Skip to content 83: Why Church Splits Happen | Reverend Rob Renfroe & Garry Ingraham Aug 22 · 1 hr 8 min ...more
83: Why Church Splits Happen | Reverend Rob Renfroe & Garry Ingraham
August 22, 2025 · 1 hr 8 min
Mainline denominations around the world have gone through schisms and splits. Divergent views on human sexuality and LGBTQ+ identity are often two of the most prominent and public areas of division
Series Love & Truth Network Podcast - Video Edition
Love & Truth Network equips pastors and local churches to restore relational & sexual wholeness and biblical identity. We accomplish this through our resources,
August 22, 2025 · 1 hr 8 min · Love & Truth Network Podcast - Video Edition
Mainline denominations around the world have gone through schisms and splits. Divergent views on human sexuality and LGBTQ+ identity are often two of the most prominent and public areas of division ...more Show the full description Show less Mainline denominations around the world have gone through schisms and splits. Divergent views on human sexuality and LGBTQ+ identity are often two of the most prominent and public areas of division
Series Love & Truth Network Podcast - Video Edition Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Support this leader
Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Give
Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
In this video 0:00 Authentic Faith and the Call to Salvation10:18 The Role of Brokenness and Healing in Faith26:51 The Journey of the United Methodist Church45:41 Grace, Truth, and the Mission of the Church1:00:12 Hope and Healing for the Broken
Authentic Faith and the Call to Salvation 0:01 If that salvation piece is not there, then, you know, you've got a you've got a really nice rotary club, or you've got the Kiwanis, or, you know, you've got0:12 a self help group, but you don't have Christianity.0:16 But that brokenness comes about, originally through broken relationships. We're broken broken in relationship. We're made whole in relationship.0:24 For more than 1 occasion when it was over, somebody just say, I don't believe you guys. I come to church every Sunday, and I see you. And you look so happy, and0:36 you look so successful, and you look so together. And I thought I was the only 1.0:43 And sometimes we look at someone like me or somebody that that is obviously very broken and just think, oh my gosh. You know? Thank god I'm not. But miss the fact that there's many people sitting in churches all around0:54 the country who have a form of Christianity but don't have the real life of Christ in them.1:00 But over time, it just became very apparent that we were at least 2 tribes pretending to be 1 church.1:11 What I realized by the the genuine amazing faith of this pastor and then through some conversations with him, there there was so much, so many folks within the UMC who had deep and authentic faith.1:23
1:26 The people that had left, they had to go through a difficult process. They had to take a boat in their church. They were often, assailed by their friends who saw things differently.
1:38 Our laypeople had to decide, I really believe this stuff. I really believe that the gospel is the power of God unto salvation, and we are willing to contend for
1:50 it.
2:13 Well, hey, friends. Thank you so much for tuning in. Whether you're coming to us through Love and Truth Network or through Transforming Congregations, we're glad that you're here and that you've joined us for another
2:22 episode of the Love and Truth Network podcast. Today, I'm joined by Rob Renfro. He has been the president of Good News for a long, long time, a renewal ministry within the
2:34 United Methodist Church originally, and that has, was formed, I believe, in 19 67. You have to correct me if I'm wrong on that, Rob. But, would love for you to share a little bit, Rob, with our listeners and viewers
2:46 on some of your own history within good news, obviously. But just to go back and even share, some of your own story of coming to faith and, what what that looked like for you kind of before and after.
2:57 Well, I'd love to do that, and thank you so much for having me on, Gary. I've been enjoyed getting to know you and seeing your ministry, and it's amazing, and it's such important work. So thank you for allowing me to
3:09 have this time with you and Certainly. Those that are watching and listening. So I wish I really had 1 of these, you know, I was a drug addict, and I was lost in sin and a depraved
3:20 life. So it's my story, and I'm very grateful for what God did for me. But it's not that story, but it does illustrate something. Not only did it bring me
3:32 into right relationship with God, but it illustrates something that I felt like later people in churches needed to hear. So I grew up going to First United Methodist Church in Texas Texas
3:44 City. That's right on the Gulf Coast near Galveston and kinda close to Houston. And I went to Sunday school. I went to church. I went to church camp when I was
3:56 12 or 13. I heard a minister there say you should read the bible every day and pray. And so I had my bible right beside my, bed, and I I read at least a
4:08 little bit every night instead of prayer. And growing up, I was the good kid. I was yes, ma'am, no, sir, very polite, never gave my parents any trouble whatsoever.
