Skip to content 81: Pray The Gay Away? Absolutely Not | Debra Baty & Garry Ingraham Aug 22 · 54 min ...more
81: Pray The Gay Away? Absolutely Not | Debra Baty & Garry Ingraham
August 22, 2025 · 54 min
Even in churches, buzzwords like 'conversion therapy' or 'pray the gay away' have been used to slander and minimize much needed counseling for people struggling with their own sexuality.
Series Love & Truth Network Podcast - Video Edition August 22, 2025 · 54 min · Love & Truth Network Podcast - Video Edition
Even in churches, buzzwords like 'conversion therapy' or 'pray the gay away' have been used to slander and minimize much needed counseling for people struggling with their own sexuality. ...more Show the full description Show less Even in churches, buzzwords like 'conversion therapy' or 'pray the gay away' have been used to slander and minimize much needed counseling for people struggling with their own sexuality.
Series Love & Truth Network Podcast - Video Edition Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Support this leader
Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Give
Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
49.1K followers
Love & Truth Network equips pastors and local churches to restore relational & sexual wholeness and biblical identity. We accomplish this through our resources,
49.1K followers
Exploring Godly Sexuality and Transformation 0:01 This isn't about changing me. This is a chance to explore and go deeper and find out what the Lord has for me and what can I do, what can I learn0:13 about how, you know, godly sexuality plays out in in the face of what I was struggling with?0:20 Our lives are changed and transformed. It just oftentimes doesn't align with exactly what we want and certainly doesn't align with the timetable that we want it to happen on usually.0:27 It was just dawning on me. I'm like, wait. The Lord's the Lord of my whole life. That means to every detail, including how I'm handling that in in relationships with0:39 women.0:40 Being Beckett is not communicating, oh, snap your fingers, pray the gay away, change affection. It's this change that happens over the course of time.0:47 This whole pray the gay away thing is just really undermining, 1, the power of prayer, and 2, not giving justice to how prayer can0:59 be woven in with how the Lord works in our lives.1:03 In our shame, we tend to turn away from him. And and and what you're talking about is, no, this beautiful value of coming to him, that invitation that he gives us to come, and and what we can receive from that. But what1:14 also winds up happening is shame breaks off.1:17 Way out of temptation is to ask the Lord. He's already provided the way of escape from that particular issue in your life, whatever it is. When we turn to Jesus and ask him for1:28 that way, we're building intimacy with him even as we're talking to him.1:34 God has taken, ones who really were, for me at least, would exclusively same sex attracted and couldn't even imagine, being in relationship with a woman, romantically or sexually. And, you1:45 know, now I've we just celebrated our seventeenth year of marriage.1:48 When you see God working over the course of years in people that you're invested with up close and personal, it's it's phenomenal. It gives you a better sense of who he is.2:23 Well, hey, everybody. Thanks for joining us for another episode of the Love and Truth Network podcast. Whether you're coming to us through Love and Truth Network or through a connection to transforming congregations,2:31 we're just really glad that you're here and that you are joining us for this, new episode of the Love and Truth Network podcast. We're also excited to have 1 of my friends with us today, Dee Beatty. She's she's become a2:43 dear friend and a colleague in ministry, and I'm excited for you to be able to hear from her today, to hear her story and also just to hear some of the the wisdom that God has given her in the space of of doing ministry.2:55 And she's a great researcher. She's a good writer, and, we just really enjoyed getting to know each other over the last few years. So, Dee, thanks so much for being here with us.3:05 Thanks so much for having me. I'm excited to be here.3:07 Absolutely. Well, hey. When, whenever we get started, our audience knows that we usually hear from our guests in terms of just their story. I think the the value of story, the value of each of us telling what it is3:19 that god has where he met us, what he's brought us through, whether we became Christians early on in life or later in life, whatever the situation, I think it's so important that people, both share their stories and hear3:30 the stories of God's redemption in the lives of those around him. And so we would love to, hear some of your story as well.3:39 Awesome. So, I became a Christian at an early age. I was 1 of those people. And around, I think, about 7 years old, heard about salvation3:51 and thought, Oh, this sounds like a great deal. I believe in Jesus. I don't go to hell. What?3:56 Who could When? When?3:58 So that was it was fire insurance. But I also