Skip to content 28: Unwanted Same-Sex Attraction | Cole Atkinson & Garry Ingraham Aug 25 · 50 min ...more
28: Unwanted Same-Sex Attraction | Cole Atkinson & Garry Ingraham
August 25, 2025 · 50 min
Raised in a loving Christian home, Cole Atkinson had always been looked upon as the 'golden boy' of his family. But he had a secret. In his teens he discovered he was feeling attractions toward men.
Series Love & Truth Network Podcast - Video Edition August 25, 2025 · 50 min · Love & Truth Network Podcast - Video Edition
Raised in a loving Christian home, Cole Atkinson had always been looked upon as the 'golden boy' of his family. But he had a secret. In his teens he discovered he was feeling attractions toward men. ...more Show the full description Show less Raised in a loving Christian home, Cole Atkinson had always been looked upon as the 'golden boy' of his family. But he had a secret. In his teens he discovered he was feeling attractions toward men.
Series Love & Truth Network Podcast - Video Edition Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Support this leader
Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Give
Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
49.1K followers
Love & Truth Network equips pastors and local churches to restore relational & sexual wholeness and biblical identity. We accomplish this through our resources,
49.1K followers
In this video 0:00 Struggles with Identity and Faith2:00 The Power of Vulnerability and Community20:00 Healing Through Authenticity and Brotherhood40:00 Living in Freedom and Purpose
Struggles with Identity and Faith 0:01 Started to notice I was very different from my friends. I, all of the boys around me were really interested in girls, wanted to hang out with them, and I was more interested in them, my friends.0:13 Trying to understand, wow, what is it about them that is is different from me but also alluring and attractive and they're having all these feelings for girls and I don't have those so maybe there's something wrong with0:24 me. If I'm struggling with this, this weird thing, what's that gonna do to my family? What's that gonna do to my parents if I disappoint them by telling them that I have something like this?0:36 And so I kept it hidden and I decided I would never tell anybody. I0:41 don't think that we as human beings thrive in that. I think we thrive when we know our boundaries. Those boundaries provide a sense of safety. And then there's room to explore. There's room to enjoy God0:52 and life and others, even ourselves and relationship to others. But those boundaries help protect us. And when they're gone, it's a very frightening place to be.1:02 Around kind of my my junior year, still in pornography, and at this point, I was hitting a breaking point and I began to engage in relationships online with other men. I was kind of out there seeking,1:15 found somebody online that I connected with and started a relationship with.1:20 Regardless of what we struggle with, again, someone who's never dealt with same sex attraction or those issues, but, the the phrase is same root, different fruit. Meaning, all of that plays into the
1:32 the the kind of fruit that's born, but so often, it's the same that we share similar root issues.
1:38 I am not what I struggle with was, I think, a key point for me to kind of start to wrap my mind around, okay, if I can kind of divorce who I am from this struggle and realize that it is
1:50 something I struggle with and not who I am, it is now something that I struggle with which is something that I can I can tackle, that I can find ways to deal with?
The Power of Vulnerability and Community
2:22 Well, hey. Thanks so much for tuning in for another episode of the Love and Truth Network podcast. I'm so glad that you're here and joining us. Once again, for those that have been with us the last few episodes, you'll
2:32 know that we're shooting from the American Association of Christian Counselors Conference. We are here in the, Opryland, resort. What an incredible place. I've been here several times,
2:44 and every single time, I get lost. I mean, it's just an amazing, myriad of different, beautiful settings and space, indoors, but, man, it is a huge place. So, anyway, we're
2:56 here to get together, Jeremiah, our team exhibiting here and having lots of great conversations. And a fun thing about this kind of conference is we get to catch up with old friends. You've heard already from some
3:08 of both my brother, my sister-in-law who's here, and some other friends that are here, and Edward, we had a, conversation with. But another thing that's fun about these conferences are is meeting new people and making
3:19 new friends. And so I've just made a new friend while we're here. His name is Cole, and he, has some connection. I'll let him tell you his own story. But he has some connection with a ministry, a really long term
3:30 connection with a ministry, that I've loved for a long time and have been connected with the executive director of for a long time, Jason Thompson. And so really happy to have him here with us to share some of his story
3:41 and then for us just to have some dialogue that hopefully will be of encouragement to you and hope building for you as well. So, Cole, thanks so much for joining us for this episode.