4:21 So somehow in high school, I began to think, I wonder how I can be certain I'm gonna go to heaven. And that just became a question I
4:32 began to think about. And I realized that, nobody was perfect. So it wasn't
4:44 like you had to make a hundred on the test to get in because nobody was gonna do that. But I kinda wondered, well, how good do you have to be? And at this time, I was getting ready to go to college,
4:57 and I heard the best news in the world. And it was that at college, you didn't have to make a 90 to get an a. You just had to beat out the other kids because they graded on the curve. And that
5:09 was very cool because I've been beaten out the other kids for a long while. When you are skinny, pencil necked, no girl is interested in you. You have no athletic ability. You got a lot of time to hit those books, baby.
5:21 So that was my sweet spot. And so then I thought, well, you know, nobody's gonna get there by scoring a hundred before god, so god's got a grade on the curve. So
5:33 I wonder what percentage you have to be in to get curved up. I've really kinda thought this way. I know it sounds bizarre, but but it's how I was thinking. And so I started looking at the other kids that I saw as the
5:43 competition. Seriously. And so they were drinking, drugging, sexing, cursing. Some were stealing things. And those were just the other kids in the youth group, the church youth group. And I thought,
5:56 wow. The kids outside are even worse. So I thought, you know, if God takes the top 20 percent, man, I'm definitely in. I am good. If he takes the top 10 percent of good
6:07 people, I still think I'm pretty good, You know, not realizing that spiritual pride, which I was guilty of, is the greatest of all sins and actually the only sin that can ultimately keep you
6:19 out of heaven. So the summer before my senior year in high school, we got a summer youth director. His name was Eddie Wills. And this was right, if you'll remember, if you
6:31 saw the movie The Jesus Revolution, it was right that same period. Yeah. And, other churches, other youth groups that we do have had gotten a summer youth director, and their guys were
6:43 really hip and cool. So we were really excited that we were gonna get 1, and Eddie was nothing in the world like that. He was in his early twenties. He's already going bald. He had thick glasses. I think everything he
6:54 wore was polyester. He had his shirt button up to the top button before anybody ever thought that might be cool. And he was so pale complected that I used to think that
7:06 his, his skin reminded me of a dead mullet's belly that had washed up on the Galveston seawall. I'm exaggerating a little bit, but not much.
7:18 Mhmm.
7:18 And we were really disappointed because we were there on the coast, kind of pretend to be surfers if we weren't, and most other guys were. And he was not what we
7:30 had wanted. It took me about 2 weeks to see, and I could see it. I don't know how I saw it. It took me about 2 weeks to see that Eddie
7:42 knew God. Mhmm. And I realized I did not. I realized that Eddie had a real relationship with Jesus, and I had a religion
7:53 about Jesus. And the only positive thing I'll say about myself is when I saw what was real, I recognized it, and I wanted it for myself. Now that summer, I was 1 of the older
8:05 kids in the youth group, and I had a job at a restaurant, and I was working many nights. So I wasn't there all the time when the other kids were. But about a month passes by, and I go to 1 of the evening
8:17 meetings. And there they are, and all the kids are singing worship songs, and they're praying, and they're reading the bible. And I could see that they knew God.
8:30 And it made me really angry. I mean, I was upset. I said, god, this isn't right. I said, I haven't done any of the things that they've done. And now they get to know you, and I don't get to know you. That's not right.
8:41 Yeah. I've been in that top 10 percent. What's going on?
8:45 Yeah. Come on. A little something for the effort, please. So, I went and talked with Eddie. And, pretty much in these
8:57 words, not quite, but what he says was, Rob, there's a difference between being a good kid and being god's kid. And you've been a pretty good kid. But all have sinned. All have fallen
9:08 short. All need grace. All need a savior. All need to accept Jesus as that savior. And so I did. So that's
9:21 how I came to faith in Christ. And that helped me that helped define the direction of my life because I had the sense that there were many
9:33 people in for me, it was a United Methodist denomination, but in mainline denominations who had never really heard just what Eddie had shared with me.
