Skip to content 167: When Affirmation Becomes a False Form of Mercy | Andrew Comiskey & Garry Ingraham Jun 9 · 1 hr 4 min ...more
167: When Affirmation Becomes a False Form of Mercy | Andrew Comiskey & Garry Ingraham
June 9, 2026 · 1 hr 4 min
Andrew Comiskey, founder of Desert Stream and Living Waters, joins us to share his journey with same-sex attraction before coming to Christ, how he entered full-time Christian service, and how, with his wife's help, he started a ministry that has lasted more than 40 years. Andrew and Garry also discuss the world’s view versus the church’s view on same-sex attraction and sexual brokenness.
Series Love & Truth Network - Audio Edition June 9, 2026 · 1 hr 4 min · Love & Truth Network - Audio Edition
Andrew Comiskey, founder of Desert Stream and Living Waters, joins us to share his journey with same-sex attraction before coming to Christ, how he entered full-time Christian service, and how, with his wife's help, he started a ministry that has lasted more than 40 years. Andrew and Garry also discuss the world’s view versus the church’s view on same-sex attraction and sexual brokenness. ...more Show the full description Show less Andrew Comiskey, founder of Desert Stream and Living Waters, joins us to share his journey with same-sex attraction before coming to Christ, how he entered full-time Christian service, and how, with his wife's help, he started a ministry that has lasted more than 40 years. Andrew and Garry also discuss the world’s view versus the church’s view on same-sex attraction and sexual brokenness.
Series Love & Truth Network - Audio Edition Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Support this leader
Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Give
Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
49.1K followers
Love & Truth Network equips pastors and local churches to restore relational & sexual wholeness and biblical identity. We accomplish this through our resources,
49.1K followers
In this video 0:00 From Gay Life to Christian Awakening11:00 Healing Wounds and Building Ministry22:00 Rejecting Labels, Embracing Transformation33:00 Marriage and Family as Overflow of Healing40:00 Resources and Call to Wholeness
From Gay Life to Christian Awakening 0:00 What I find so self sabotaging in the kind of pro rainbow Christian world that's sort of now sort of0:12 seeking conservative wear, if you will. I would say it's such a thin understanding of human sexuality in owning0:24 one's homosexuality as a as an unchanging condition. This is a fixed state. This is me. It's buying into what I would see to be an0:36 old school understanding of homosexuality.0:39 Too many times, I think, even in Christian marriages, we are looking for someone to complete us. We're looking for someone to, to fix what what's aching, what's broken, what's lonely, what's empty. I almost0:51 never hear someone talk about, I love her and I wanna be in relationship to her, and I long for marriage because I have this overflow that I feel like God wants to pour out of me into the other.1:01 I think I'd rather be a minority voiced, youthful, and countercultural because I think anything that's a authentic Christian is counterculture.1:13 We need to be focused on, Lord, how can I I'm not gonna arrive at perfection this life? I for sure, sanctification is a journey, but how can I become whole enough that it opens up this overflow of a1:24 longing to pour out and bless another as opposed to take in constantly? The fact that we we get to be countercultural, and to stay faithful to that is such a beautiful thing.1:30
1:40 Welcome to the Love and Truth Network podcast, your guide for hope and healing in a hurting world searching for truth. Here, we explore God's extraordinary design for biblical sexuality, identity, and authentic
1:51 community. You'll be impacted by incredible stories of
1:54 transformation, practical wisdom from pastors and counselors, and
1:54 the power of God practical wisdom from pastors and counselors, and the power of God's grace that changes lives.
2:08 Hey, everybody. Thank you so much for joining us for another episode of the Love and Truth Network podcast. We're really excited that you're with us today. I'm excited in particular. And I know every time that I bring a
2:18 guest to you that I'm excited to have them. And that's true, of course. But this 1 is particularly, a pleasure to me. Andrew Kamisky has, been a part of my life in many, many ways.
2:30 It was at 1 of his trainings, that he was doing, a living waters training he's done for many, many, many years. But back in 2004, while I was on pastoral staff and and newly so, I went to my
2:42 very 1st training, for Living Waters, and that's where I met my wife was at that training. It's where I found a ton of freedom. It's actually it's where you kidnap
2:52 where you kidnapped your children. That was that was difficult.
