Skip to content What Is Critical Theory? Oct 23 · 59 min ...more
What Is Critical Theory?
October 23, 2026 · 59 min
Bradley G. Green joins Camden Bucey to discuss What Is Critical Theory?: A Concise Christian Analysis. They trace the Frankfurt School’s Marxist roots and explain why thinkers such as Theodor Adorno, Max Horkheimer, Walter Benjamin, and Herbert Marcuse turned from a narrowly economic account of oppression toward culture, institutions, authority, family, and religion.The conversation evaluates critical theory as a counterfeit religious vision with its own accounts of creation, sin, redemption, and eschatology. Drawing on Cornelius Van Til, Green shows how unbelieving thought oscillates between rationalism and irrationalism; drawing on Henry Van Til, he explains why culture is “religion externalized.”ResourcesWhat Is Critical Theory?: A Concise Christian AnalysisBradley G. Green at Southern SeminaryChrist OverallChapters00:00 Introduction04:30 Introducing What Is Critical Theory?08:14 Marxism after the failed German revolution10:43 The major Frankfurt School thinkers12:35 Culture, oppression, and the long march through the institutions15:54 Critical theory as a counterfeit religion19:06 What the critical theorists see—and miss21:56 Creation, givenness, and the autonomous individual24:05 Sin relocated from the heart to the system25:18 Marcuse’s vision of sexual liberation29:42 Utopian hope and Adorno’s “Grand Hotel Abyss”33:11 Walter Benjamin and a “messianic rupture”36:45 Repressive tolerance and the authoritarian personality42:35 Van Til on rationalism and irrationalism46:31 Culture as religion externalized49:22 Pastoral and educational applications53:55 Using the book for personal and group study56:20 ConclusionMentioned in this episode:Christ the Center 1000Christ the Center 1000 SummitChrist the Center 1000 Live in Austin, TXChrist the Center 1000 Summit
Series Reformed Forum
Reformed Forum supports the church in presenting every person mature in Christ (Colossians 1:28) by providing Reformed theological resources.
October 23, 2026 · 59 min · Reformed Forum
Bradley G. Green joins Camden Bucey to discuss What Is Critical Theory?: A Concise Christian Analysis. They trace the Frankfurt School’s Marxist roots and explain why thinkers such as Theodor Adorno, Max Horkheimer, Walter Benjamin, and Herbert Marcuse turned from a narrowly economic account of oppression toward culture, institutions, authority, family, and religion.The conversation evaluates critical theory as a counterfeit religious vision with its own accounts of creation, sin, redemption, and eschatology. Drawing on Cornelius Van Til, Green shows how unbelieving thought oscillates between rationalism and irrationalism; drawing on Henry Van Til, he explains why culture is “religion externalized.”ResourcesWhat Is Critical Theory?: A Concise Christian AnalysisBradley G. Green at Southern SeminaryChrist OverallChapters00:00 Introduction04:30 Introducing What Is Critical Theory?08:14 Marxism after the failed German revolution10:43 The major Frankfurt School thinkers12:35 Culture, oppression, and the long march through the institutions15:54 Critical theory as a counterfeit religion19:06 What the critical theorists see—and miss21:56 Creation, givenness, and the autonomous individual24:05 Sin relocated from the heart to the system25:18 Marcuse’s vision of sexual liberation29:42 Utopian hope and Adorno’s “Grand Hotel Abyss”33:11 Walter Benjamin and a “messianic rupture”36:45 Repressive tolerance and the authoritarian personality42:35 Van Til on rationalism and irrationalism46:31 Culture as religion externalized49:22 Pastoral and educational applications53:55 Using the book for personal and group study56:20 ConclusionMentioned in this episode:Christ the Center 1000Christ the Center 1000 SummitChrist the Center 1000 Live in Austin, TXChrist the Center 1000 Summit ...more Show the full description Show less Bradley G. Green joins Camden Bucey to discuss What Is Critical Theory?: A Concise Christian Analysis. They trace the Frankfurt School’s Marxist roots and explain why thinkers such as Theodor Adorno, Max Horkheimer, Walter Benjamin, and Herbert Marcuse turned from a narrowly economic account of oppression toward culture, institutions, authority, family, and religion.The conversation evaluates critical theory as a counterfeit religious vision with its own accounts of creation, sin, redemption, and eschatology. Drawing on Cornelius Van Til, Green shows how unbelieving thought oscillates between rationalism and irrationalism; drawing on Henry Van Til, he explains why culture is “religion externalized.”ResourcesWhat Is Critical Theory?: A Concise Christian AnalysisBradley G. Green at Southern SeminaryChrist OverallChapters00:00 Introduction04:30 Introducing What Is Critical Theory?08:14 Marxism after the failed German revolution10:43 The major Frankfurt School thinkers12:35 Culture, oppression, and the long march through the