9:45 Because I thought about all the messages I had heard, and it wasn't that they were bad, but it was pretty much, okay. We need to be really good people. We try to need we need
9:57 to follow more the example of Jesus and treat each other right. Man, I've preached those sermons, and that's a good message. But if it's not coupled with
10:09 for all of sin and fallen short, and it's by grace you're saved, through faith, if that salvation piece is not there, then, you
The Role of Brokenness and Healing in Faith
10:21 know, you've got a you've got a really nice rotary club, or you've got the Kiwanis, or, you know, you've got a self help group, but you don't have Christianity.
10:31 Yeah.
10:32 So that was part of my I think when I finally felt like I was called into the ministry, I wanted some big lightning bolt. I was getting ready to go to college and where I went
10:44 through a 3 main tracks. It was either liberal arts, we called it a little something different, or there was science and engineering, or there was architecture, and I had thought that I was gonna go into medicine. And
10:56 the classes right from the beginning were very different in the direction that they took. And so I wanted some lightning bolt, experience that assured me that this is what I
11:08 was supposed to do. But I talked with the second youth director that we had the next summer right before I was going to college, and he says, Rob, you have the gifts.
11:20 You have the sense that this is what you'd like to do, and god's already been using you this way in the lives of other young people. That's a calling. You don't need the lightning bolt. And
11:32 so I remember, I basically prayed, god, I think you need somebody in the United Methodist Church that will tell people how to accept Jesus. I don't know what pastors do. I don't know if I'll be good at what
11:44 pastors do, but I think you need somebody who will do that, and I can do that. So until you tell me different, I think that's what I'm gonna do. So that's kind of my story in a
11:56 a nutshell. I'm really grateful for my parents who took me to church and really grateful for my church that brought in somebody that led us all to faith in Christ because that was a big
12:07 big, summer for almost all of the kids in the, youth group. And probably 15 years ago now, we hadn't seen Eddie in years. And
12:19 he came to Houston, and we all gathered around him. And, you know, we just adore him, And we're so grateful for him. I don't think he had any sense of the impact that he
12:31 had on our lives. I'll tell you 1 story just because I think it's a very cool story.
12:35 Yeah.
12:37 So I asked my brother once. I said, why why do you think that Eddie had such a big impact on us? And he said, because when you talked with Eddie,
12:50 it's like you were the most important person in the world. It was like everything else went away, and all they cared about was you. And so, you know, you responded to that,
13:02 and you wanted to hear what he had to say, and you wanted to have whatever he had. My brother told me that 1 night, my brother was more of the more of a rascal than I was. Mhmm.
13:13 And, I tell people it was really great. He did all the wild things and got into trouble, and I could always tell his stories, and it hadn't cost me anything. So it was perfect for
13:25 me, man. But my brother was more conflicted about accepting Christ. And he had he accepted Christ before I did, and the change in him was dramatic. And that was another
13:37 reason that I thought there's something real here. But he had a dream, and in his dream, Jesus was on 1 side, and the devil was on the other
13:49 side. And they were both calling his name, and he didn't know what to do, and he couldn't make a decision. And then he looked,
14:01 and in his dream, there was Eddie. And so he just jumped into Eddie's arms. And it was kinda like, I don't know what decision to make, but I know that I would be safe with
14:13 Eddie, and I'm gonna make the right decision if I'm with him. So it's always from the get go been a reminder that, yeah,
14:24 people need Jesus. I mean, that's what you and I have given our lives to. But most people experience Jesus through a person who says, come here. It's safe to
14:36 be here with me. And I'm gonna love you no matter what you decide, but I'm also gonna end up pointing you to Christ. So always begin with love and, and keep
14:48 loving even when we end up having to tell people the truth.
14:53 Well, Rob, I I mean, you're you're speaking our language as as a ministry both for Love and Truth Network as well as Transforming Congregations. I mean, it's we we say over and over again as our ministries focus
15:06 on equipping pastors and leaders especially, but also moms, dads, strugglers, but that our ministry focuses on restoring sexual and relational wholeness and I and biblical identity, but that
15:17 brokenness comes about, originally through broken relationships. Revoke broken in relationship, we're made whole in relationship. And Yeah. What you're describing about Eddie, I mean, there's so many different things
15:27 kinda going off in my brain about that about him and and just the way you described him and how, you know, I I can't help but think about the fact that so many churches today,
15:40 and probably churches back then, but so many churches today wouldn't even give someone who looked like Eddie, a chance. I mean, you know, the idea of of this outer appearance and and not
15:51 only outer appearance, there'd be other things too. But I think for so many churches, even, you know, wanting someone who can, the kids are gonna be quickly relatable to and kinda be on their level. And I I
16:03 could see Eddie being passed over by so many churches today, and yet that's where that's where the real life was. That was where God was, you know, pouring out and and giving you, you know, casting vision for
16:15 what real life looks like. I mean, what what are your thoughts about I mean, so you you know Eddie. You know what he looks like. And and and that initial reaction you even had, wouldn't that
16:27 probably be a lot of the reaction of many churches that might even consider hiring him and kind of pass over? Don't you think?