2:57 Traumatic. I know. Exactly. So we won't get in all that. But now there's, there's a long history, with Andrew. But 1 of the things I wanna note in that same training, it was the 1st time
3:09 that I had ever become aware that even though I wasn't acting out in in old familiar patterns of hookups with someone or pornography or chronic masturbation or any of those kinds of things,
3:21 And I and I thought, oh, this is, like, the pinnacle of the Christian life. Like, this is what it's all about, just not doing naughty things. And I had no idea how much was still sitting inside of me in terms of wounds
3:32 and in kind of infected emotional places that were still driving. I I I kinda had a handle on the on the sexual acting out and all that kind of stuff, well, very much so. But I had no idea how many wounds were
3:44 driving me even in my pastoral care role and things like that. So, anyway, there's a long history, with us, with Andrew, and I'm just excited to have him here today. Also, I'm gonna note,
3:55 before Andrew, shares that and you might hear, a dog in the background. They have several dogs, and we are just going to, not worry about that if they, are gonna carry on.
4:06 We're
4:06 just gonna forge ahead. Yes. Yes. Anyway, Andrew, thank you for joining us. That was a long and kinda weird introduction, but yes. No.
4:13 Actually, Gary, that is a exceedingly important introduction. I mean, as far as a take on, what are we trying to get at here in
4:25 sexual identity issues? You know, And I I appreciate that. And I I very much remember your entry into the Living Waters world because
4:37 I think you were with a few people, were you not? Your your church was a significant church in upstate New York. This wasn't it Presbyterian? It was it was it a Presbyterian?
4:49 It was more of a nondenominational church. But when I came in, I'm I was there on the, East Coast training in 2004. And then for the next training, I I dragged along 5 other of,
5:01 the senior pastor, missions pastor, worship pastor, and some other people, to join me for the training on the West Coast, later in 2005. So yeah. So, Andrew, I would love for you just
5:13 to share with our audience, some of your story, and I know you told it lots of times, but, I get sick of hearing myself tell my own story sometimes, but I would love to. No.
5:22 I get sick of it too, Gary. You know, it's weird because I get sick of hearing you too. Yes. I don't know that you're gonna come out of your mind. I love to hear mine.
5:35 Yes.
5:35 No. Sure. No. I'd be so happy to, Gary. So I was a Southern California guy and, got into homosexuality quite early, you
5:47 know, way too much exposure in a beach town in Southern California and, you know, had homosexual feelings based on some family of origin stuff
5:59 and, you know, just kind of thought, well, these are my feelings and I gotta do my life. And there wasn't I mean, there was all the bullying and all that, but when it came to making
6:11 some decisions as far as gay identification in high school, acting out with other guys, going up to LA and doing the club scene and all that, I felt kind of
6:22 free to do that in a way, but it also was dehumanizing. And that was evident. You know? Even as a, someone at this point
6:34 driving, obviously, a little bit later high school, I was aware, like, this is the center can't hold here because there kinda is no center. You know,
6:46 it's sensational, but it's, disintegrating, I guess, is how I would define it, really, how I felt it then, though maybe I didn't have the words. But,
6:58 anyway, my 2 older brothers, whom I didn't really care for very much, I was sort of alienated from the masculine and from these 2 older guys, and my father, not
7:10 much of a relationship there. But my 2 older brothers became Christians in the kind of Jesus people, Jesus revolution mode, you know, late sixties,
7:22 early to mid seventies. And, they had become Christians. And when they became Christians, they became very kind. So these guys who were more inclined to being surly
7:34 and bullying and kind of normal demonized to guys, you know? Yeah. I mean, I was demonized in my own way, so I I wasn't the virgin demon. You
7:46 know? But they were just different. And, but conversion to Jesus made them very kind and very concerned about me not throwing the
7:58 bible, not why are you a sodomite, but more are you okay? Like, you're changing, and we're concerned. So this compassionate
8:10 concern was to me the best good news that I could discern. You know? They didn't have to throw me bible verses. It was more, wow. Jesus somebody, this
8:22 Jesus is changing my brothers and making them caring. So Wow. That invited me to consider, yeah, I need something. I need this
8:34 Jesus. My life is not going anywhere well, and I I need help. And it's so deep. You know? Sexual stuff is so deep.