don't want to take for granted that that was a great thing to be introduced to Christ at a young age. But I didn't really understand4:10 the implications of it all, of course, at that age. When I went to a camp, we went the last week of the summer every year to Camp Holawasa in southern New Jersey,4:23 which is still working and going on today. And there I got to see people living their lives for Christ up close and personal in a way I hadn't seen before and started picking4:34 up, oh this is not just fire insurance. This is something that the Lord is the Lord of our lives. That that's not just a title, that that has weight and meaning.4:46 So I picked up on that and rededicated my life to the Lord around 13 where I thought, okay, now I'm going to understand that this is a relationship. This is an ongoing,4:59 acknowledgement that you're in charge of me. Around that same time, I started noticing that I was attracted to women in ways that people around the women,5:11 girls around me weren't, and didn't know what to do with that. And that was back in the dark ages before the Internet. So finding resources was5:23 really difficult, if not impossible, especially as a kid. And I was going to a small United Methodist church there at the time, but there was nothing5:35 there for about sexuality or gender or anything. So I was I'm thankful in a way that I didn't hear what many others5:47 around that time they were hearing, fire and brimstone condemnation type sermons with homosexuality being, you know, the the main object of of all that wrath. So I5:58 didn't hear anything like that. But I also didn't hear any hope for redemption or transformation or sanctification, anything. It seemed to me that this was something Christians didn't struggle6:10 with was what I was left to conclude. But I'm also, I'm thankful that it allowed me and the Lord to just figure it out together6:22 instead of having other input. I didn't have condemnation. I didn't have affirmation. I just had me and Jesus. So6:34 I searched the scripture, and so did not find a single positive reference to homosexuality in in the Bible and thought, okay. So that's not looking good,6:47 for me. But I didn't know how to practically live or work that out as I realized more and more that this was something that wasn't just going away. Right.6:59 So, I'm thankful for that time. But I also was probably the loneliest time in some ways because my prayers seemed to bounce off the ceiling. Like I didn't,7:11 you know, God answered prayers in many other ways in other areas of my life. But with this 1 it seemed like there was silence and didn't quite know what to do. So fast7:23 forward to college, I ended up going to a college in Center City, Philadelphia and was looking for churches. And the first7:35 church I tried was Tenth Presbyterian Church in Center City, Philly. And they had on their bulletin a ministry of the week that they would pray for and they would switch, you know,7:47 rotate through different ministries. And that particular week, it was Harvest USA and it was written there in the bulletin and they prayed for it during the service. And I still have that bulletin,7:59 because they said this is a ministry outreach to people dealing with homosexuality, same sex attraction. And I I couldn't believe it that I'd found I'm like, I don't care if I don't like the music, if I8:11 don't like the preacher, I'm going to go to8:13 the church.8:13 Right. They've had this outreach.8:16 And and Deborah, did you say did you say tenth Presbyterian? Okay. It's just so funny that, you know, first, I've heard of second. I've never heard of all the other ones down to tenth. Okay. Got it.8:25 Yeah. Yeah. And it's pretty iconic there in Philadelphia, and it was James Montgomery Boyse8:31 was the8:32 pastor at the time and C. Everett Koop became a Christian going to that church. So yeah, it's, it's tenth Presby and they had this outreach8:43 because the front steps of their church on Friday and Saturday nights, male prostitutes would use the front steps of their church to pick up, clients quote8:55 unquote. And they were trying to figure out what they should do and being good solid And I say that in love9:07 because I love the nerdy wing of the Christian realm is being that Presbyterian group. So they that turned into Harvest USA Ministry. Wow. And I'm9:19 so thankful. They're still going Oh,9:21 yeah. They are.9:21 40 years.9:23 Yeah.9:23 Yeah. They're super. And it was just the right ministry for me because I tend to be on the nerdy end of the Christian spectrum myself. So,9:36 at first when I got in touch with them, I met with John Freeman and he suggested I go to their support group for women. And I thought, this is the stupidest idea I've ever9:47 had. Because I'm like, some man must have come up with this idea because he obviously doesn't know how women work. Because if you put a bunch of women in a room together having, you know, just9:59 complaining about and spilling our guts about how hard this is, we're all just going to pair off. And don't they understand that's that's just not a good format.10:11 