institutions15:54 Critical theory as a counterfeit religion19:06 What the critical theorists see—and miss21:56 Creation, givenness, and the autonomous individual24:05 Sin relocated from the heart to the system25:18 Marcuse’s vision of sexual liberation29:42 Utopian hope and Adorno’s “Grand Hotel Abyss”33:11 Walter Benjamin and a “messianic rupture”36:45 Repressive tolerance and the authoritarian personality42:35 Van Til on rationalism and irrationalism46:31 Culture as religion externalized49:22 Pastoral and educational applications53:55 Using the book for personal and group study56:20 ConclusionMentioned in this episode:Christ the Center 1000Christ the Center 1000 SummitChrist the Center 1000 Live in Austin, TXChrist the Center 1000 Summit
Series Reformed Forum
Introducing Critical Theory and the Frankfurt School 0:00 Hi. I'm Camden Busey, host of Christ the Center. And on February nineteenth and twentieth, we will record the one thousandth consecutive weekly episode of Christ the Center live in0:12 Austin, Texas, and we would love you to join us. We have never done anything like this. If you come, you'll join no more than three hundred people from around the world for two days of conversation on reformed0:24 theology and the Lord's work in missions with a banquet and breakfast included. Early bird pricing ends soon, so register at summit dot reformed forum dot org. That's0:35 summit dot reformed forum dot org. Welcome to0:47 Christ the Center, your weekly conversation of reformed theology. Now getting on episode number nine hundred eighty two. My name is Cam Debussy. I'm, in Libertyville, Illinois at reform forum headquarters as we like to0:59 call it. And And I'm happy to be back, speaking with another friend looking forward to, the conversation on reform theology and philosophy today. And to do that, I'm welcoming to the1:11 program doctor Bradley Green, professor of philosophy and Christian theology at the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary. He also works with and is cofounder of Christ Overall, our friends1:23 over there in a very similar, type of resource ministry to what we do here at reform forum. Brad, it's so good to see you. Welcome to the program. It's great to have you.
1:31 Yeah. Cameron, thanks. I'm excited to be here. I appreciate, your all's ministry and looking forward to our time together.
1:36 Yeah. Me me too. You know, just for some background to to everyone, we've... We met virtually once as we were talking with, I got... I did an interview a while back with David Schrock. We have
1:48 a OPC minister nearby me and an old friend of mine named Daniel Schrock. And to our knowledge, they're not not closely related. But David Schrock has been on the program, and, he's also involved in the work
2:00 over at Christ Overall. You can find them. I've got their website, right here, christ overall dot com. And, check them out. And a lot of great articles, podcast, all sorts of wonderful
2:12 material there. So we were able to chat a little bit and just talk and compare notes a while back. And then to be able to, connect face to face at the Rome Scholars and Leaders Network,
2:24 in June in Rome with our with our dear friends there, Leonardo and Clay. And, oh my goodness, Reid. It was so fun to have everyone there and to to get to meet
2:36 in person. Now you've that's something you've been part of for for a while now, hasn't it?
2:40 Yeah. I go most summers
2:42 going
2:42 back to two thousand seventeen. It's it's, one of my favorite kind of speaking trips, a lot of fellowship as well. It's it's a great it's a great group. I encourage folks to consider it.
2:53 Yeah. I really appreciated your your, speaking. I mean, we were talking a bit about Peter Kreft and his new book Yeah. Which is, you know, a little disturbing. But, I
3:05 mean, talking about those conversion to Roman Catholicism and some of the reasons he gave, but it was an interesting an interesting lecture. And then also speaking about your your background and history and classical
3:17 education. I'm sure some people might be interested to know about that. You recently made a move, but back in Jackson, Tennessee, you... For a long time, you you you founded or got started a classical Christian school.
3:29 And, certainly, you're passionate about that. Can you let us know a bit about that? People would love to hear it.
3:34 Sure. Yep. Yep. Yeah. So, Augustine School is a school we helped start in Jackson, Tennessee. It's part of this classical Christian education movement or network. Mhmm.
3:46 And
3:46 we just celebrated twenty five years. Yeah. And, and so the, the... All three of my children came to Augustine School. I'm still on the board. It's thriving.
3:58 Like every school, the challenges of a start... Startup, the typical challenges
4:04 of I'm living it, brother. We know it. Yeah. We we know. I live in it in many ways. The school, the church, my... The work here. Yeah. We get we get it.
