Skip to content 113: Faithful God, Part Two | Keith Boyette & Garry Ingraham Jul 31 · 55 min ...more
113: Faithful God, Part Two | Keith Boyette & Garry Ingraham
July 31, 2025 · 55 min
In part two of last week's discussion, Keith Boyette and Garry Ingraham discuss the tragic but fascinating story of the United Methodist Church.
Series Love & Truth Network Podcast - Video Edition Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Support this leader
Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Give
Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
49.1K followers
Love & Truth Network equips pastors and local churches to restore relational & sexual wholeness and biblical identity. We accomplish this through our resources,
49.1K followers
In this video 0:00 Trusting God and the Journey of Faith6:54 The Evolution and Challenges of Methodism21:21 Community, Identity, and the Call to Holiness34:32 Navigating Identity and Church Membership
Trusting God and the Journey of Faith 0:01 I have learned that if I will trust God, if I will let him take the lead, he will take care of everything.0:10 It sounds it may sound simple, but I think it's such an important thing. What's the application for us out of this scripture?0:16 If I if you're about God's work, if you're doing what God has told you to do, he is gonna make a way. He's gonna overcome the impossible barrier, and it will not be according to something you've dreamed of.0:27 When we are relationally full, it is a lot easier to say no to sin and to recognize temptation when it's coming to us than when we are emotionally starving and pretty lonely and pretty empty.0:39 Methodism, especially United Methodism, increasingly became an institution that lived for itself, not as a tool0:51 that God could use.0:53 So many people began to interpret scripture through their own experience versus allowing, coming under the design and the purposes of God and aligning themselves to that. United Methodism became1:05 it lost its sense of being under authority. It was no longer under the authority of scripture and God's word.1:12 I think it's so unhelpful when, when churches or denominations embrace this idea that, oh, you can't have sex with the same sex, but it's good and healthy for you to identify as a gay man or a lesbian woman or a trans individual.1:24
1:28 For me, it was the 20 12 general conference in Tampa. I believe the spirit of God left the United Methodist Church at
1:39 that conference.
1:41 Love rejoices does not rejoice in unrighteousness, but rejoices with the truth. When we start accommodating things that aren't actually biblically accurate, I I think we do some real damage,
1:53 to to individuals. Welcome to the Love and Truth Network podcast, your guide for hope and healing in a hurting world searching for truth. Here, we explore God's extraordinary design for biblical sexuality,
2:05 identity, and authentic community. You'll be impacted by incredible stories of transformation, practical wisdom from pastors and counselors, and the power of God's grace that changes lives.
2:21 Thanks for sharing that. I think it's just so it's so helpful. It's so important to to hear, I think, from some a seasoned person, many seasoned people, in terms of what does it
2:33 look like to, again, to be, you know, not a contemplative typically, right, and and not just somebody who's an introvert that just wants to be off by themselves in, you know, a monastery somewhere or
2:45 whatever, that that what does it look like to be someone who's driven, who's very capable, who, you know, could could easily, just kind of live in that that place of control
2:57 of of life and and kind of combine that with with their faith in some ways, but yet to come to this place of of, continual surrender of more and more and then also,
3:09 to to be sensitive to the voice of the lord. To ask it sounds it may sound simple, but I think it's such an important thing that we actually approach what you were saying. Approach the word with, lord, what do you my
3:21 boys are are always talking about what's the application for us out of the scripture. No matter where we're reading, there's there's always opportunity to gain application and and asking the lord for what that looks
3:32 like. I mean, so I mean, so Keith, you know, I've known you again for several years and I guess since, like, 20 16. So it's been longer than several. But, how how would you
3:43 say, like, I'm assuming you're not looking back with regrets that you said yes to the Lord. Right? You moved in. So tell us a little bit more about that before we shift, and that's a
3:55 perfect segue into kinda talking about the United Methodist Church and and some of those things.
4:00 Well, you know, if, if I had been given a piece sheet of paper when I was 4 years old or at any point that early in my life and been asked to map out the future course of my life,
4:13 none of what has happened. Yes. It's what has been on that sheet of paper. If you had asked me at any point in my life, will there come a time that you will be 1 of the leaders of a movement that will launch an entire
4:24 new denomination of Christians?
4:26 Global new denomination of that fact. Yep.
4:28 Nowhere would that be at it. At 1 point in my journey, the Christian artist, Stephen Stephen Curtis Chapman Mhmm. Had a song that
4:40 he did called the great adventure.
4:43 Yes.
4:43 And, I would say that is my journey with God, the great adventure. I think, I don't think there have been any accidents in my
4:55 journey. I'm sure that there were probably other routes that I might have chosen that may have got me where God wanted me to be much sooner, but I've come to believe that each step was a
5:07 necessary step for God to prepare me for the next step. Yes. And, I I really am glad that I released control and but, hey, I'm not gonna say I've completely released control.
5:19 That's a daily We're
5:20 still a work in progress.