3:49 Hey. Thanks for having me. This is great. What a pleasant surprise.
3:52 Yeah. Yeah. It's kinda fun. Yeah. So, what what is it in terms of your story?
3:58 Mhmm.
3:58 What are you comfortable kind of sharing with us about a a bit of your journey? I know it's hard to to take a lifetime of, of stuff Yeah. And and condense it into 10 or 15 minutes. But, you know, just share some of your
4:10 story with us.
4:11 I'll give it my best shot. Alright. Yeah. But so, yes. Part of the reason probably you and I are having having this conversation, the biggest piece of it is I grew up struggling with same sex attraction. So, I'll start
4:21 at the beginning and kind of work my way through. But, so I was born, raised into a Christian family. Mhmm. I had great Christian believers. Mhmm. Grew up going to church, all of those good things. I've got an older
4:33 sister and a younger brother that were great companions through life.
4:37 Yep.
4:38 But really found early on in my life that I did not connect very well with men. Mhmm. I was a little bit emotionally distanced from my father. My brother and I didn't quite get along very much, but I
4:49 had really loving women in my life Yes. That grew doted on me, that really cared for me. I was a very emotional companion for a lot of the women that I was around. Mhmm. And through
5:01 that journey, just kind of later in life, probably around middle school when I started to develop some sort of sexual identity. You know, as a kid, you don't really understand what any of that means. But at
5:13 some point, around puberty, starting to develop what is sexuality, what is this. Started to notice I was very different from my friends. Mhmm. I, all of the boys around me were really interested in girls,
5:25 wanted to hang out with them, and I was more interested in them, my friends.
5:30 Right.
5:30 Trying to understand, wow, what is it about them that is is different from me, but also alluring and attractive? And they're having all these feelings for girls, and I don't have those. So maybe there's something wrong
5:41 with me. Mhmm. Just as time wore on, kind of beginning to understand what that meant in my life, what this kind of difference in sexual attraction
5:57 what what does this mean? What does this look like for
5:59 me? Right.
6:00 And, I very remember vividly in freshman year of high school, it kind of sunk in. It was this moment of, oh, I'm very different. This is not changing.
6:12 I think I'm gay. Mhmm. I'm having these thoughts and attractions that nobody else is having. Nobody's talking about them. I think I'm the only 1. And a big part of kind of what that did
6:24 to me was it sunk me into a huge depression.
6:26 Mhmm.
6:26 I kind of felt like my future had been pulled out from under me or that there was no future for me. Part of my childhood, I'd grown up kind of the golden child of the family, the 1 that tried to keep the family apart as,
6:37 you know, brother and sister did this and that. I felt like a lot of the family's honor or dignity kind of rested on me as a child. And, so that was really crushing
6:49 to say, if I'm struggling with this, this weird thing
6:53 Yep.
6:54 What's that gonna do to my family? Mhmm. What's that gonna do to my parents if I disappoint them Mhmm. By telling them that I have something like this? Yep. And so I kept it hidden, and I decided I would never tell
7:05 anybody. But I also felt like that stripped me of a future of things that I did want. Yep. I'd always pictured myself, you know, the normal kid, grown up, getting married, having kids eventually of
7:17 my own, and, just being a normal person. And it felt like I couldn't be that anymore. Mhmm. So depression for a long time, and eventually, through some help, I my parents took
7:29 me to counseling. They were wonderful through the whole process. Yep. Was able to kind of pull myself out of the depression and decided I'm just never gonna talk about this again. I'll sweep it under the rug, pretend
7:40 like it doesn't exist, and I'll try and move on with my life as best as I can.
7:44 And so that came out in the counseling office? I mean, it did it came up there?