But he insisted that at least try, you know, and I said, well, if I could talk to the woman that's leading it, the coordinator for that group, then maybe I'll think about it. And he just was very kind and was like, okay,10:23 we can make that happen. And I didn't realize that was a requirement before you joined the group. They got.10:28 You had to do that, right?10:30 So I was like, he was just playing along with me, which is very specific. And, and yeah, it was a fantastic group. And I met the person coordinating at the time that was a social worker10:43 and she just seemed very with it. And they had a code of like a not a code of conduct, but just something that you would sign that just said, you know, you're going to keep this confidential. You're not10:55 going to meet with people outside of the group and be in touch with them. And just the the way that they had that structured, I thought, okay, so there's ground rules.11:05 Yeah. There's safety.11:06 And Right. So I can abide by that. And then if somebody, you know, get started, things started going the wrong way with someone in the group, I could always pull that back out and go, hey, look, we agreed. Yep. We both11:18 agreed to this. So I was very thankful and I love that group. It was phenomenal. It was a total godsend.11:27 How long were you a part of it?11:29 About a year and a half.11:31 Yeah.11:32 And the reason why it was not 2 years was because they switched location to a place where I just didn't have transportation reliable to get to get there. But I got so11:44 much out of it. And there's so many we hear so many bad stories, of people's bad experiences with counseling or like quite often I we11:55 don't hear the details of what that means.11:57 Right.11:59 So I try to find out when someone says they had a bad experience. Like, could could you share what specifically do you mean? 1 example I can give is12:10 the when that group started, for for harvest, there were about 30 women in the room. 35. And I'm like, this is not a small group. This is too big. And then the next week there were12:22 12 of us and the week after that there were 8. And I asked the leadership, like, why do we have this 35 down to? And they said that this happens every year, that12:34 they they do all the interviews. They, you know, have everyone sign the paper. And every year there's a huge group of women to start off with. And then the next week they're gone. Wow. And it's sometimes it's the same12:46 people every year and it's like they're just trying it out to say that they tried it or just see who's there or they don't know exactly all the reasons why, but they're just faithful12:58 in providing opportunity. It's up to the individual to get something out of it. So when somebody says they tried it and it didn't work, I want to know what do you mean by try it?13:10 Did you go to the 1 or 2 meetings and then thought that this wasn't up your alley or and is that because it didn't work or because you didn't like what they were doing or what was going on or you weren't13:21 ready or like what what are the details behind that? So I try to figure that out before moving forward because it's very easy to say that that didn't work. Yep.13:35 But this there were everyone on staff at Harvest had a master's degree or higher in some either, you know, divinity, some theological degree or13:47 in counseling. So that was 1 of the unique aspects of harvest compared to other ministries that made for a really mature staff. And I loved that13:59 professionalism poured over into all that they did. I wanted to know, you know, how long before I start noticing a difference in my attractions14:11 and desires? You know, how long is this going to take?14:15 Yes. Right.14:16 Yeah. The answer was, you know, most people come here for 2 years. And I was like, well, that's not what I asked. I asked, you know, how much to make a difference. And you're14:28 telling me that the average people person comes here 2 years, you're not giving so you're not giving me a guarantee that changes are going to happen. You're just saying this is how long people come. So I picked up on14:38 that right away that they weren't promising changes in desires or attractions, which I thought was fantastic. And I think that's probably the number 1 thing is having those clear expectations14:51 from the start to help with satisfaction in counseling? And that's across the board in counseling. Yes. Whatever kind of counseling you get to. Are you going to get clear expectations from the15:02 outset? But especially in this area. So I tried to emphasize that that we just don't have guarantees and in we, you know, we can't make God jump through our15:14 hoops.15:15 Right.15:15 In other words. So I appreciated that. And I think having that clear expectation that, okay, this isn't about changing me. This is a chance to explore and go deeper and find out15:27 what the Lord has for me and what can I do, what can I learn about how you know, godly sexuality plays out in in the face of what I15:39 was struggling with?15:40 Well, indeed, 1 of the things I I don't want you to