5:21 Daily thing, you know, of of because I have what I want, but I have learned that if I will trust God, if I will let him take the lead,
5:33 he will take care of everything. And he he took me through experiences that showed me he was faithful. I mean, just a very briefly, you know, when I left Richmond, Virginia, left the law
5:45 firm and moved my family to Kentucky, we had a very nice house with a very large mortgage on it. And for 18 months, that house did not sell and I had to pay those mortgage payments. And literally,
5:57 I was down to not having any money to make the next mortgage payment. Yep. And it was at that moment, God came through and had someone send me, who I did not even know, send me
6:09 the next month's payment, mortgage payment, exactly the sum of money, we never communicated, and then within days after that, the household. Wow. And so, I
6:21 mean, that was my lowest point. I've I here I've got my family uprooted. I've moved to seminary. I've left, you know, a very profitable practice. People were saying,
6:32 if god called you, why hasn't he taken care of this stuff? And and yet, I stayed the course and god came through. I you know? And so that has shown me no
6:44 matter what the odds are, if I if you're about god's work, if you're doing what god has told you to do, he is gonna make a way, he's gonna overcome the impossible barrier, and it will not be according to
The Evolution and Challenges of Methodism
6:56 something you've dreamed up. You better be open to him coming at you from another direction, you know? Yeah. And so you're right. Nope. This is, I praise God for every moment of my journey.
7:08 There are no regrets. I the people who ought to be, celebrated in this is not me. I simply said yes to God. It's my wife who you
7:20 know, who took the flying leap with me. It's my children Yeah. Who, you know, made that journey. And, I, you know, I I just stand in
7:32 awe of what God has done.
7:34 Yeah. That's that thank you so much for sharing all of that. I, I wonder if you could give a little bit of a, I don't know, just a summary, and I I know it's it how do you
7:45 summarize a global movement like the United Methodist Church and John Wes Wesley? And, but could you talk a little bit about, I think, the the founding of the
7:57 denomination and a little bit of John Wesley's perspective and just so often I mean, I honestly, I think about King Solomon often, how he began so well, so so well, and God
8:09 blesses him with unbelievable wisdom and as well as wealth. But the end of his life, God was not pleased with Solomon at all. He'd allowed his heart to be turned to idols, towards sexual
8:21 morality. And, and so when we begin something, we see this over and over again. I mean, how many how many institutions do we have that, educational institutions that were founded on such solid biblical pers
8:33 perspectives, and now they're enemies of of the cross. You know? Right. And, so talk a little bit about, the UMC and kind of where it's it's wound up today if you can.
8:45 Yeah. Yeah. Well, obviously, Methodism has been an incredible, movement used by God over the centuries, to reach many, many people for
8:56 Christ. But I believe Methodism, especially United Methodism, increasingly became an institution that
9:08 lived for itself, not as a tool that God could use. And institutional preservation became the priority, not
9:21 surrender to God. That was but 1 I mean, I think that's what really set the stage for what later developed. It was the
9:33 flaw, and that could happen in any movement.
9:35 That's right.
9:36 Okay. I'd I'd pray regularly for the Global Methodist Church that we do not become institutional, that, we realize that we're
9:48 simply called to the work that is being done and in in global Methodism is a way that we are organized, but it is not the end all be all. The end all be all is the
10:00 kingdom of God
10:01 Yes.
10:02 And serving the king of kings, the lord of lords. Secondly, I believe United Methodism departed from its rock solid commitment
10:14 to the authority of the Bible, and its centrality, you know, Wesley is described as a man of 1 book despite the fact that he had
10:26 an incredible library and that he oversaw the preparation of a library that he wanted every Methodist pastor to have. So he was a he was a person who believed in being
10:38 widely read Yes. But yet he was described as a man of 1 book because the bible was central, primary, authoritative, and and, you know,
10:50 United Methodism became it lost its sense of being under authority. It was no longer under the authority of scripture and God's word, and
11:01 so anything that appealed to our itching ears as it were, began to be promoted and supported. And
11:15 people's experience quickly was elevated over Yes. Biblical revelation. And, you know, experience is
11:27 a wonderful thing, but it's also easily manipulated, very deceptive.
11:34 Yep.
11:34 And we can very and and and and hubris pride enters into this where we think we are the ones who have got it all figured out. Boy, is that dangerous
11:46 Yeah.
11:46 When you are dealing with the truth of all truths, you know, Jesus, the way, the truth, and the life. There is no room for competition with him. Okay? But
11:58 very quickly the church elevated who it is and it was and its agenda over against Jesus the Christ. And and then
12:10 quickly following upon that was, just a complete loss of order, a descent a descent into chaos as the
12:22 church no longer stood for what it had adopted by, you know, consensual, discernment as a church. You know, each
12:33 person could do what was right in their own eyes.
12:36 Right.
12:39 And, you know, boy, anyone who does what is right in their own eyes is on a fast track to falling badly. Okay? And that
12:51 the arrogance that was part of that, the complete abandonment. I mean, by the time we reached 20 16, it was clear to me
13:02 that Methodism had left its historical roots. The beauty of of John Wesley's understanding of the Christian life, and of course,
13:14 he he didn't he didn't create this. I mean, the the the Wesleyan way has was there in the first century. I mean, Jesus is the 1 and I don't I don't mean to say, you know, hey, well, the Methodists are
13:26 the only ones following Jesus. That's not what I'm saying. Yep. But but, Jesus' building of community where where these disciples were in relationship with each other and they were
13:38 under authority. And the word of God was there to direct and shape and mold them. I mean, that was carried forward in in mister Wesley, in the band meetings, the class
13:50 meetings, the fact that you were you were not an authority unto yourself. But all of that was abandoned in so many parts of
14:02 United Methodism, and and, you know, the the syncretism, the melding together
14:10 Yes.