7:48 Kind of. Yes. Well, yes and no. So I was I was probably a terrible counselee. Mhmm. I never actually spoke about it in the counseling. I was too scared to tell a soul, even somebody that wasn't my
8:00 family members.
8:01 Right.
8:01 I couldn't bring myself to talk about my sexual attractions. I was so confused by them. I didn't understand them. I didn't want them.
8:08 Yep.
8:09 And they scared me. Yep. And and to speak it out loud would to make it true and would to mean that this was a reality that I had to deal with. Yeah. And so I would rather pretend Yeah. That it wasn't Suppress
8:20 it and just
8:21 suppress it. And I would, you know, tell my parents I'm sad because of all these other things. Yeah. Because of friends or because, I just don't feel like I fit in. You name it, I found ways to kind of talk around it. So
8:32 never even spoke it to a counselor. But in that process, I think just kind of solidified this idea that I could tamper it down and I could keep it under control and it would never arise again. Yep. And that's
8:44 how I would move forward. So the counsel not necessarily in the counseling, but through the counseling and having people talk at me and and having to think about what I'm gonna say to these people,
8:56 was kind of how I came to that conclusion of I'm not going to talk about it.
9:00 Okay.
9:00 So in that way, counseling was a part of it.
9:03 Okay. Yeah. And and about how old were you do you think when you just decided I'm just Yeah. Just sealed the deal even deeper, I'm just not going to talk about this.
9:11 Yeah. That that was around junior year of high school. So freshman year, big realization, big depression, for about a year and a half. Mhmm. Just absolutely, you know, despondence. It comes through my whole
9:23 life. I used to say, I tried to will myself into nonexistence. Yes. Yes. I I wasn't suicidal necessarily
9:28 Right.
9:28 Borderline, but just didn't wanna be around anymore. But then, yeah, through that time about junior year, going into senior year, I was, like, burying it. We're moving on. I'm gonna just try and enjoy life however
9:40 I can.
9:41 Yep.
9:41 Yep. And and so
9:42 Okay.
9:44 But that doesn't last very long. You can't do that. You can't with with, all of these emotions and all of these this part of our sexual identity, it's not something that you can push aside or temper. It's always gonna
9:54 come back up. Mhmm. So, college was kind of the next big moment in my journey with sexual identity, with sexual, understanding, and and sexual feelings. First time out on my
10:06 own. I I went to college away from town, away from my parents, away from home, and there's just unprecedented freedom. And the first thing I did was get addicted to pornography. Mhmm. It was the first time I'd really
10:17 encountered it or got to engage with it, and it was like this it just consumed me at that time. And I was still very much a Christian, very much still going to church. All throughout high school, I tried to
10:29 do youth group, went to conferences, very much loved Jesus, but now I had this other big sin thing in my life that I couldn't ignore. Mhmm. Thought I could ignore my sexuality, and now
10:41 I'm dealing with pornography. And that's when the real kind of pull intention started to become too much.
10:47 Yep. Yep.
10:49 So faith So
10:50 not much pornography before then? No. Okay.
10:53 No. I didn't I I didn't have access to it. I had I had tried a couple of times. Yep. And and so funny, I forget this event, but I'd even been caught by my parents at 1 point.
11:02 Okay.
11:02 And I remember my dad having a conversation with me being like, what is this? What's going on? Mhmm. And I took all my energy to convince him that that wasn't a permanent thing. Yep. This is not me. It's just a phase
11:13 Mhmm. Using all kinds of language, and whether he bought it, I don't know. I should I should ask him. I'm like, was that convincing when I tried to do that Right. Years ago. But, he he let it he let it be and never spoke
11:25 about it again. Good grief. Whether he was trusting me that it was just a phase or just to know how to connect with it. Either way, I I I couldn't blame him too much. But yeah. So up until that point, never really
11:36 experienced pornography. Knew it existed Mhmm. And knew it was something that I probably wanted to get into, but never had the opportunity until college. Yeah. And then it just became overwhelming. It it was quick
11:46 addiction Mhmm. And as as often as I could. And, that was just a new level of sin and struggle that I had never really done for. I've always been a really good kid. Yep.
