Skip to content 58: A Discussion Regarding "Gay Christianity" | Robert Gagnon & Garry Ingraham Aug 22 · 1 hr 14 min ...more
58: A Discussion Regarding "Gay Christianity" | Robert Gagnon & Garry Ingraham
August 22, 2025 · 1 hr 14 min
Many supposed scholars and self-proclaimed Biblical experts make the case that Jesus and the Bible actually endorse homosexual activity, and go to great lengths with these re-interpretations.
Series Love & Truth Network Podcast - Video Edition
Love & Truth Network equips pastors and local churches to restore relational & sexual wholeness and biblical identity. We accomplish this through our resources,
August 22, 2025 · 1 hr 14 min · Love & Truth Network Podcast - Video Edition
Many supposed scholars and self-proclaimed Biblical experts make the case that Jesus and the Bible actually endorse homosexual activity, and go to great lengths with these re-interpretations. ...more Show the full description Show less Many supposed scholars and self-proclaimed Biblical experts make the case that Jesus and the Bible actually endorse homosexual activity, and go to great lengths with these re-interpretations.
Series Love & Truth Network Podcast - Video Edition Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Support this leader
Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Give
Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
In this video 0:00 Foundations of Biblical Sexual Ethics1:56 Personal Testimony and Scriptural Convictions18:19 Theological and Cultural Challenges40:41 Sin, Repentance, and the Call to Discipleship50:55 Transgenderism and the Biblical Response
Foundations of Biblical Sexual Ethics 0:01 So I got a little bit from both sides. And as you can well imagine in moving through venues like Dartmouth, Harvard, and Princeton Seminary that I was getting a lot of attempted indoctrination,0:13 not only to support, the, so called gay lifestyle, but also, to be able to say that scripture had no real problem with it. Paul describes this, phenomenon0:25 in Romans 1, as you know, Romans 1 24 to 27, as a dishonoring of oneself and of another. And what he means by that is treating 10:36 sex or gender as only half rather than wholly intact in relation to one's own sex. And that dishonors what God has actually created.0:46 2 people of the same sex between 2 men, 2 women, the lack of complementarity there also is not just anatomical, biological, but it's also spiritual. It's the reality that we have different I believe0:58 that that we're made in the image of God of equal value, male and female, but of different expressions.1:03 What we want to say to people is don't stunt your masculine development by thinking that you're gonna get that your masculine needs met by merging with somebody who's male and trying to1:15 steal from them and affect what God has already given to you.1:18 The church is actually accommodating that thinking it's being kind and gracious when it's actually allowing the stunting to continue in that person's life.
1:26 Jesus is the most rigorous interpreter of the significance of the sexual binary for developing standards for sexual ethics in the entire known ancient
1:38 world. Your appeal to him as somebody who's willing to give up that foundation, that male female requirement, is absolutely absurd. He he would be the last
1:49 person in the entire ancient world that you would want to appeal to for eliminating that as a foundational element.
Personal Testimony and Scriptural Convictions
2:19 Well, hey, everybody. Thank you so much for joining us for another Love and Truth Network podcast. Whether you're joining us through Love and Truth Network, a connection there, or through transforming congregations, We
2:29 are so glad that you're here again today and able to to listen or view this podcast with doctor Robert Gagnon. He is somebody that I have respected for a long time, his work,
2:41 and his writings, and just teachings on the topics of, theology and sexuality and just the the the deep understanding of what the scriptures teach on identity issues and
2:53 sexuality. And so I've I've known him through his teachings and through his writings in the past and then our passive cross in ministry in a variety of ways, especially with Restored Hope Network and our our mutual
3:05 connection there on the board and things of that nature. And so it's a real joy for me to have, Roderick Agnan here with us, today for this podcast, and I know it's gonna be a treat for you to listen in on as well. So,
3:16 doctor Gagnon, thanks so much for joining us for this podcast.
3:20 Thanks for having me on, Gary.
3:22 Well, our guests are accustomed to, the folks that or our listeners, I should say, are accustomed to, those who join us as guests sharing a little bit about their own faith journey and their story of what
3:34 life was like before Christ and how they came to Christ and what life has kinda been like afterward.
3:42 Well, I was a really solid, moral, good guy, you know? Thought I was better than most people looking around me. But, I became a Christian largely through,
3:55 means that surprised me. I was trying to date a young woman who was a Christian and and, to continue that relationship, her parents insisted that I start reading scripture. So I started
4:07 reading scripture and, the New Testament, looking at Matthew, looking at Mark. And eventually, I was really persuaded by the amazing portrait of Jesus in the gospels.
4:19 And when I reached for the second time in Mark, second time in the gospels in Mark 9, the story of the father with the epileptic boy where the father says, lord, I believe. Help my unbelief. It all
4:31 kicked in for me. At that moment, I felt the supernatural presence of the lord in my bedroom where I was reading scripture and dedicated my life to him. That was at the age of 17.
