and a half, maybe 2,
6:01 I distinctly felt like this is all this is all wrong. If I could go back, if I could somehow have been made a girl, god must have screwed something up. And and so that that was something that I wrestled with. Of course,
6:12 I never told anybody about that kind of thing. But even, doing some some cross dressing in my in my bedroom away from everybody, those kinds of things, definitely engaged in some of that.
6:24 And I look back on that now, and I think, oh, there was profound confusion going on in my mind about who I was and what it meant to be a boy. And and, of course, that was being reinforced by a lot of things out here
6:34 coming at me. But when I think about that, I think about friends like Chloe Cole and, you know, many others I've actually interviewed, Ted Haley and many others on this podcast. The the way that,
6:46 culture right now and and I feel like the brakes have been tapped a little bit, but I feel like the way that we've been moving is this creating this idea of fluidity around,
6:59 gender and this idea that that there's all kinds of different genders. And it's already hard being, a kid moving into adulthood, going through puberty and the entire process. That is not easy at
7:10 all for a lot of different reasons. But now we live in a culture that is removing even this the most basic scientific boundaries of, well, maybe you're not even a girl. Maybe you're not even a boy. And and and we're just
7:22 widening this these opportunities for kids to have all kinds of confusion and to believe that if I go through social transition, chemical transition, and maybe, a surgical
7:34 transition, that it's going to solve all of these feelings of unrest and disturbance. And so I think it's a really awful thing that we're setting children up for in general. But I I would just love for you to
7:46 comment either on what I'm sharing there or just, kind of launch, our audience and understanding more about who you are and how you got interested even in these topics.
7:55 Well, I would say, 1 thing I would say that you're what you're getting at too is, I think, the evolution of I know you've talked about this before, but the kind of competing
8:07 ways that we can kind of think about gender distress or sex distress. And, and then you have so you have, like, historically, this, like, gender dysphoria paradigm. Right? And then you
8:19 have what I what you what some people would call the the gender diversity paradigm or, WPATH uses the language of gender incongruence. And so what's going on here
8:31 is essentially in the name of destigmatizing and depathologizing sex distress, they created a new category that is essentially only defined
8:42 in relation to stereotypes, but then it it then actually removes distress as the key feature. So now the only thing that makes you transgender per se is that identity claim.
8:54 Right? The the distress is not is no longer key, but then you have this sort of this tension or paradox where if that's the case, so this is non pathological, and the distress is
9:06 not inherent to this this this way of being, then how can this also be simultaneously lifesaving or medically necessary care? And that's that's kind of a attention I've I've been fascinated by since I started
9:18 working on this. And I actually just wrote an article for, the dispatch on WPATH's standards of care, and I focused it on this point because I think it gets at the attention
9:30 between doing kind of robust psychological assessment and differential diagnosis and then affirming the identity. Because if the claim is that these identities are immutable and natural
9:41 and there's people are generally right about they know who they are, so to speak, as the language activist says, you know, kids these trans kids know who they are. If that's the case,
9:53 then there's a lot less incentive to do this kind of other, psychological screening. Because in the end, you're thinking, okay. They like, these these conditions are not causally
10:05 driving their experience, so they're secondary. And then so the idea is that you can you can kind of just engage in affirming interventions, and then the the the psychological comorbidities will kind of melt away
10:17 by addressing the the gender, first and foremost. Of course, data shows that generally speaking, psychiatric utilization is still pretty high even after,
10:29 affirming care interventions or sex reassignment. So that's kind of an interesting, an interesting point that, that it is as far as we know, and there's limited data on this, but that, these procedures don't
10:41 kind of provide that cure all that a lot of people think they do.
10:45 Yes. Which in the end, if you're expecting this to be some kind of cure all. And I remember there's a gal on on, social media that has recorded a few different takes. I mean,
10:57 maybe many now over the years, and she talked about how for her the goalpost kept moving. She would some the she would establish something that felt like I'm gonna become a a man or more of a man if I do this.
11:09 And the idea of it and the moving toward it was very it was something that that heightened her emotions, and it was kind of euphoric for a while. But as she moved
11:20 closer to it, and then as she achieved it, it the the goal post moved again. And every time, it would it would happen, and she just talked about that in a few weeks ago.
11:29 Of, Sarah Mittermeier, she goes by she had a
11:33 I'm not.