8:47 I knew that it had to involve something unseen and powerful and good. And, you know, that's that's Jesus.
8:59 And so I became a Christian, you know, kinda simply. I was in college at UCLA University, and I thought I just really need
9:11 discover this Jesus. And through the prayers of these this wonderful young adult movement, you know, and, you know, people that were a little near into my family and myself,
9:23 there was good intercession, and there there was a new kingdom that I became a citizen of. And I thought, I wanna be part of this even though it was so hard. Of course, it's so
9:35 hard. You know? You don't really know anybody, and you're sexually addicted, and, you know, your sexuality is so powerful.
9:46 And, Andrew, I remember you saying years and years ago about this phase of your life that it wasn't like the church was running towards you with open arms.
9:54 Yeah. Yeah. I I mean, they were, like, kind of I mean, not indifferent. I'd say loving, but you're kind of not really knowing what to do with
10:06 me. Exactly. And but thank God, you know, and that's the advantage of Southern California culture. It's kind of a dare to be different culture. It really is not a button down, be
10:18 really conservative and just act like everything's okay. It's it's more of a be who you are. Of course, in this Christian culture, it was become
10:29 like Jesus or, you know, I mean, it was kind of a bunch of dumb clucks trying to figure it out, honestly. But they love Jesus, and I think he honored their faith and
10:41 a kind of compassion and inclusivity. And I think that made a difference for me. But I guess kind of in the end,
10:54 I had to determine to find the narrow way. And Yes. You know, by the grace of god, I did. And, I I got involved with a a a
Healing Wounds and Building Ministry
11:06 Christian it was a fraternity, a conservative fraternity the UCLA campus of really good guys. I mean, very different from me culturally, but
11:19 really, like, eyes of integrity, kind of more Baptist, you know, and love the bible and and doing the right thing. And I kinda needed
11:31 a little bit of a conservative element in my life because I was I was I was a little bit out there on the lunatic fringe, not just morally,
11:42 but attitudinally, politically, kind of everything. And so I needed to be grounded, and these guys were very grounding. And that was kind of the base
11:54 on which I could start sorting out what's really going on. And, you know, kinda like you said early on, you can overcome destructive behaviors that are clearly
12:06 non biblical behaviors, and they're wrong because they're hurtful. They disfigure you. You know? And all of my friends at this point were dying of HIV, and,
12:18 you know, it was very difficult time in the culture and and, wow, lot going on there. But once I overcame
12:30 the felonies, you know, I could begin to look at what's going on. You know? What is happening in my heart, and what do these intensive same
12:42 sex affections mean? And and how do I find healing? I was in this great house, and there was a guy in the house, not not all the guys by any means, but there was 1 who was very kind and very nice looking
12:54 guy. And though, you know, we're all in this together, 4 or 5 guys in a bedroom, it's it was kind of, you know, like boot camp sort of your it's not this was not high
13:06 living. But there was 1 guy that, you know, was attracted to me. And because he was kind and friendly and present, you know, it was sort of like, wow. What's
13:18 going on with my heart? And, you know, and that was really a good thing because it was like, yeah, you can't run away from your heart. You know? You can't run away from your affections and,
13:30 you know, in in unguarded moments, how you feel about certain guys and so on. And this was an, an
13:41 invitation, you know, to go to therapy, you know, not so much deliverance, you know, that's kind of the go to. He needed deliverance. He needed 7 really powerful
13:53 people to ask this out of him. You know, I mean, I I am sure I had a lot of unclean spirits. Gary, you know that I did. Gary encountered some of my
14:05 demons, at different points and types. But, no, really, it wasn't so much that. It was really a profound psychological thing that was indicative of what I had not worked
14:16 out in my life. It was it was a disintegration. And so I was in a neat church. The Vineyard church had just started, actually, in West LA, which had
14:28 been kind of a plant from Calvary Chapel, of all things, in Costa Mesa with Chuck Smith. But the pastor Ken Gullickson, who was in charge of pastoral care, very healing and
14:40 sharp man, wanted, you know, kind of a more come holy spirit, but also psychologically insightful, a storyally thoughtful approach
14:52 to people and discipleship, and which is so sweet. I mean, could there be a better combination, like, loving Jesus, like, come like, let's not put a limit on what the Holy
15:04 Spirit can do. Hello. But also, let's deal with the human person and what's what what's going on with him or her, and don't just judge the symptoms.
