Skip to content Revelation 15-16 God's Just Judgement - Dr. Andrew Hébert - Growing Deeper Jun 23 · 46 min ...more
Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Support this leader
Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Give
Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
16.1K followers
Growing Deeper with Dr. Andrew Hébert is dedicated to helping believers grow in their walk with Christ. Through the expository preaching of the Bible, Dr.
16.1K followers
Structure of Revelation's Judgments 0:02 Welcome to Growing Deeper with doctor Andrew Hebert. For more information about this ministry, visit growing deeper dot net. Well, this morning as we come to Revelation 15 and 16, we0:14 are concluding a major section in the book of Revelation. If you look at the structure of how Revelation is pieced together, the 1st section is in chapter 1. It's an introduction. It's all about Jesus. The 2nd section is0:26 Revelation 2 through 4, which contains letters to 7 churches. The 3rd section is chapters 4 and 5, which paints a picture of the throne room of God, God who is0:37 sovereign over all of history. And then chapters 6 through 16 constitute the next major section0:53 between the 1st and 2nd coming of Jesus, what scripture calls this present evil age. And this section, chapter 6 through 16, contains 31:04 cycles of judgment. You see 3 series of 7 judgments, 7 seal judgments, 7 trumpet judgments, and 7 bowl judgments.1:16 And I've argued over the last few weeks that those are not sequential in time, but rather they are cyclical. That the seals and the trumpets and the bowls are basically telling the same story of of,1:28 what's happening between the 1st and 2nd coming of Christ multiple times from different vantage points. So when you read the seals, you gain some insight about the story. When you read the trumpets, you gain a little1:40 different perspective on the story. And now as we come to the bold judgments, you gain still a 3rd perspective on the story. And actually the Bible is full of this kind of1:52 repetition. For instance, the gospels, right? We have 4 gospels telling 1 story of Jesus, but each of those 4 gospels tells the same story from a little different angle, highlighting some2:03 unique things. The story of creation is the same way. In Genesis 1 and 2, you have the story of creation told 2 times from 2 vantage points. Genesis chapter2:15 1 is like the 30000 foot view. You see the 7 days of creation. And then Genesis chapter 2, the author zooms in at a street level and you have the same story told from a2:27 different vantage point highlighting the creation of Adam and Eve. That's what's happening in the book of Revelation. Multiple tellings of the story from different angles that highlight different2:38 aspects of the story. Now when you come to Revelation 15 and 16, we have this 3rd and final series of 7, something that is called the bowl judgments. And that's what we're going to2:50 look at together this morning. Now the bowl judgments unfold in 2 scenes. Okay, so we're going to see 2 scenes this morning. Now what's interesting about how John structures3:03 Revelation 15 and 16 is that in Revelation chapter 15 and verse 1, he begins to tell about the bowl judgments. But then in the very next verse,3:15 he shifts to a different scene. And verses 2 through 4 describes an entirely different scene. And then in verse 5, he picks back up3:27 with the scene of the bowl judgments. So it almost works like a sandwich. You have bowl judgments that are introduced, then you have a separate scene in the middle, and then you have the bold3:39 judgments that are described. And so it's like 1 scene tucked inside of another scene and that structure is on purpose. The structure is there because when you start to read Revelation 15 and3:51 16, here's what you're going to read about. Revelation 16 is about the severity of God's judgment. And when you read about the severity of God's4:03 judgment, it can cause great fear and trepidation. That's why you have this other scene tucked into the scene about judgment. In chapter 15,4:15 John is gonna describe the security of God's people. And you need to know if you belong to Jesus Christ, even though the judgment of God is coming, you don't need to be afraid of the4:27 judgment of God because of the security of God's people. That's a glorious truth, isn't it? You don't have to be afraid of the coming judgment because if you are in Jesus, you are safe4:39 and secure from the judgment of God. And Revelation chapter 15 prepares you for that. Revelation 15 is like the assurance to say, yes, God's judgment is coming. You need to be4:50 informed about that, but you don't need to fear