11:34 She used to write under under a pen name, Eliza Mondreen. But she writes about, sort of online trans communities, and she's doc she's written about this phenomena before where in some
11:45 cases, you actually have people that are not dysphoric to start. They start with trans identification, and then they become dysphoric. Basically, through this process where they start at
11:58 things that they wouldn't have fixated on previously now become increasingly psychologically salient. And so then you're trying, and then it's like, okay. Now it's like but my hands aren't masculine or feminine
12:10 enough, or I'm have hair where I don't it just becomes like, as soon as you reconcile yourself with 1 part of your physical self, it's like you're now dissatisfied with another part of your physical self. And so it
12:21 actually kind of I think people have described it online as almost like, transgender OCD is how people phrase it, where they become, like Yes. Very preoccupied with, their secondary sex characteristics. And then
12:33 I think there's always this burden of which I think is really sad, and and I must I imagine is very stressful of, of just constantly feeling like, do I pass? How are people reading me? Do I
12:45 am I perceived the way I wanna be perceived? Or and then worrying about, like, misgendering or, like, just wanting to be seen a certain way and then constantly kind of doubting whether you're actually seen that way, I
12:57 think, is just puts a tremendous amount of, like, psychological stress on a group of people that I think are already, pretty stressed out, I would say.
13:05 Yes. Yeah. I think that is a that's a huge point. And what really grieves me the more I think about this and with some of the friends that I have that are detransitioners is, again, they believed that. And
13:17 I can understand how a young person could feel like I have all of this all this pain, all this junk, all this stuff going on inside of me. I don't even know what it's all connected to. Sometimes it's connected to abuse
13:29 situations or rejection, abandonment, a variety of things, but there's all this emotional stuff that's going on within them. And some of it is very connected to very real things. Some of it, you know, our perception
13:39 feels like everything to the individual, to me, to you. Our perception feels true. And and so when we perceive these things and then they're reinforced in society as being bedrock truth, and a and a and a young
13:51 person starts to think that if I just go through with this process, I I it's all gonna be better. It's all gonna be it's a concrete way of resolving these issues, and they start down this pathway through social
14:02 transition and then, maybe very shortly chemical transition of some kind or another, whether that's puberty blockers, cross sex hormones, and then and then go into and those things alone, just
14:14 the the cross sex hormones and puberty blockers are, they have they have major side effects and which you could speak to, I'm sure, but then then surgery. And you get these people who the that are down this
14:26 road, double mastectomies or, other other medical interventions that have gone on And eventually realizing, I don't know that I'm ever gonna get to where I thought I could be, but I can never go back to who I once
14:38 was either, at least at least in terms of what I've, you know, what I've done or what I've allowed other people to do to me. And I just think that is such a horrific place to to lead people to. It just to me
14:50 makes so much more sense that you would deal with the dysphoria or the, the issues that are going on within the the mental, the mental health issue within that person, maybe
15:01 issues, and and bring them to a place of congruence with their bodies because they can never become the other gender. That's a that's a pipe dream.
15:10 Yeah. You're making a lot of you're raising a lot of interesting points. And I think part of that, I I've noticed something where there's a lot of sort of ideological assumptions built into even, like, the
15:22 clinical framing of this kind of problem. Like, 1 thing that often comes up frequently is this concept of, minority stress theory. I don't know if you're familiar. The it's a it's a basically it's a it's
15:34 a model that basically just tries to explain why, there are potentially elevated rates of, psychiatric issues among minority populations. And there's a Yes. A sort of a
15:46 version of this that is trans specific. And the idea is basically, like, in order the the the truth is is that there are elevated rates of psych of psychiatric issues in this population. So to
15:58 explain it, they're like, what's going on here? In this depathologized gender incongruence gender diversity paradigm, you you can't kind of have there's a tension here being like, this is not
16:10 pathological, but then, like, why are these people why are they suffering? What's going on here? So the explanation that's often positive is that it's due to societal stigma, discrimination, prejudice,
16:21 etcetera, which ignores that for a lot of this population, their trans identity, they were suffering with psychiatric issues before they were trans identified in a lot of
16:33 cases. And I think Yep. You talked about how powerful perception is. And I I've written about this before because I think that, what's going on here is partly, a perceptual
16:46 issue fueled by the kind of affective and cognitive processes often associated with mental health issues, including, like, rejection sensitivity, which you're
16:58 hypersensitive to, perceives perceived, rejection, abandonment, and this is tends to be correlated with a lot of psychiatric issues. But you can