15:16 You know? You know, try to get down to what's really going on at core, which doesn't mean we we always know what that is. But in this case, I was with a really good
15:28 trained therapist who was a Christian, going to the supportive, wonderful, you know, come as you are, bring everything to the
15:39 cross, let Jesus and his friends help help you. And I got better, and I got through this relationship. And I realized I'm not really in love with this guy. I'm just
15:51 I'm just working out friendship and solidarity with other guys. And on that basis, I began to have, you know, some feelings for women
16:03 wanting to kinda move on with my life. You know? That's to me, that's the best biblical witness is the Imago Dei. Humanity made in his images, male and female, and that's not just, you know,
16:16 Adam and Eve, not Adam and Steve and some stupid, trivial thing. It really means I was made for woman. That's what it means. God made me in his image, so he knows
16:28 what he's doing. He knows what's maybe dormant and undeveloped, but he's always gonna take me there. And I thought, I need to get on with my life, you know, and not
16:40 just be mucking around with, you know, uneasy feelings towards guys. I need to get on with exercising my masculinity. And so I met, you know, I dated a few women. I was
16:51 a real player, Gary. I was amazing. I I was dazzling. I mean, I had to get married, lest I confuse Yeah.
17:02 I know. I understand why you like telling your story, Andrew.
17:04 Yeah. I mean, Gary what can I say? Anyway, I did find a woman who wouldn't put up with me and, you know, and and but no, really. The woman who became
17:16 my wife, Annette, and around that time, I was just finishing at UCLA, but my pastors, they were so great. They said, why don't you start helping people? People need help. People are coming into this church. The church
17:28 was in revival. It'd gone from, like, 200 people. Long story came yeah. Started big. You know? A lot of people interested at 1st, but then it went to, like, 1000,
17:41 then 1500 in, like, a year and a half. So lot of people coming to the lord, lot of people needing help. And so Annette Annette was game. She was
17:53 like, okay. Yeah. She she had her own problems and was finding help through this community. And together, it was like, we can help people a little bit. You know? Leanne
18:04 Payne had just written broken image. This is, like, late seventies, just about 80 now. And the broken image was such a beautiful,
18:16 thoughtful book on how Jesus restores, you know, the broken image in people and and and looking at all the misunderstanding
18:28 of homosexuality in the greater American culture and how it was dividing all the Protestant denominations in that time. You know, Lutheran, Presbyterian, Episcopalian,
18:40 United Church of Christ, Methodist, Gary, Methodist, Methodist, Methodist, you know, all of it. And she said, we don't understand what homosexuality is, and that
18:52 Jesus actually offers a clear and true way or reintegration. You know? And so, anyway, broken image was
19:04 key. Being part of the Vineyard Movement, I started going to Fuller Seminary at that time. Annette and I got married, started our family. Desert Stream Ministries began in 19
19:16 80. And, and then, as a result of just working with people continually in small group settings, we started Living Waters, which was, you know,
19:27 prophetically, of course, for people wanting to come out of homosexuality, but most of the people in our church were just, you know, opposite sex offenders. You know?
19:39 Right. Damaged, unintentionally offensive, maybe, men with women and women with men that needed help to kind of
19:52 make peace with the good of their sexuality and, you know, learn how to be a better gift to others. And so that was how Living Waters began, Gary,
20:04 and we just developed it. I hope it got better. I think it did get it certainly Yes. Became more thoughtful and, as we grew and were trained in various ways.