lose your place, but 1 of the things that I really appreciate about what you're sharing too is that, I find that when this was true for me. This is true for15:52 probably everyone I know that has dealt with same sex attraction or something on the LGBTQ plus kind of spectrum is, you know, we're looking for a very we're hoping for a very short16:03 window of time that we need to be, you know, in in a group like this or maybe in in mentoring or coaching or or counseling. And and we're often looking to have16:15 this issue alone addressed. I mean, this is what the big thing in our in our way of thinking is. And I think from what I know of Harvest and you know more than I do with them, but from certainly, in our ministry context16:27 and from other ministries that I think are doing a really great job is that this is about a discipleship process of the whole person. This isn't about just 1, you know, 1 area of our lives no matter how16:39 dominant or how frustrated we might be with just that 1 area, And I think that's more reflective of the way that God works. It's not so called conversion therapy. It is this this, journey of discipleship16:51 that God is inviting us on, and I and I love what you just described there. And also the boundaries around or the or the the idea of, of not making false promises, or or, again,17:03 the more specific things, we need to we need to really leave it open to what God is gonna do in that person's life, give hope because there always is hope in, in discipleship. And in, our lives are changed and17:14 transformed. It just oftentimes doesn't align with exactly what we want and certainly doesn't align with the timetable that we want it to happen on usually.17:21 Right. Yeah. Like, can we get this done by today? That'd be great. Exactly. I've got things to do. And that's like what you said about it's, you know, God doesn't work in isolation like that.17:33 He doesn't just take 1 part of our lives and isolate it and then fix that and then plug it back in. That's also not how human sexuality works.17:42 That's right.17:43 And that's 1 of the downfalls of the ideology behind sexual orientation. Ideology is saying this is 1 aspect of personhood that's, you know,17:55 independent of everything else. And that's just unfair because human sexuality is way more complicated and complex. It's integrated into all different areas and aspects of our lives.18:08 So the Lord working on this is in keeping with that greater complexity of sexuality. And for us as people of18:20 faith, pastors and pastoral counselors, to keep that in mind because that's that is 1 of the other downfalls of other ministries that I've heard that been a legitimate, you know, complaint is to say you18:32 have a ministry's treating the issue as though it's this isolated faith problem. And if you just deal with it, you know, in obedience and have enough faith then18:44 God's gonna get jump through the roof and and magically fix it. And that's not in tune with how God really works, and it's not in tune with how, you know, the reality of the complexity of what we're talking about.18:56 Right. Right. So you were with Harvest, for some time. What where do you wanna kind of I interrupted your story. I apologize. But No.19:04 You're good. Yeah. I ended up working, like, volunteering for them, because I couldn't, you know, go to their the second half of the meetings when they switched locations. But I did some19:16 volunteer work in their office and represented them at different missions conferences and things, which was wonderful. And, you know, just read and got started getting a lot more of the resources,19:28 cassette tapes from different ministries of people's testimonies, essays, books and just devoured whatever I could and loved. And19:40 that's that's part of what inspires me to continue the newsletter writing that I do today is I was so hungry for resources.19:48 Yes.19:49 And trying to filter through what is good and bad and helping to equip pastors. So I started writing a newsletter maybe like the next year after20:01 I had graduated, when I started getting in tune with, you know, different those ministry resources that were available and send it to20:13 just a group of pastors. And that was back in the day for snail mail. So I was, you know, hand mailing these newsletters to whoever would listen and did that for for quite some20:24 time. And then, you know, that just got set aside. Eventually I became a board member for Harvest when they opened an office in Chattanooga because I lived20:36 near there, which was another great experience. And then, I guess the in20:48 between, I guess, I'm skipping over some stuff. So in graduate school, like at harvest, 1 of the things this was pretty huge because I talked about lordship salvation and understanding21:00 that more as I was growing up. Well I didn't really realize the weight of it when it came to my affections until I was in that group at harvest. And, you know, it21:11 wasn't something that they, you know, hammered out. It was just dawning on me. I'm like, wait, if the Lord's the Lord of my whole life, that