17:10 a lot of, trans identified people and kids often have we've seen this in some data, often have real experiences of of ostracization or bullying as kids even but not even
17:22 related to gender identity. These are kids that tend to be Right. Tend to be have social and peer challenges even prior to that. And so I think what you're getting is you have these kind of perceptual problems,
17:34 which are then fueled by the the kind of culture at large always telling you, like, this policy in this state that just says, hey. This medical practice doesn't work for this particular treatment is
17:45 inherently discriminatory, and they want to erase you from the face of the earth. Obviously, to a a population that's really sensitive to this kind of perceived rejection, this kind of messaging also, I think, amplifies
17:57 a lot of, this, this this catastrophic thinking that some people, I think, are already inclined to do. Mhmm. At least that's something I've I've I've thought quite a bit about. So
18:09 Yeah. I I I agree. And I think also just in the when you're talking there, Joseph, I you bring up a point in my mind about the the the various bans that have, been
18:21 placed on mental health counseling for minors. And, in in in Canada, of course, there's a complete ban, whether you're a minor or an adult. You know, counselors, really no 1 is
18:33 allowed to, to walk with somebody if they if if they come to a pastor or they come to a a mental health counselor and say, you know, I'm experiencing gender dysphoria, and and I'm I'm
18:45 I'm not comfortable with trying to become the other sex. I don't believe that's possible or it doesn't align with my spiritual beliefs or whatever. And and yet I'm experiencing these things. And I'm wondering, would you
18:56 pray with me? Would you help me from a mental health perspective to a licensed counselor or whatever? It is illegal in Canada to do that for anyone, whether
19:03 it's a minor or an adult. Alberta Alberta might be the 1 exception, as far as I'm
19:08 Okay.
19:09 But, yeah, Canada is pretty, all in on, a lot of this.
19:14 Okay. But here we have in our country many states, and and and this is actually a question now before the Supreme Court. Right? There are many states that have banned therapy for minors, and and here's my
19:26 point in saying that. Actually, I'd love your comments on this. It's interesting how so much of this is cast as the compassionate approach. It's cast as, oh, we're going to make other any
19:38 anything but so called gender affirming care, whether that's, surgical, chemical, or or mental health. We're going to make all of that illegal, And and we're
19:50 just going to, affirm what you believe to be true about yourself or what you want to be true about yourself. And somehow and it's easy to understand how that's cast as compassionate. But when then when you look at all
20:00 these countless numbers of detransitioners that are now like, what in the world was I did I do to myself? Why was this even something I could do to myself? At at a certain age, the
20:12 ability to make con informed consent is impossible at at a certain age. And so, you know, what in the world have we done? And I think that, I'd just love your thoughts on that
20:24 perspective of how do we how do we how do we get into the kind of the mess that we're in right now, And and what are some pathways forward, I guess, in terms of dialing this
20:35 back and and helping people really process through the gender dysphoria or the other mental health issues that are going on?
20:42 I think I mean, my intuition would be that adopting a treatment that has a more favorable, risk benefit profile, even though there's you
20:54 know, it's true that there's not great high quality evidence, for example, about psychotherapy for the treatment of gender distress, but psychotherapy has a much more favorable
21:06 risk benefit profile. There's no irreversible intervention here. And psychotherapy historically is good at treating a lot of the comorbid mental health conditions that are often associated with
21:18 sex distress. Mhmm. But to your other point, I think that the the main problem with the affirmation only approach is that it's not developmentally sound, and it act it tips the scales in favor of a
Affirmation vs. Evidence-Based Care
21:30 particular outcome when psychologists are in theories, right, supposed to be not pushing this not tipping the scales in either direction. And it's not a very it's
21:40 not a very self determination.
21:42 Yeah. And there's not a very it's not a very developmentally sound approach to to treat, like, anyone who knows anything about, like, child or adolescent psychology, for example, is not gonna be
21:54 sort of, like, in the business of, like, crystallizing an identity early in development. And and then you get into the the issue with historically how a lot of trans identified youth
22:05 are same sex attracted with then then you get into this issue of, like, is affirmation therapy actually people have made this point before? Is this actually, ironically, an another
22:17 form of gay conversion therapy, which is kind of, like, an interesting way to rethink it because this is framed as the compassionate approach. But you could actually argue that this is kind of in the in the
22:29 name of being compassionate, they're skipping steps to the point where they're actually harming, a very vulnerable population that they purport to care about. And so I think it's more about not
22:41 being, developmentally sound or informed than being kind of cavalier with, with, with the risk.
22:49 Mhmm.
22:49 And to get to your point about should we talk a little bit more about how we got here medically? How our medic how our medical associations
22:55 Yes, please.