20:16 And, yeah. So there you go, Gary. You know? I'm I'm just kinda doing the same thing. I wish I could say I have new information
20:28 for you, buddy. But, you know, I mean, I love to do what we do because it's so necessary and and is cross denominational, certainly applies to all
20:40 expressions of Christian faith. And our goal is to equip laypeople who are working responsibly in their communities with you know, in conjunction with elders
20:52 and pastors and people who want them to be doing it so that we're tapping into the authority Jesus gives his church to to
21:04 hasten our conversion at whatever level. In our case, it's it's at the level of of becoming truer in our manhood and womanhood
21:15 and working that out, you know, in in the community and certainly beyond in the world. So, yeah, so that's that's what I we're still doing
21:27 here, Gary. As you know, I'm in Kansas City, not in LA anymore. I'm now a Catholic. I'm not a a part of the vineyard anymore, though I that those
21:39 are my roots. I love the vineyard, but I love being Catholic, and I love that perspective on imparting people who have different different ideas about
21:51 worship, but who really love Jesus and who wanna be faithful to him and don't know how to do it unless the church actually offers
Rejecting Labels, Embracing Transformation
22:04 a winsome, truthful, faith way forward for them to come out and say, yeah. I'm gonna I'm gonna entrust this to people I worship with,
22:16 and try to take steps towards wholeness in my faith community. And, I mean, we gotta. You know? I
22:28 don't think we should have to commute too far to get the help we need because we need it, and we need to integrate it, you know, where we worship and or those sort of
22:40 things.
22:41 Love about Living Waters and the work that you've done, Andrew, is that it's it really is about, the church. Each church, that it's about the local church whether and and, of course,
22:53 Living Waters is not just here in the United States. It's international. It's a lot of different countries. And
22:58 Yeah.
22:59 And the we've seen over and over and over again that Sure. Literally, there have been thousands upon thousands of people that have been, impacted by, living waters
23:11 over the these last, whatever it is, 44, 45 years. I mean, it's it's been a long
23:15 time. 46. Yeah.
23:17 Yeah. It's incredible. So Yeah. And and 1 of the things about that longevity is it really speaks to the the depth of, obviously, of consistency and and a faithfulness
23:29 and the fact that God is is doing great things through Mhmm. Living waters. I mean, I can't even imagine where I would be, hopefully, you know, still still living, you know, faithfully, not going back to where I once
23:41 was. But I know that I would have been living a very truncated, a kind of not so much maybe rules based, but I would have been I would
23:53 have been doing a lot of things right on the outside or trying desperately to do that.
23:57 Yeah. And yet there would have been
23:58 a lot of unhealed places on the inside. And so Living Waters has been profoundly impactful. And, also, I think a lot of people kind of the origins of Living Waters was certainly speaking to the topics
24:10 that I've come out of, you've come out of in terms of the LGBT world. But the vast majority of people that are now a part of Living Waters, are are Justin, you you referenced this earlier a little bit, but I just wanna
24:22 highlight this. It's it's for people that are dealing with kind of life dominating issues of a of a sexual nature often, but not always. But it's often heterosexual, brokenness Yep. And not just
24:34 LGBT. I think that's the greater number of people.
24:37 Right. Right. Yeah. No. We I would say probably 30 to 35 percent SSA, so higher than the average in the population. But
24:49 but so I find it much healthier for everyone to kind of drop the labels. Labels are labels, plastic
25:01 sexual labels are rarely my friends. Yeah. They never serve me well. You know? They're not real. They're fair weather at best. You know? And, so
25:13 I I prefer just to see we're all human beings made in God's image, and we all have different frustrations in walking that out. And the the the
25:25 more ironclad our labels, other than being beloved sons and daughters of the father, you know, good enough expressions of
25:37 male and female made in his image, You know, I mean, you can't say that to everyone every time you introduce yourself or something. Right. But I mean, Gary, I don't have
25:48 many friends, put it that way. I don't get many callbacks when we say this. But I would say it's just like you drop that. You know? You kind of just leave that
26:00 behind and say, what good does that do me? You know? Yeah. It's a is it a defense? Is it does it just reinforce my uncomfortable residual same
26:12 sex feelings? Or do I wanna kinda move on and just own what I must, but, you know, not to not to split off from it and say I don't I'm not still
26:24 dealing with stuff, but, actually, it's not central. And there's a core reality in me that has to do with
26:36 Jesus and kingdom reality and God's vision for my life that I may have only seen in part just a little bit, but that's where I'm going. Yeah.