11:58 Made all the rules, did all the good things, went to church. And now I was dealing with something new. Yes. Something really intense.
12:04 And something that quickly took a hold of you.
12:06 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It was it was strange to be consumed by something that you think you're in control always of your life, and then the realization when you're not can be very scary.
12:15 Yes.
12:15 That didn't come till a little bit later, but, it really was a weird and wild twisted journey there at the beginning.
12:21 Okay.
12:22 So so, yeah, spent the first couple of years in college, really just kind of trying to be as normal as I could, whatever that means at the time. Just engage with normal college activities,
12:34 be a regular person, dealing with pornography on the side, trying to go to church when I could, when my spirit would allow me to. There were times where I felt so guilty and so shameful. Yeah. Couldn't even step into
12:46 church. Yep. But, I but tried as best I could. Mhmm. And so for about 2 years, really kind of struggled back and forth with this, back and forth, back and forth, being pulled in 2 different directions. And about
12:57 my junior year, I like to say I did 2 junior years. I was in college for 5 years.
13:02 Right.
13:02 Right. Fifth year senior. Mhmm. But around kinda my my junior year, I I hit a breaking point. I had gone abroad and did a study abroad, which was unbelievable and really fun, but
13:14 come back to an even stronger addiction Mhmm. Of pornography and a stronger feeling of loss of community. I had no people, no friends when I moved back Yep. And was and couldn't bring myself to go to church anymore.
13:26 So still in pornography. And at this point, I was hitting a breaking point. And I began to engage in relationships online with other men. I was kind of out there seeking, found somebody
13:38 online that I connected with and started a relationship with. And I'll I'll I'll jump ahead in this. So 1 thing that always struck out to me later on in life when I was reflecting on this
13:50 is that relationship with him never turned sexual. And I didn't want it
13:55 to. Okay.
13:55 Which was very strange to me. Even during that time of, like, I thought that's what I was after. I thought that's what I wanted. But later during my reflection time on it, after I'd kind of gotten some healing,
14:07 was I just wanted somebody to know me and like me.
14:10 Yes.
14:10 Want to know me and love me and to say, this person knows exactly what I'm going through. I would tell them I'm I'm gay. I'm having these struggles. Mhmm. I didn't use the word struggles, but, I have these feelings. And
14:21 he said, great. That's super cool. Me too. Mhmm. And was interested in me. And to have that combination was a powerful thing.
14:28 But never crossed sexual boundary lines.
14:29 Never crossed sexual boundary lines. Wow. And I remember even in the in that relationship thinking, is it that's what you wanna do. Right? And and something in me was like, no. No. No. Don't ruin this. Right. Don't you
14:41 don't wanna go there. So I I think that's just a spirit thing. I really see God's hand protecting me from engaging in behaviors that would I would have to unravel later on, and so I'm thankful for that.
14:52 Yeah. For sure.
14:55 But, during this time, this is when my breakup with Jesus happened. Mhmm. I came to a point where I I had found somebody that could accept me and love me, and I was I couldn't reconcile my same
15:07 sex attraction in Christianity. So I I came before God and I said, hey. 1 of these gotta go. Right. These 2 things don't mix. Yep. And my attractions aren't going anywhere. So do you see
15:17 not changing them.
15:19 I'm not changing. I don't know.
15:20 Mean, God's not changing them either.
15:21 Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Thanks to God. I'm like, you're not doing anything about this. I've asked. I've prayed. I pleaded. I you I obviously don't want this, Lord. Mhmm. But 1 of you's gotta go. You can't live together,
15:31 and I can't change the attraction, so it's gotta be you. Yep. Jesus, you gotta go. And it was my my breakup moment with Jesus. Yeah. I very clearly remember him saying, you're gonna be back. I'll let you go, but you're
15:41 gonna be back. And I hated that. I said, you don't know that, Lord. Right. Yeah. That came to bite. Yeah. He's like, well, yeah. I do. But but after that, spent a lot of time trying to de
15:53 Christianize myself. I tried to really walk away from Jesus, push anything that I knew that was kind of attaching me to any sort of holiness or good person isk, And I just wanted to live my
16:05 life in whatever way I wanted to.