22:56 So for, yeah, for for listeners, I'm sure a lot of people here are probably familiar with the idea that, generally speaking, the the US medical establishment,
23:08 is pretty all in on gender affirming care for the most part. There's often a common refrain that all major medical associations, endorse these practices. And that's generally speaking,
23:21 true, especially until recently. But what the average person probably may not know is that in a lot of ways, this consensus was, both artificially constructed
23:33 and also not based on the highest quality evidence in what's known as evidence based medicine, which is kind of a field that evaluates, the quality of evidence available and
23:45 then, tries to make recommendations that have the most, you know, favorable, risk benefit ratios after kind of assessing what do we actually know about the about the interventions. So,
23:58 a couple of and you know what? My it's worth saying about this too. The original Dutch protocol that pioneered, gender medicine, has the 2 2, 2 studies that
24:10 came out of the Netherlands. They've never been the Dutch protocol has never been replicated. The UK tried to replicate this, and they they were not able to do it. The study itself had a lot of, methodological
24:22 issues. There's a great article I recommend people read called the myth of, reliable research in pediatric gender medicine that goes over a lot of these controversies and just goes over the the problems with, why
24:34 these studies, weren't, you know, robust from an evidence standpoint from the get go. And, actually, pediatric medical interventions were in part conceptualized because adults had such poor
24:45 psychological outcomes. So the idea was if we intervene earlier, maybe the outcomes will be better be based on the assumption that well-being is is all kind of determined based on how well
24:57 your appearance and your gender identity match this idea of appearance congruence, it's called. However, the the actual practice was was done in what's called an innovative practice
25:09 framework, which is more experimental and is not essentially, is for a small population. It was not meant to be scaled up without these kind of robust,
25:21 clinical trials or whatever that were essentially never done. And then this practice was kind of scaled up around the world despite, you know, a a quite a small, quite a small sample.
25:33 But then going back to the consensus in the United States, the US Endocrine Society, the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, and the American Academy of Pediatrics, I think,
25:45 are the the big 3 organizations that kind of came out endorsing these practices. And what many people may not realize is that, these position statements put out by these organizations
25:57 or, clinical practice guidelines in some cases are often not actually looking at the evidence directly or weighing the strength of the evidence in the way that, like, a European style,
26:10 evidence review in countries like the UK, Sweden, and Finland have done, where the health care bodies there actually commissioned evidence reviews, looked at the overall risk benefit, ratio, and said, hey. You know
26:22 what? The, the evidence for harms is is fairly considerable, and the evidence for benefits is weak. So based on that kind of risk benefit calculus, more
26:34 cautious approaches should be the default approach. And, again, these are based on evidence reviews in the United States. The US Endocrine Society's, guidelines endorsing pediatric general
26:45 medicine were based on, studies of adults, not based on studies of children. The American Academy of Pediatrics position statement famously was written by a single pediatrician, doctor
26:57 Jason Rafferty, and it was also not based on evidence reviews. And then, WPATH, most famously, commissioned actually commissioned evidence reviews
27:09 by researchers at Johns Hopkins and then actually suppressed the evidence reviews because the they, like all the other systematic reviews that have been done in this area, only found low certainty
27:21 evidence. And so we know that from, litigation in the case of Beau v Marshall in Alabama. So this came out through discovery. And,
27:33 yeah, I think that the average person kind of assumes that medical associations are only endorsing practices based on the highest quality science. And oftentimes, when these organizations say things like the practice is
27:44 evidence based, they're not using evidence based in this sense of evidence based medicine. They're using it in this more kind of casual sense of, like, it's been part of a research study regardless of whether or
27:56 not that particular study, is reliable or high quality.
28:02 Okay. Wow. So what you're saying there with, WPATH, for example, that that they had commissioned, research, but then suppressed the
28:14 results because it didn't it didn't prove to be, as favorable as they were looking for it to be to to bolster their their perspective or their ideology. Is
28:26 that fair?