4:14 Yeah. And if you wanna make a donation to Camden Busey at the reform forum... Yeah. So, but it's a part of our story
4:21 Yeah.
4:22 And I'm very thankful. And trying to work through what does the lordship of Christ look like in education and learning. It's been a long time. Passion. And, I'm very
4:34 thankful for Augustine School. I'm thankful to the Lord that we're still standing twenty five years later and thriving.
4:39 Oh, Christian Ed is so important. I know, you know, I've not only talked about things like that and our shared reformed convictions, but, our shared love of Van Till and and, things
4:51 downstream of Van Till, which we'll certainly get into today. So there's so much there in terms of Christian Ed. Perhaps another day, we'll... We we can talk and plumb the depths of that. I'd love to. But today, we're
5:03 gonna get into it certainly thinking critically, no pun intended, but we are going to be speaking about this this new book, if I get the lighting right. What is Critical Theory? A Concise Christian
5:15 Analysis by our author. Our guest today wrote the book, and it's published by Crossway. I believe it came out in March twenty twenty six, but, we got a copy here today, and I'm excited to to speak
5:26 about this. This is such a... An important topic. We've been speaking about it, you know, for the last several years. This has come up in cultural discourse, but there isn't there isn't always a great understanding
5:38 of of what it is. And, there are a handful of little books and intros to it, but many of the... Much of the literature that's out there, it's either too dense, and and very,
5:50 difficult to to access and might require, you know, graduate education just to get into some of the literature on the subject. Or the other end, it isn't literature. It's just people spouting off on podcasts and
6:02 cable news talking about Yeah. Critical theory and, those types of of things. And most people might hear this. And you you mentioned this in the intro and in the book itself that many listeners or readers might hear
6:14 critical theory and they think immediately of critical race theory. That's not entirely outside of our purview, we might say. But I wonder if you would be willing to really define or set the limits of what
6:26 you're addressing in this book in terms of critical theory and even why you chose to focus on the older Frankfurt School thinkers. I think that introducing them would be useful to us. Sure.
6:37 Thanks, Ken. Mhmm. Yeah. Essentially, more than one person, when I heard I was writing the book, they they said, well, I can't wait to see what you have to say about CRT. I said, well, actually, you know, there is a a
6:48 brief section where I kinda touch on
6:50 Yeah.
6:51 How critical theory itself downstream has certain, tendencies in thinking about race in in less than helpful ways.
7:00 Yeah.
7:01 I chose to to focus on the original four or four of the original thinkers, and I'm not the first one to concentrate on the four I did. I'll get to those in a minute. But Yeah.
7:13 I chose to focus on critical theories of school thought that that does go back to the nineteen twenties and thirties in Germany and Frankfurt, Germany. So that's sometimes called the Frankfurt School.
7:25 And... Because these guys were serious scholars. Mhmm. People like Theodore Adorno particularly were were very sharp, very thoughtful. I think there's serious trouble
7:37 in their thinking and serious, as Christians, we would say, quite serious errors, but they they weren't lightweights. They were... And they weren't just activists. They were serious thinkers trying to come
7:49 to terms with the problems of their era. And I thought they were worthy of attention, and I I was seeing, Kevin, some quasi popular
8:01 liberal books critiquing wokeness, and that's fair enough. Mhmm. But I thought I wanna I wanna get into these men and see what they're actually saying and then try to,
8:13 offer a distinctly Christian reformed, engagement. Because I think that the the world of reformed thought and especially Van Till is just kinda pregnant with
8:25 the resources to offer meaningful engagement with these kind of massive meta meta systems. And so, yeah. So I focused on, the early Frankfurt
8:37 School, self designated as critical theory, and then tried to offer a distinctly Christian engagement with them. Mhmm.
8:46 Well, as far as I understand, and as you write in the book that the Frankfurt School grew... Kind of grew out of a disappointment. And, you know, predecessor, Marx, expected the revolution in Germany, but it it
8:57 didn't come, at least in the way that that he might have expected. So how did that failure shape everything the critical theorists eventually went on to write?
9:07 Yeah. It's a great it's great. So I I I decided to throw myself into reading, primary sources, secondary sources as well, but I really want to read primary sources. And and the...
9:19 A common thread was that, the critical theory of Marxist of a certain kind, and they are... They're German. They're they're they're generally
9:30 German Jewish Marxist, and they're looking kinda longingly over at the Russian revolution of nineteen seventeen. And they're saying, well, if it happened there, why hasn't it happened here?