it. Because if you belong to Jesus, you're completely safe and secure from God's judgment. So think about it like this way. If you if you take a ride on a roller coaster,Security of God's Victorious People 5:01 you buckle in, you pull that safety bar down, you are safe and secure. But you're still going to get a safety briefing. The safety briefing is given5:14 not because you're in danger, but so that you won't panic when the ride gets bumpy. Revelation chapter 16, the ride gets pretty bumpy. Revelation chapter 15 is our safety5:25 briefing. It's just a reminder that if you belong to Jesus Christ, the bumpy ride that is to come is not something that you should be afraid of. Does that make sense? So with that in mind, I want us to look, 1st of5:37 all, at the security of God's people. That's the 1st thing that John is gonna describe in chapter 15. God's people are secure. Look at chapter 15 beginning in verse 1. Then I saw another5:49 great and awe inspiring sign in heaven. 7 angels with the 7 last plagues, for with them God's wrath will be completed. All right, this is the introduction to the bowl6:01 judgments. But then before John gets into that, he's gonna press pause. He's going to say, before I get into that, I want to shift the scene and I want to remind you of some things about your relationship with the Lord.6:12 Before we ever get into the bowl judgments, I want to assure you of some things. So verse 2, we have a scene shift. I also saw something like a sea of glass mixed with fire, and those who had6:24 won the victory over the beast and its image and the number of its name were standing on the sea of glass with harps from God. And they sang the song of God's servant Moses and the song of the6:36 lamb. And this is the lyrics to the song. Great and awe inspiring are your works, Lord God the Almighty. Just and true are your ways, King of the6:48 nations. Lord, who will not fear and glorify your name? For you alone are holy. All the nations will come and worship before you because your righteous acts have7:00 been revealed. Alright. Let's stop right there. The 1st thing John wants us to understand is something about the security of God's people. And this is a really important truth to talk about for a few7:12 moments together because what the bible teaches is that when you are saved, you are also secure. That's really good news, isn't it? When you come to Jesus for salvation,7:24 you are also secure in your salvation. The way Baptists have expressed this for many, many years is that you are once saved, say it with me, and always7:36 saved. Jesus not only forgives us of our sin and rescues us from our sin, but he also holds onto us. He keeps us in his hand. He preserves us in salvation.7:48 He never lets us go. He lets no 1 fall through the cracks. Once you're saved, you're always saved. There's no such thing as being unsaved. Good news, right? This is the way that Peter puts it. In 1st Peter chapter 1,8:00 he says that according to God's great mercy, he has given us the gift of new birth into a living hope through the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead. That's about our salvation. But 2 verses later, he says, we8:11 are those who are guarded by the power of God for a salvation that will be revealed at the end. That's about the security of God's people. So we are both saved8:23 and secure in God's hand. He saves us, he holds on to us, he never lets us go. Now here's why that's important. As a pastor, I have lots of conversations with lots of people all8:35 the time about their spiritual condition. And 1 of the things that I've found is that a lot of people are worried about the security of their salvation. And here's here's why.8:47 People trust Jesus, they come to faith in Christ, they give their life over to the Lord, and they expect, okay, I've been saved now. Everything's gonna be different. I'm gonna be so righteous and I'm gonna be so obedient8:59 and I'm gonna be like a super Christian who follows Jesus, right? The world behind me, the cross before me, no turning back. And then Monday comes.9:11 And they realize the ride is bumpy as a Christian. Can I get a witness? It's not always easy to follow Jesus, and you're not always going to be as righteous as you thought you would be. You're not always going to be as9:21 obedient as you thought you would be, and you're going to experience as a Christian failure and sin in your life, and so people begin to experience that, and they fail, and they're not as righteous as they thought. And9:30 then they begin to question, oh my goodness, does that mean that I'm gonna receive God's judgment? When I die and go to be before the Lord, is he gonna judge me for that? Folks, here's