4:43 That's a long time ago now since I'm 65, getting up there in years. And, my journey has been 1 of, of course, like all Christians, seeing god's faithfulness in
4:54 various parts and facets of my life. As you know, eventually, I moved into, the academy, became a New Testament scholar, did my undergrad at Dartmouth and then Harvard Divinity
5:06 School and then Pittsburgh Theological Seminary for PhD. And, I was drawn somewhat to this issue because I had belonged to a church in the Boston area that had a local
5:18 ministry reaching out to persons who were same sex attracted. And I got to meet a number of those persons and get to know them personally, their struggles, their concerns, their victories.
5:31 And, that sort of drew me into the discussion on a very personal level. I also encountered in college and in graduate school many persons who had no desire
5:43 to, mortify desires that god expressly had forbidden, to be practiced and to be gratified. So I got a little bit from both sides. And as you can well
5:55 imagine in moving through venues like Dartmouth, Harvard, and Princeton Seminary that I was getting a lot of attempted indoctrination, not only to support, the,
6:07 so called gay lifestyle, but also, to be able to say that scripture had no real problem with it. Jesus himself, in particular, had no real problem with it. So I
6:19 was really getting 2 different vantage points. 1 was the personal level and meeting people on various sides of this issue who are struggling with it or affirming it. But then on the other hand, the whole
6:31 scriptural question, what to do with the witness of scripture? And I must say that I was, both, offended and, mortified
6:42 by the really shoddy work that was being done with scripture on this question and really misrepresenting the biblical text at every point
6:54 from the creation narratives, the Sodom text, Levi to Gibeah, the Levitical prohibitions, Jesus' own witness, Paul's discussion of it, particularly in Romans
7:05 1, first Corinthians 6 9, first Timothy 1 10, and and just the whole fabric of scripture generally. I mean, the whole so many arguments, so many bad arguments,
7:17 such, ignorance really of the historical and literary context for these texts, and really for the sense that the biblical witness on this is not a not a few texts here
7:29 and there, but really the biblical witness on this is that there is a male female foundation for sexual ethics and that all other sexual
7:41 ethics standards according to Jesus Yeah. Really, are predicated on this foundation. So this is not like a minor matter. It is the foundation for
7:52 all of sexual ethics and certainly is understood by Jesus. So, to misreceive the biblical text, I mean, it was so important to me,
8:04 not only because it's my field of expertise, but also because, again, that's how I became a Christian. It's meeting and countering Jesus in scripture, and the whole apostolic witness to him.
8:18 To see that distorted and misrepresented, I feel is really blasphemous. At least at least come right out and acknowledge that this an overwhelming biblical witness
8:29 against, the promotion of the LGBTQ, lifestyle and agenda, and then say, well, I just simply disagree with Jesus. I at least have some respect for that. I think you're making
8:41 a major cataclysmic error to, disagree with Jesus, right, and and claim that you're a Christian and that you fall under his lordship. Because if he does indeed regard it as
8:53 foundational, then, for all sexual ethics, then you're you're essentially calling into question his lordship. So I guess that's a roundabout way of saying to my 2 major
9:05 concerns, the personal dimension, but also the dimension from scripture. It's Sure.
9:10 Yeah. Absolutely. And and you mentioned, doctor Gagnon, you mentioned the ministry up in the Boston area. What what ministry was that? Was it right there? The ministry alive in Christ?
9:23 Okay.
9:24 No. It was just, for this particular church. I'm even blanking on the name of the church. It was an American Baptist church in
9:32 Got it. Got it.
9:33 Blind Boston. Yeah.
9:33 I might not be familiar with it.
9:35 Ruggles Baptist. Ruggles Baptist Church.
9:37 Well, and and and I appreciate also the fact that you you're you come out of a of a pretty rich background of both being exposed to and having conversations with and dialoguing
9:49 around, the issues, for those that have come out of this out of the LGBT world, to follow Christ and, you know, are are wanting to come under Jesus' lordship or or choosing to come under his lordship
10:01 and and therefore align their own lives, you know, under his authority rather than I often say that, you know, we live in a in a time when people who claim to be Christians are so often rather
10:13 than, coming under his lordship and authority, they're remaking God into their own image in a sense and using a lot of the same language, a lot of the same titles, you know, Jesus, Holy Spirit, God. And,
10:25 you know, the gospel grace even is is often a word that doesn't mean what what the Bible used in a way that the Bible doesn't, it doesn't describe the fullness of what grace actually is.