16:07 Mhmm.
16:07 And it was miserable. Yes. It was so miserable. I had no framework, no structure for my soul. I I was completely empty. So every little inconvenience, every little,
16:20 hardship in my life, I I would just collapse into this messy pile of depression and woe is me.
16:25 Yep.
16:26 There was nothing to rely on. And so I just remember being an awful time.
16:30 Well, and part of that too, I wonder I don't wanna I don't wanna get you off track of your story. Please. But part of it, that I've realized is we actually thrive when we have
16:41 boundaries, not not walls that are so constricting, which sometimes our Christian religious background is sometimes that way. Like, all we know
16:48 are the do's and don'ts. Mhmm.
16:50 And it's so constricting, and it's so limited. But to also be in a in a space where there are absolutely no boundaries, there's no fence, it's just this wide open space. I don't think that we as human beings thrive
17:02 in that. I think we thrive when we know our boundaries. Those boundaries provide a sense of safety. Yeah. And then there's room to explore. There's room to enjoy God and life and others,
17:14 even ourselves and relationship to others. But those boundaries help protect us. And when they're gone, it's a very frightening place to be.
17:22 Oh, absolutely. And and I had never even heard of boundaries until much later when I started going through, like, Portland Fellowship and understanding how good and beneficial they were. But to me, a lot of that would
17:32 but like you said before, were just walls. They were just things to keep me in Yep. And, and to control me and to but, I think 1 of the things that I often think about is when I lowered those boundaries, you're also
17:44 letting a lot of things in. Mhmm. And a lot of there's no protection from bad things. Yes. And so there is it it was exciting at first. I remember being like, oh, I'm I'm finally free.
17:56 Yes.
17:56 I don't I don't have anything weighing me down. I can live how I want to, but the stuff that came into my life, was was horrifying and and terrible. And, there's nothing to protect you if you don't have any boundaries.
18:08 So it that freedom to have within good boundaries and well established boundaries and boundaries of love, are extremely important Yes. In all of our lives.
18:17 No. Absolutely. Absolutely. What, where where did your shift begin to happen Mhmm. Where like, you were you did say deconstruct you weren't working to
18:29 deconstruct your faith. Maybe there was a little bit of that. But but you, where did you kind of begin to reengage with Jesus again with, with the father again?
18:38 Yeah. Oh, this this is my favorite part, and I'll probably cry. I always do. I always do. It's it's fine. It is probably it is probably my fondest memory, that I will last forever. But, there was 2 kind of incidences
18:49 that really turned the tables back to Jesus for me. 1 of them was the the guy I was in a relationship with online asked me, he says, does anybody else know that you're that you're gay? Does anybody else know
19:00 that you have these feelings?
19:01 I said, no. I can't tell anybody. Mhmm. It's very scary. And he said, you have got to tell someone or you're gonna die. This is gonna kill you. You have to tell someone. Mhmm. And he was like, how's your relationship
19:12 with your parents? And and I had a real good relationship with my parents. Yep. I really love them. And he's like, you should tell them. And and he was the 1 that actually encouraged me. I know. Yep. It's kind of 1 of
19:21 those it was so strange. The the 1 of the persons who's leading me into sin Yes. God used as a voice. Yep. It's kind of like, Balaam's donkey sort of deal. I gotta Right. He can use anything to bring bring his word to
19:32 his people. And so, I I gathered up the courage with, to tell my parents. I came home from college 1 day, and I had this whole long kind of speech written out. I'm gonna tell them I've got these weird
19:43 feelings I don't know what to do with, and I'm hopeful they'll go away. Just kind of trying to give them something hold on to while telling them what I'm really feeling. And I remember getting I halfway through and just
19:55 bawling. I couldn't even finish what I was trying to say. It was miserable. But I got the I got it out there. I got what I wanted to say out there to them. And at the time, I was sitting on the floor on the couch overShow more
Comments No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Comments
Keep it kind. Comments are public.