the good news of the gospel of9:42 Jesus Christ. The good news of the gospel is that because of the once and for all sacrifice of Jesus on the cross, he pays the penalty for9:53 all of your sin. Your sin past, your sin present, your sin future. And when you give your life to Jesus, you have been saved and delivered from all of it. You've been saved from the sin that you10:05 used to do. You're saved from the sin that you currently do. You are saved and forgiven from the sin that you don't even yet know that you're going to commit. It is once and for all fully and10:17 finally bought and paid for by the blood of Jesus Christ, which means that you are completely secure in your salvation. John 3 says that you are no longer under condemnation if you believe in Jesus. You10:29 have moved from death to life. You have moved from condemnation to forgiveness. Paul says in Romans 8 1, there is therefore now no condemnation for those in Christ Jesus. And the picture that John10:40 paints in Revelation chapter 15 is of a people who are secure in God. We see 3 pictures, 3 images of God's people in chapter10:52 15 verses 2 through 4. 1st of all, John pictures God's people as victorious, victorious. Look down in verse 2. I11:04 also saw something, John says, I saw something like a sea of glass mixed with fire, and those who had won the victory over the beast and its image and the number of its name were standing on the11:16 sea of glass with harps from God. So the 1st thing that John sees is the saints. He sees the people of God standing on something like a sea of glass. And now we're introduced11:28 to that very same kind of language in Revelation chapter 4 and verse 6. You'll remember Revelation 4 is describing God's throne room. And this is what Revelation four:six says, something like11:39 a sea of glass, similar to crystal was also, say this with me, before the throne. Now John sees the saints11:52 in Revelation 15 standing on this sea of glass. And where are they? Before the throne of God. Folks, this is a picture of the security of God's people. What is12:04 pictured here is the saints not on the receiving end of God's wrath, but rather standing before God's throne, secure in his12:15 presence rather than being on the receiving end of his wrath. You don't need to fear the wrath of God, because if you belong to Jesus, you're in his presence before his throne. Amen? And so there's12:27 something else that's pictured here. They're standing on the sea. Now that may remind you of what John wrote about in Revelation chapter 13 and verse 1. Do you remember that in Revelation 13, John describes a beast12:39 that arises from the, say it with me, from the sea. You remember that? In chapter 13, John sees a demonic beast coming12:51 up from the sea. And in Jewish thought, the sea was an image associated with evil and with fear. And so if that's what John is alluding to here, if he13:02 has that in mind, then the picture that he's painting here in chapter 15 in verse 2 is of God's people standing on top of the place from13:14 which the beast arises. The place of demonic evil is under their feet. And they are standing,13:26 emerging victorious and triumphantly standing on top of the devil's domain. This is a picture of the people of God victorious over the enemies of God.13:38 In chapters 12 and 13, God's people are opposed by the dragon and his beast. But here in chapter 15, they are victorious over their enemies through Christ. They are standing on the13:50 sea. They are trampling it underfoot. Well this is exactly how Paul talks about this reality. Listen to Romans chapter 16 and verse 20, the God of peace will soon crush Satan, say it with me, under14:03 your feet. This is what John means in verse 2 when he says that these are those who had won the victory over the beast and its image and the number of its name. Listen to me,14:15 folks. Why shouldn't you fear the coming judgment of God? Because in Christ, victory over the beast has already been won. This is the people of God victorious. Secondly, this is the people of14:26 God delivered. They are pictured here as a delivered people. Look in verse 3, they sang the song of God's servant Moses14:39 and the song of the lamb. And then you have the lyrics to that song in verses 3 and 4. Now, we know that Moses wrote a couple of songs. You can read those songs in Exodus chapter 15 and14:51 Deuteronomy chapter 32. In Exodus chapter 15, Moses wrote a song of praise to God after God delivered the Israelites through the Red Sea from theSeverity of the Bowl Judgments 15:02 Egyptians. So God delivers his people through the Red Sea, and then Moses writes a worship song. And we have it recorded in Exodus 15. He writes