28:27 That's correct. And, Jesse, the journalist Jesse Single actually wrote about this for The Economist, a few years ago. And, yeah. I mean, that that story has been out there for, you know, years, and it's kind of, like,
28:39 1 of those things that if you're follow this topic, you're aware of it. If you don't follow it super closely, that's it may not be, something you're aware of. But, I mean, that's a very to me, this is a very important
28:49 kind of story, right, about about the nature of of of evidence and kind of, like, how we know things and, when when I think it shows, you know, the kind of failure of the medical, the failure of the medical establishment
29:01 to kind of act in the best interest of the public and also kind of is disingenuous in the way that they frame the evidence for
29:09 the public. Okay. Well, when you're talking about risk benefit ratios, you mentioned that a few times. And and what comes to it and that that makes a lot of sense when that's based on, actual science
29:21 and and and outcomes. But when I I think about that idea of of, risk benefit ratio in terms of the language I've often heard, and I'm sure
29:33 you have too, of mental health providers or doctors that will say to parents, do you want a dead daughter or a live son? Do you want a dead son or a live daughter? I mean, to that parent, they're lighting their hair on
29:44 fire thinking, oh my gosh. I mean, the so if if the result is you as the professional are saying, this is the likely outcome death of my child. And so that's a risk I'm not willing to take, and so I'll do
29:56 anything to to avoid that. And so, yes, let's go down this road that you're recommending. I mean, that just seems unbelievably egregious to me, and I would love if if there's if there's any data
30:08 that you're aware of, Joseph, around, the the the fallacy, of course, there are those who have committed suicide, that are dealing with gender dysphoria and these these kinds of things. But but is that
30:20 statement is that the kind of thing that that counselors and and medical personnel should be putting out to parents as if as if those are the only 2 alternatives?
30:28 No. And I think this has been a kind of a point of, a talking point and, you know, a huge debate about the the suicide claim because it's often used as kind of,
30:41 it's often, you know, kind of something that that that hangs over parents' heads when they're when they're making decisions for their kids. And, I mean, the there's no good evidence
30:53 that, you know, not receiving affirming care leads to to suicide. There's elevate there are elevated rates of suicidality associated,
31:05 with trans identities and gender dysphoria, which is separate than completed suicide. So suicidality is suicidal ideation or thinking about suicide. My understanding of this, generally speaking, is
31:17 that this is often more associated with the comorbidities that are often that often plague this population. So there was a study from the Netherlands that looked at all cause suicide
31:29 mortality, and they found that when you actually control for these comorbidities, they're what predict, suicide outcomes, not gender dysphoria. And there's often, you know, it's often framed
31:41 that there's, like, that there's, like, that there'll be, like, a rope there's gonna be a suicide epidemic if we if we stop kids from from medically transitioning. But, again, there's no,
31:54 there's no good evidence that that that's the case. And it most of the time, this conflates suicide and suicidality. And, famously, during, Scormetti oral arguments, Chase Strangio,
32:06 the lawyer representing the ACLU conceded that completed suicides are rare in this population and that, you know, kind of retreated to the the suicidality instead of the suicide argument.
32:19 So I think that's a huge point of, Mhmm. It's a huge misunderstanding in this area, and I think also so oftentimes, the the advice is often we need to be better at addressing psychiatric comorbidities
32:31 in this population to prevent to prevent suicidality and suicide as opposed to, you know, rendering affirming care practices. Your other point, though, I think gets at
32:44 a really you you used the word egregious, which I think is appropriate for because you have this incredibly manipulative, tactic from an informed consent standpoint. Right? And this actually was a talking point
32:56 in, the, are you familiar with the the Fox variant detransitioner case from New York? Yeah. So this was a It was not in all
33:07 the details, but vaguely. Yeah.
33:08 This was a talking point in in in her case as well where apparently, there are psychologists. And this there was a lot of vile there was a lot of just egregious violations of the standard of care in this case, but, that
33:20 there the psychologist told the mom allegedly that, her daughter would kill herself if she wouldn't transition. And, of course, that's not true. And so from an from a from an
33:32 informed consent standpoint, it's even more, problematic because you're making a decision under false pretenses and under false information. So all the pro most people point out simply the
33:44 fact that based on their immaturity, minors can't cognitively even though they're assenting because parents are the key decision makers for gender medicine, even though they're assenting, there's still you know,
33:56 there's a larger issue of when the information being shared with families isn't accurate, that's also an informed consent problem. Right? Because if you're making these decisions under under duress, thinking that, you
34:07 know, your your child is gonna kill themselves be if they're not given these these interventions, you know, that's an incredibly manipulative tactic to use, especially if, and I'm sure a lot of
34:19 I'm sure a lot of those those physicians probably believe what they're told. Like, that that talking point has been out there so much that I and it's repeated by civil rights organizations,
34:31 medical associations. So I don't blame, you know, parents for hearing that and thinking that there's merit to the claim, but it's it's on medical providers who are supposed to
34:43 be the experts on these issues, I think, to make sure that what they're the information they're sharing is true.Show more
Comments
Keep it kind. Comments are public.