9:42 And what are what are the conditions that might be impeding such a revolution? Mhmm. So the critical theorists at the heart of the, the Frankfurt School was
9:55 what maybe is wrong with our current form of Marxism and what might need to be reworked or what what might need to be rethought. So it's a chase in Marxism.
10:07 It's still Marxist. If you read it long enough, you see the tropes and the themes. But it's reworked and and, reconfigured to account
10:19 for maybe it's not just about, economics. Maybe it's not just about pure, simple, rich people oppressing poor people or the owners
10:31 oppressing the workers. Maybe there's other factors that keep people, quasi voluntarily oppressed or keep them,
10:43 such that they are enjoying their oppression, at least satisfied with their with their being oppressed. So as the critical theorist work this out, they
10:55 they... And I should say the the four I'm talking about is Theodore Adorno Mhmm. Max Horkheimer, Walter Benjamin, an interesting man who was kind of
11:07 the the the the legate over in Paris.
11:10 Didn't live too long if I recall.
11:12 He... Yeah.
11:13 He died early.
11:14 He... That's right. It's sad. He... It appears he committed suicide. He was trying to escape to the, to the states Yeah. And, thought he was trapped. Looks like he committed suicide. Very, very sad.
11:25 And then Herbert Marcuse Mhmm. Probably the most famous and really the rock star of of the gang that we'll we'll need to return to.
11:32 Yeah. Lead singer.
11:34 Lead to yesterday. He really is. He really is. A quick story story so I don't forget later. He... He's in the state. These guys come to the states because of, Nazism. And we'll we'll we'll talk about why
11:46 Nazism is is key to their development. And Marcuse really is admired for for a very dense philosophy. He's he's read. He's admired. And the story goes, he walks into
11:58 a concert, a rock concert, and people begin to whisper, he's here. He's here. Marcuse is here. And they literally kind of part. The crowd parts to allow him to get down to the front of the show.
12:10 So he really, really almost was
12:12 a rock star.
12:12 He didn't quite sing lead that night, but he's got to go near the front apparently. So... He had the he
12:18 had the appeal. My goodness.
12:20 That's right. But the critical theorist, I'll just kinda start with this so we can talk back and forth is if if it's not economics,
12:31 what what might else be going on? And and they began to to write and think about how culture can influence people to be satisfied with the
12:43 status quo. So there's a critique of the culture industry. There's a critique of religion, and authority and the past and the... All these... And and traditional
12:55 marriage, these these cultural forces that might keep someone making a modest salary with two children and enough to get a pizza once a week out, you know, to be satisfied with the... We
13:07 might say middle class or even lower middle class existed. So there there were cultural influences and cultural forces at work that kept people satisfied with
13:19 being oppressed. And so, you know, sometimes hear the word cultural Marxism, which I don't think is race baiting as some have said that they'll they'll use it of themselves sometimes. Mhmm. But the the the
13:31 forces are cultural that keep people in this state of oppression, and those cultural forces have to be undone. And thus, the the the famous phrase, the long march
13:43 through the institutions to to bring about a certain kind of cultural change so that eventually the conditions to allow the revolution, will emerge.
13:56 It's almost as if some... In some forms of this, I suppose, that the people that the critical theorists see as being oppressed are beholden to the system because they like what the system
14:08 produces as well. So it's... I don't know. Some weird analogous form of, like, a Stockholm syndrome or something like that.
14:15 Yeah. That's another... They would say that. They would. They would. You know, I I once had a...
14:19 Particularly with goods, like, and and, you know, the things that capitalism produces. You know? You like your TV, your entertainment, all that stuff, and that keeps you within the system rather than overthrowing it.
14:31 Yes. Yes. No. That's exactly right. And it... It's it's interesting, Camden. There's, the, Horkheimer and Adorno, the two of the... They are brilliant. In the
14:43 forties, they wrote a book, Dialectic of Enlightenment. It's it's produced in forty four in kind of a mimeograph form. It gets published a few years later, and it gets
14:54 published about the same time as a classic book by Richard Weaver, Ideas Have Consequences.
14:59 He's more
15:00 of a traditionalist traditionalist conservative fellow. But here's what's interesting, I think, for the for the Christian and the Ventilian,
15:12 Weaver and the critical theorists were asking a very similar question. What has happened by the time of the middle of the twentieth century? Two world wars, that amount of carnage, that amount of suffering.Show more
In this video 0:00 Introducing Critical Theory and the Frankfurt School15:20 Critical Theory as an Alternative Religion32:00 The Pessimism and Utopianism of Critical Theory43:00 Repressive Tolerance and Cultural Consequences57:00 Practical Implications for Christians Today
Comments No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Reformed Forum
Comments
Keep it kind. Comments are public.