means to every detail including,21:25 he's the Lord of my affections. So am I going to allow him to rule over how I'm handling that in relationships21:37 with women. And I had a really big argument with God, one-sided, about that. I'm like, Wait Lord, you know, you're asking me you're asking way too21:49 much. Like you're asking me this and how can you ask me to not, you know, should you ask me to not show affection unless I check it off with you first? And what are you saying? And22:02 how how much are you asking of me? And about 3 or 4 hours of me crying and, just I ended up on the floor in a pile of tears. And22:15 when I finally allowed the Lord to get a word in edgewise, he patiently listened to all that. I, you know, I ended up with the question, you know, what are you asking of me? And he said, you22:27 know, still a small voice. Trust me. And I thought, well, that just sounds exactly like something you would say. I just was not I did not have a good attitude. But it was also22:39 the perfect thing to say, you know, because it was it was a hope and a challenge and, like it's on that relationship level. Like, am I going to actually trust22:51 him? Even to that level of if he says go, go, if he says stay, stay. And, he's never betrayed that trust23:03 is what I can say in all the years since. I wasn't always perfect in keeping up my end of trusting him. But I'm so thankful that he answered in in that way. And I've23:15 I've lived on that, leaning on that trust, I guess ever since.23:20 Yeah. Well and that reminds me just even talking about affection, it reminds me of Beckett Cook's book, A Change of Affection, you know. And I I love that that idea. And, of23:32 course, you know, when when it's easy to kinda pull out that title and make it say something that it's not. I mean, Beckett is not communicating, oh, snap your fingers, pray the gay away, change the defection.23:43 It's this change that happens over the course of time, you know, and it and it's it can be long and grueling, but in the end, in the end and even in the process, it's it's so worth the journey23:56 of of that surrender and that following after and really giving God, access to our to the deepest places and the affection to to align them more fully with with who he is and and what he's24:08 called us what he's created us for, really.24:11 Mhmm. And that's you mentioned that the the pray the gay away type thing, that's something that's been a bit of a pet peeve of mine through the years because before I24:23 went to harvest, no 1 had ever prayed with me about this area of my life. So when you pray, you kinda take prayer for granted when you grow up in the church. Like, we pray for the weather. We pray24:35 for our test grades. We pray A24:37 parking spot up front in front of the store. Yeah.24:39 The parking spot. Like, we pray for stuff all the time, but to not ever pray with somebody about this 1 area that was really scary and intimidating and like you don't24:51 understand how big a deal it is, first of all, to be able to pray with somebody over something that you, you know, when you're taking everything else for granted. And then secondly, at Harvest,25:04 the way they structured their meetings, you we would start off going around the circle and we could ask for a prayer request, if we wanted to. And then if you didn't, you didn't have25:16 to. We would go over a topic of that week and, it was a different subject. 1 week I remember I was surprised they talked about anger, and I thought, what25:27 does anger have to do with sexuality? Well, what's the last 1? Yeah, exactly. You're laughing already. You're like, guess what? Because I'm like, what kind of stupid idea? No, no, that wasn't a stupid idea. And just25:38 processing that. And they, they had a lot of open ended questions. So if whatever you were hitting on that week didn't apply to you, it didn't apply to you. So and they didn't, you know, have25:50 a problem with that. So they didn't use a formula that they were trying to force everybody into. They just left it open between you and the board. Although they they had some common denominator topics that most26:02 people would have something, to to learn from just we all can learn about how God wants us to handle anger in general. But they were able to apply, you know, we were in that room applying it26:14 specifically to that complexity of sexuality. And then at the end, we could pray about something we had learned that night that we want to pray on or something in the future or if you didn't want to26:26 pray, you didn't have to. So this whole pray the gay away thing is just really, undermining 1, the power of prayer to me26:39 and 2 not giving justice to how prayer can be woven in with how the Lord works in our lives. So it's more of a26:50 relational conversation is what prayer is. It's not just a vending machine. So if all you see is the vending machine part, sure, you shouldn't be interacting with God in that way to begin with,27:02 though. So whenever I hear that phrase, I kind of step back and go, let's talk about what prayer means first before you use