10:37 It seems like it's more permissive, you know, God winking at people and their sin rather than actually grace being empowerment according to Titus chapter 2. And so there's a lot of a lot of things
10:49 there where language is shifting and people are shifting perspectives, but then you also had, you had a lot of conversations with those who had no interest in coming under the authority of Christ. And so you've been
11:00 exposed really to both worlds, it seems, you know, pretty thoroughly. And and then, you know, your your heart, your your gifting, your drive toward, really understanding theology,
11:13 going back to the original, you know, language, understanding what's being talked about there, the cultural, nuances and dynamics. I mean, I just so appreciate again the way that, as I've heard you teach,
11:25 and as as I've read your writings, it just there's such a thorough, handling and careful handling of the of the word of God. So what that brings up to me though is, you know, I read Matthew Vine's
11:37 book, God and the Gay Christian, and, of course, he makes an early claim to having a high view of scripture and then goes ahead and pretty much obliterates, you know, what the what the scripture teaches, you know, I
11:48 think very openly, very clearly on these issues. Matthew Vines is more the camp of prorogate theology. Right? And Selamette just full on live into this space. And so what are your, your thoughts about, some
12:00 of the arguments he makes? For example, Paul never knew anyone back in his day that, you know, were they were in monogamous gay relationships. It was all about these abusive, temple prostitution, you
12:12 know, pedophilia, the the these kinds of abusive relationships as of or not relationships, behaviors as opposed to monogamous gay relationships. Seems ridiculous to me that this is some
12:24 brand new thing that's happened, you know, only in our time. But what are your thoughts about that or other, aspects of his arguments or other arguments supporting so called pro gay theology?
12:37 Yeah. Matthew Vine just sort of popularized, some scholarly views on the question. I really don't. He he's really not somebody that I have, how do I put it?
12:49 He's not a he's not a scholar. He he's a bright guy. He did go to Harvard. He didn't finish Harvard. He he left to to do pursue more of this gay agenda stuff, but, almost all
13:01 this stuff is derivative. At 1 point on on Facebook, I he was commenting on a Facebook friend's site that something like Agnes History Passay.
13:13 And, and so I said, okay. Really well, it rumors like Mark Twain. Right? Rumors of my demise are premature. What is it do you think that is erroneous about what I've argued? And then he
13:25 immediately begged off, well, I'm not a biblical scholar, and I you know, really, you should discuss it with others and so forth. So he was so certain, you know, that he was correct about his view. But then the moment
13:36 that I actually showed up and there would be a possibility for real time discussion, debate, dialogue, but about the question, suddenly, he he had no case.
13:46 Yes.
13:47 You know? So it's typical that many will want to argue, some kind of new knowledge argument that we have, as you noted. For example, that, they didn't know about committed gay relationships in the
13:59 ancient world or they didn't know about anything corresponding to sexual orientation, any sort of congenital innate factors that key into homosexual development. And both, it turns
14:10 out to be false. There's really an array of committed relationships that exist in the ancient world. You can see our already from Plato's Symposium, in the
14:22 classical period and beyond, into the, Roman imperial age, where there are lots of known committed relationships between persons of the same sex,
14:34 relatively equal age pairing, in some cases even involving semi official marriages that take place between men or between women, for example, in Rome or in Alexandria,
14:46 Egypt. And, in fact, we have both church fathers and rabbis of the period commenting on these marriages and saying that doesn't make it valid. It's
14:58 still a a relationship that's contrary to nature, because you don't have a relationship between the 2 sexual counterparts as designed by god. So anyone who
15:09 actually does know the literature well knows that there are plenty of examples, both conceptually, the ability to to conceive of committed same sex relationships
15:22 and, real time actual relationships taking place. We even have debates between proponents of male male love and proponents of male female love as to which is superior,
15:35 going on in the first and second century AD. And it's acknowledged by both sides that there are committed same sex relationships. But that
15:46 doesn't that doesn't make it doesn't override the struck if you will, structural incongruity of the relationship of trying to unite, 2 persons of the same sex
15:58 who clearly, anatomically, physiologically, and even psychologically are not sexual counterparts to each other. It's more of the same. Right?
16:10 So it raises the question of what is wrong with the same sex relationship, even if it's done as well as it can be done. And what's chiefly wrong about it? Many things. I mean,
16:22 1 just simply is the perception of a sexual same as, in effect, a sexual other to oneself, sexual complement to oneself. If the if the logic of an of a
16:34 hetero or other sex union is the 2 halves of the sexual spectrum become united into a single sexual whole, then the logic of a same sex sexual union is 2
16:46 half males become a whole male, 2 half females become a whole female. In other words, your your a person is conceiving of their own sexual identity as half, not in
16:58 relation to the other sex of the 2 parts of the sexual spectrum, but rather half in relation to one's own sex. And and why is that? Why why
17:10 would a person be and here we're getting into also philosophical elements of the discussion, the key and the theological elements of the discussion, which is why would a person be erotically
17:22 aroused by what they already essentially are, A male being aroused by essential masculinity or a female being aroused by essential femininity.
17:34 And the reason for that is is actually just fairly obvious. A person is not who experiences that attraction and arouses her for what they already essentially are is
17:46 experiencing that because they don't actually perceive themselves as whole in their masculinity of male or whole in their femininity of female. This is what Paul labels in Romans
17:58 1. Just by the way, as you can see, I mean, I can do a whole semester course and beyond on this. I could do an entire year course on this, and I could write a thousand pages on the subject. So it's up to you
18:10 to just, you
18:10 know Jump in.
18:11 Interject if you think I'm going off and I'm not helping to change it.
18:14 I'm I'm actually very interested in where you're going with this, particular part. Yes.
18:18 Okay. Paul describes this, phenomenon in Romans 1, as you know, Romans 1 24 to 27, as a dishonoring of oneself and ofShow more
Comments No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Comments
Keep it kind. Comments are public.