14:11 Of the world's values to the exclusion at times of kingdom values. So so, and and the the the breadth
14:23 of the conflict, you know, Jesus was very clear, a house divided against itself is gonna fall. And, it was so obvious that United Methodism was divided
14:34 against itself. You know, I probably was 1 of the earliest, not the earliest, but 1 of the earliest people to say, this this house is
14:46 gonna fall, and we never need to be ready for what God would have us do on the other side of that. Mhmm. Which which led to the Wesleyan Covenant Association and all
14:58 the work that occurred there.
14:59 Yes. Yes. Well, there was also so I was hired by, a renewal ministry called Good News, which, is wrapping things up now and and, I think,
15:12 shutting down because of, in a very good way in having completed a lot of its goals and purposes in also being instrumental in launching this new, the Global Methodist
15:24 Church out of the United Methodist Church. And and so the but I think about I mean, it I think it started back in the in the sixties. I think it started as a renewal, ministry
15:35 then. And then there were a number of other renewal ministries that started up within the UMC. So did you just for our listeners' sake, it seemed like the United Methodist Church was really crumbling in theologically
15:48 in in a lot of ways, back at a time when it was it was it became a crisis situation, and Renewal Ministries formed that that did bring, I think, a a lot
16:00 of, breath of fresh air with regard to, the sound teachings of scripture and all that back into the United Methodist Church, and many people took hold of that and and and recognized the
16:11 goodness and the wholesomeness, the truth of it. So and then eventually wound up though being this this really big divide of of of those who were embracing
16:24 really, I I oftentimes think in in conjunction with what you just said, so many people began to interpret scripture through their own experience versus allowing, coming under the design and the purposes of God and
16:35 aligning themselves to that. But you started to see those 2 very big factions, growing within the UMC. So was there a time when when the church kind of as a whole was
16:47 looking pretty bleak, and that's why these renewal ministries kind of came on board? And did you see a renewal happening because of them?
16:55 Well, certainly, you know, really since the the turn of the into the twentieth century, you know, late 18 hundreds, early 19 hundreds, you
17:06 had the introduction of biblical liberalism which began to undercut the authority of scripture. And, and that I believe began
17:18 the the decay in the foundation of the Methodist denomination. And so, you know, really you look at some of the
17:29 institutions that were birthed in that period like Asbury Theological Seminary, Asbury College, that, were were a reaction to
17:41 that growing liberalism, biblical liberalism, and I and it's important to put biblical in front of that because, it literally was a completely different way
17:53 of interpreting and applying the bible. Yep. You know, it came to a head, you're correct, in the early sixties around issues of, you know, the lordship
18:05 of Christ as preeminence, his superiority, for the faith and many other issues, frustration with the watering down of Sunday school literature,
18:18 you know, the adoption of a of a political agenda that aligned with a secular kind of mindset and understanding of the world.
18:31 And you're right. So so, you know, good news was the first really of the renewal movements that came forth and was gen then joined by others. Mhmm. And and there were
18:42 multiple crises that occurred that usually gave birth to, like, the confessing movement, another renewal movement. You know, I think I think, at the early stages and really for
18:54 most of the life of, say, good news, the belief was that the role of these kinds of movements was to contend for the faith within the church
19:06 and be there present to be used as salt in the body to help the church repent and return to its first
19:18 love.
19:19 A prophetic voice in many respects.
19:20 Right. No point in those years was there an effort to say, well, we have to create something entirely new. Mhmm. But for
19:32 me, it was the 20 12 general conference in Tampa where I believed that and I'm gonna I'm just gonna state this
19:44 blunt. Yeah. I believe the spirit of God left the United Methodist Church at that conference. You know, I had I had been on the good news
19:55 board before. I had been elected to the judicial council of the United Methodist Church at Supreme Court and served on that for 8 years, had come off of that. I was now chairperson
20:07 of the good news board, at the 20 12 general conference, and I walked away from that saying, I don't see I mean, god, you can do anything, but I don't see
20:19 how you're going to to save this this expression of your faith. And, you know, then by 20 16, the
20:31 the, animosity and divide, the conflict had become so exacerbated that even the council of
20:43 bishops finally recognized that if something dramatic didn't happen, and, of course, their their their proposal, then known as the 1 church plan, was basically to
20:55 say, well, each church and for that matter, each pastor and for that matter, each believer could decide what they believed was biblical and the way to go. And,
21:08 you know, at that point, there was no spiritual vitality or strength, in United Methodism, in my opinion. Now there would be those who disagree
21:20 with that very strongly, who happened to be on the other side of this, so to speak.Show more
Comments No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Comments
Keep it kind. Comments are public.