that and just act like a bumper sticker dismissal of something27:14 that's really intimate.27:16 That's true.27:17 Yeah. So well and and that's something else to to highlight. So it's easy for me to see how people can feel27:29 like these temptations are a permanent part of who you are. Like, this is who I really am. Because, especially at that time, I could not imagine myself being attracted to a27:41 man at all. Like, this is just the way things are. But I learned through harvest the time that I was there to see27:52 this as a temptation I'm experiencing. Like this is not hardwired into me to the degree that the world is claiming that it is.28:04 This is something I'm experiencing, not something that's who I am, definitive of who I am, because who I am in Christ is deeper than anything else. And there is a28:16 time where I would, however, you know, even knowing all that, there was a time where I would start to experience a temptation and I would just fall flat into fantasy life, fantasizing about28:28 women. And I got really frustrated because it was almost like you couldn't finish the word temptation. It would be like, yep. Like I would just fall so fast and I got just tired of28:40 it. And at 1 point just called out to the Lord and said, Lord, can you just show me what is setting me off? Like, what is going on here?28:53 And the Holy Spirit just gently and kindly revealed that with whenever I was disappointed in life, I would go right into,29:05 fantasy world to escape, to distract me from that disappointment. And 1, I was embarrassed because it was so simple and such a basic thing. Like, well, that's kind of sad. And then 2,29:18 the kicker was that when the Lord revealed that to me, you know, Jesus said, you know, when you're disappointed, you can come to me.29:31 And it just like, it kind of like, slayed me because it was it was not that he was he wasn't disappointed in me. He was just hurt29:43 that I wasn't wanting to spend time with him. And it was so like he was hurt to see me hurting myself by being29:54 distracted. Like, it didn't matter that it was that particular fantasy. It was just I could have been distracting myself with anything else.30:03 Right.30:03 He would have said the same thing. You know, he was just like, hey, you know, instead of filling off like that, you could be spending that time. Tell me when you're disappointed. I want to30:15 hear about it. I care about you and I want to know. And there's a passage, first Corinthians 10 13, it says, no temptation has overtaken you except what's common30:28 to man, but God is faithful and he'll not let you be tempted beyond your ability. But he'll with the temptation, he'll also provide the way of escape so that you can endure it. And30:40 I love that passage because it's pointing out that well, 1 of the cool things, it's like it's like pulling the rug out from under Satan.30:51 Right.30:52 That that the way out of temptation is to ask the Lord to show you like he's already prepared the way. It's not that, oh my gosh, you know, you're tempted. Forget31:04 you. When you figure yourself out, then you can come back to me. Like that's not how God operates. Like he's already provided the way of escape from that particular issue in your31:16 life, whatever it is. And the way of finding it when we turn to Jesus and ask him for that way, we're building intimacy with him even as we're talking to31:27 him about it, if that makes sense. It's not just if you're obedient, then you can have intimacy with me. It's like, no. No. You talking to me about it is building that intimacy so that we can31:40 develop that deeper relationship so that we can hear and recognize the voice of the good shepherd, more quickly. Yes. And it's more familiar.31:48 And it's and it's also it strikes me as you're sharing that. I think it's so spot on what you're sharing, and I hope those listening, watching are are really taking in what you're what you're saying. But I think the the32:00 other kind of counter effect that's also so valuable is that most of us, we we tend to run from, which, of course, is silly. We know we can't run. I mean, god sees it all. But in our shame, we tend to32:12 turn away from him. And and and what you're talking about is, no, this beautiful value of coming to him, that invitation that he gives us to come, and and what we can receive from that. But what also winds up happening32:23 is shame breaks off. Is that rather than living in the familiar patterns of turning away and running and and then sort of trying to clean ourselves up in a way so that we kinda feel better about ourselves to come back I32:33 mean, which, of course, none of those things are of value to him, but rather, you know what? I'm gonna I I don't care about the shame. I, you know, I, yes, it's heavy on me. Yes, it feels awful. And, yes, I know IShow more In this video 0:00 Exploring Godly Sexuality and Transformation33:01 The Role of Community and Accountability in Faith50:19 Resources and Hope for Redemption
Comments No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Comments
Keep it kind. Comments are public.