16:34 I think, you you know, as you were talking reminded me, we have this treasure in clay vessels. And and where Paul said, to the Corinthians, you know, not many of you were wise,
16:47 went through their bona fides, and they ended up, you know, lacking in in every department. Yeah. But we have this treasure in, clay vessels, and
16:58 it's the treasure that changes lives and that people are drawn to. And the, outer appearance, of of the vessel isn't
17:10 nearly as important. And people are looking for love, and people are looking for compassion and grace. And when it's there,
17:23 and I'm not just talking about a kind of a shallow acceptance or just, oh, you're fine just the way you are, but somebody that truly cares and wants to be involved in their story and wants what's best for them.
17:34 I'll tell you what I was thinking of, Gary, right after you responded to my story. I know enough of your story to know that was with a group of men who loved you and accepted you.
17:45 Yes.
17:45 That there was a transforming power that came into your life. So both of us, our lives tell the same story just from, you know, very different, well, you grew up in the church too, but
17:57 from from different places.
17:59 Yeah.
18:00 We ended up just where the love and compassion of someone who saw us and cared about us and treated us like we mattered, made a huge difference in our lives.
18:10 Yes. Well and I I think what you're sharing there and what you're sharing in your story, I I I feel like I'm going to kind of fail at describing what's in my heart about what I wanna say about this,
18:22 but I I really want those that are are listening or watching this to lean into this for a moment because, so the the book that I wrote, the the title of it is Am I Gay? The
18:34 subtitle of it though is Coming Out of Cultural Christianity and LGBTQ Identity into Authentic Faith in Christ. And and so that I needed to be saved every
18:46 bit as much from a cultural Christianity where and and in many ways, it's it's easier to spot the real broken places. It's easier to spot where, you know, my
18:58 behavior's out of control, and I don't even like what I'm doing, and yet I'm compelled and addicted or whatever you wanna talk about, whether that's LGBT or it's homo it's heterosexual or whatever the case is, or it's
19:09 not even maybe a sexual brokenness. But But but what I love about your story, and there's a woman on our website, her name is Sherry, and and what she shares about her story is it reminds me of yours. It's very different
19:20 than yours, but it reminds me of someone who grew up in the church, didn't have a ton of their own sexual brokenness or none of those issues, and and yet through other circumstances around them, took on this
19:32 kind of shame, that drove her from a very early age to I just wanna get married and have a good family, and everything about her revolved around the image of her family and
19:43 Yeah.
19:44 And and and was oftentimes just suppressing a lot of the the the brokenness or junk that was going on because the casting that image was so essential. Yeah. But but that idea, it doesn't matter whether
19:56 we are caught up in all kinds of crazy addictive patterns, whether it's substance abuse or behavioral patterns of some kind or another, sexual brokenness, or or we just have
20:08 we've grown up in kind of a cultural form of Christianity, and we're we're doing a lot of the right things, and yet it's it's not authentic. It's not connected to the source of Christ. We've never fully surrendered, you
20:20 know, to to salvation and and his finished work. Regardless of where where we are, we're broken and we're lost.
20:26 Mhmm.
20:26 And so I think it's so important that we recognize that that issue, that sometimes we look at someone like me or somebody that that is obviously very broken and just think, oh my gosh, you know, thank god I'm not,
20:39 but miss the fact that we can there's many people sitting in churches all around the country who have a form of Christianity but don't have Yeah. The real life of Christ in them. And and so I
20:50 think it's important that we address this kind of genuine authentic faith
20:55 Right.
20:55 Knowing that no matter what it looks like on the outside, a person can be just as lost as the prostitute or the the drug addict, and as anyone else. So I don't know.