26:48 And I'd rather I'd rather cast vision for people to come into that rather than, you know, have all all these, you know, this sort of
26:59 categorical thinking in sexual terms that seems to me seems self defeating and not very Christian, actually.
27:10 Right. Right. Well and and speaking to that, Andrew, it it immediately prompts me to think about the the different, categories of, you know, the side a, the side
27:22 b perspective.
27:23 And I would love for you
27:24 to speak to that a minute. I Yeah. Obviously, the side a, for people who don't know, would be those within this framework of what we're talking about. Side a would be those who believe in full on that god
27:36 made people gay, trans, whatever, and and that he blesses those unions. He blesses someone going and getting a attempting to get some kind of a sex change, cutting
27:48 off healthy body parts and trying to become the opposite sex or no sex or whatever sex. And and so, you know, side a has a a real per, perspective on revisionist,
27:59 theology of scripture. They've gone back and basically rewritten it to to to fit their own desires in a sense. Whereas side b is the perspective of, no, we understand the bible teaches a sexual ethic that god
28:11 created sex between 1 man and 1 woman. But in some ways, I feel like side b is actually worse than side a. And maybe worse isn't the right word, but but whereas side a is is kind of outside
28:24 many, orthodox, biblically based churches. Like, they recognize immediately. Oh, this is actually antithetical to scripture even though they call themselves Christians or whatever. They're not they're
28:35 not practicing what Christ has called us to the the body does. But side b, I think, is all is more corrosive because it actually winds up entering into the church. Like, a lot of churches welcome that perspective
28:47 in. And then because they don't realize that while they claim to have a biblical sexual ethic, their their basis of identity, which is more foundational than what we even do with our bodies, it informs what we
28:59 do in a sense. But they they live on this fault line of I'm choosing an identity that doesn't align with scripture, and I I embrace that identity, but I can't act on it. So it's this constant place of friction, and it's
29:11 often a stepping stone to side a. So I'd love for you to speak to to those 2 perspectives, Andrew.
29:18 Yeah. I mean and I I would agree with what you just said, Gary. I would also say there's so many versions of that now Yes. Which are
29:30 often for, you know, I would say, conservative tending towards being moderate evangelicals and
29:42 Catholics for that matter. You know, different flavors, maybe charismatic, maybe not, maybe, yeah, more buttoned
29:54 up Presbyterian like or, you know, whatever, beachy. All I different flavors of American, evangelicalism,
30:06 really. But I would say the the the the difficulty, as you say, is that it's deceptive. I just think it's deceptive because I think it gives the appearance of being
30:18 orthodox that because I don't believe in gay marriage. Oh, no. You know? You're agreeing with the letter of the law, if you will. No sex, please. We're unmarried.
30:30 You know? But in owning one's homosexuality as a as an unchanging condition, this
30:42 is a fixed state. This is me. It's buying into what I would see to be an old school understanding of homosexuality, You know, that this is just
30:54 how I am. This is my orientation. It's fixed. You know? If not born that way, it's so deep and impermeable,
31:06 which I just think, well, that's a lot. Those are a lot of assumptions about about homosexuality, and, and and it's passive. It's kind of a state
31:18 of no more becoming, in in my masculinity, in my femininity. You know? Historically, my longings
31:29 for men are are coming out of a deep place of of, a a kind of a void, you know, something that has not
31:41 been adequately welcomed, worked out, owned by myself, or I wouldn't be longing for a guy. I I
31:53 wouldn't I wouldn't be yearning for a a unity with him that, a, is impossible. I really can never be 1 with him the way I
32:05 can with my wife. And, b, it's it's emotionally and spiritually and psychologically frustrating, nor can I be 1 with him in those ways? You
32:17 know? Right. Like, oh, Jonathan and David are so special. Even though our genitals don't clash in the night, it's still like on yours and you're
32:28 mine. You know? The below you know? The romancing of the same sex while not, you know, while saying I won't have sex with you, but
32:40 I'll I'll I'll I'll romance you, and I'll I'll I'll make you my own affectionately. How frustrating is that? That's just not
32:52 a good idea. And I think I'm not saying everyone in that world, you know, would would do that, but there's certainly so many of those conversations thatShow more
Comments No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Comments
Keep it kind. Comments are public.