21:07 That's the
21:08 the Pharisee that, thank you, God. I'm not like other people. That's basically what I was saying. You know, he was saying, thank you, God. I'm in the top 10 percent. And so yeah. And who went away absolutely lost.
21:20 You know, not the tax collector beat his breast and said save me a sinner. Let me build on something, Gary. There's there's another reality within the church,
21:32 and that is people who have been broken, and they do have true faith in Christ.
21:41 Mhmm.
21:41 But they've never been invited to do the work or knew that there was work that they could do so that that brokenness could be healed. And here I'm not talking about sexuality. For
21:53 many years and, I don't know, a dozen times or more, I've led a a course called Making Peace with Your Past. It was, produced by a Baptist pastor who grew up the son of an alcoholic.
22:05 He compensated by being a very high achiever, and then later in his ministry, he his life just fell apart. He went to a, kind of a a
22:17 healing center based on the 12 steps, and he came back and he created a workbook from what he learned there and then also, faith in Christ. And I have done that with,
22:31 like I say, at least a dozen times. I've done it with men and women together. Doesn't work. I've done it with just women. I have I've moved away from that. And so the majority of the time has just been with men.
22:43 Yeah. And the I don't tell them this book is for those of us who grew up in dysfunctional families because many guys don't think they grew up in a dysfunctional family, just in a real family.
22:55 And so this is for if you grew up and things happened in your, childhood or teen years that you think are still keeping you from full joy and effectiveness in life, this is of course
23:07 for you. And then it starts off about, here's the characteristics of a dysfunctional family. And I've had guys call me up because they're supposed to read the first chapter before we get there and say, Rob, I think I'm
23:16 in the wrong group. This is for people with dysfunctional families. I said, read the whole chapter. Right. And they start listing, Dysfunctional families this. And they said, well, yeah. We had some of that.
23:26 Dysfunctional family yeah. We had a lot of that. It was like check, check, check, check.
23:30 Yes.
23:31 So this has happened more than once, Gary. We have that first session. We're in a small room, so we're seating close together, kind of a
23:43 lounge furniture, but we're not sprawled out. I I want it to feel close. I want it to feel like we're all in this together. And I say, who is prepared to start
23:55 and to be honest? Who is ready to tell us what happened to you when you were young? And the pain that it caused? And
24:06 who's ready to tell what you did to take away that pain and that shame that only created more problems in your life than in the lives of others. And if the first
24:18 person will be honest with this, everybody shares things they've never shared with anyone before.
24:26 That's right.
24:26 I've had on more than 1 occasion when it was over, somebody just say, I don't believe you guys. I come to church every Sunday, and I see you,
24:39 and you look so happy, and you look so successful, and you look so together. And I thought I was the only 1.
24:47 Yes.
24:49 So, nobody is the only 1. I mean, you have your story. It's unique to you, but we all end up getting broken and many people in ways that
25:01 are devastating and and create great pain and shame and guilt and confusion. And they may even come to accept
25:13 Christ, but they still live with all of that. They've got real faith, but they don't know what to do with any of that. And Yeah. Typical male gutted up, just work through it, ignore
25:24 it, succeed it, and then, of course, drink it, drug it, sex it,
25:29 those
25:29 kind of negative things too. But even guys that don't make those mistakes, they don't know what to do with it. I think that and I know you agree. There there's kind of 2 forms
25:41 of spirituality, and I think this may be kind of part of what you were getting into. And 1 is, let's all come to church and just really be happy for what Jesus has done for us and let's put on our happy for
25:53 what Jesus has done for us face. And we won't talk about the other stuff.
25:59 Right.
25:59 And that looks like a great church, and it looks like a great spiritual family, but it's not spiritual at all. I'm not saying they're not true believers, but that is not good, healthy, true spirituality. True
26:11 spirituality is so certain of the love of God that you can put your arms around what changed you and, the
26:23 the ugliness and the parts where you think if anybody knew me for who I was, they wouldn't want me around. Real churches that are committed to true spirituality make places for
26:35 people to share that and to share those secrets. I know you know this. Secrets make you sick. And because we all have this these secrets, all of us have some kind of sickness. So
26:47 real spirituality makes it possible for you to embrace the totality of our humanity and end up bringing it to Christ. Mhmm.Show more
Comments No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Comments
Keep it kind. Comments are public.