another song in Deuteronomy 32. Here we are told15:14 that they are singing the song of Moses. Now why does John mention Moses right here? I believe that he's evoking the memory of the Exodus.15:27 It was after the Lord delivered his people through the Red Sea that they sang this song. And what John is doing right here, he's saying there's a sense in which we also, as God's people, have been delivered15:39 in a greater Exodus. Like the exodus of Moses, we have been delivered by the lamb. That's why he links Moses and the lamb right here in verse 3. In the same way that God brought Moses15:51 to bring his people out of Egyptian slavery and deliver them in liberation and freedom, we too have been delivered by the blood of the lamb. We have a greater Moses who has led16:03 us out in a greater exodus. And like Moses, Jesus has delivered us, not from pharaoh, but from the powers of darkness. We are no longer in Egypt. We are16:15 no longer in the kingdom of darkness. We are no longer under the tyranny of the beast. We've been delivered by Jesus, the greater Moses, the lamb who was slain so that we can be free.16:27 The reason that we are secure from the wrath of God that's coming is because of the liberating work of the lamb, the living Lord Jesus Christ. We are completely secure. We are16:39 victorious. We are delivered. But there's a 3rd and final image that we see of God's people here. We see God's people standing victorious, standing16:51 delivered. And as a result of those 2 things, we see them standing worshipful, worshipful. Do you see them in verse, verses 3 and 4? They're singing this song17:04 of Moses and the Lamb. It's a worship song. Look at what they sing. Great and awe inspiring are your works, Lord God the Almighty.17:16 Just and true are your ways, King of the nations. Lord, who who will not fear and glorify your name? For you alone are are holy. All the nations are going to come and worship before you because your righteous acts have17:28 been revealed. The picture that we have of the people of God standing before the throne, standing on top of their enemies, delivered by a greater Moses, the Lamb, they are standing in total17:40 awe of the work of God. Great and awe inspiring are your works. There's the people of God before the throne of God singing praise to God because of his17:52 awesome work. Now the word awe inspiring translated there in verse 3 in the CSB, awe inspiring. That's a beautiful word. It's translated in the King James as marvelous.18:05 God's works cause us to marvel at what he has done. ESB translates it amazing. God's works are amazing. CSB, they are awe inspiring. In other words,18:17 the works of God, what he has done for us, in giving us the victory, in delivering us out of bondage, it should inspire total awe.18:28 Awe means that you are overwhelmed with how awesome God is. You are full of awe. You are just overwhelmed by the beauty and the majesty and the glory of God. When was18:40 the last time truly that you can say that you were just overwhelmed at the work of God? I can tell you exactly when I was last overwhelmed at the work of God. A few weeks ago, I was with Amy. We were18:52 taking an anniversary trip down to, central Texas. And we rented a treehouse in the woods. It was awesome. And every evening, we'd get our coffee19:04 and we'd go sit out on the porch and right at dusk, we would see these little bugs with lights. Their butts would light up. That's what was happening, lightning bugs. 119:16 of my younger ones once called them lightning butts. And we're just watching dozens of them and then hundreds of them and then thousands of them in the woods begin to light up and we're just sitting there with our coffee19:27 like, this is awesome. Even in a small insect level, God's works are marvelous. And we go to bed, we wake up the next morning, and19:39 there's little spider webs that had grown all over the porch. And we'd look at that and we'd be like, wow, look at how that spider weaved that web. And look, there's lightning bugs in there. It caught some. Like,19:51 it's it's awesome. If you look at the works of God, even at the small level, what my friend Scott Morris, who teaches chemistry at LeTourneau, he calls it the the tiny hands of God.20:03 When you look at the the work of the tiny hands of God, it is awe inspiring. Listen, 1 single strand of human DNA contains enough data to fill up 1000 books.20:15 And that's at the small level. Then you look at the big level. I mean, in our galaxy alone, the Milky Way galaxy, over 100000000000 stars. In the known universe, it is 93000000000 light years across. And20:27 you look at the small or you look at the great, and it is just stunning and awe inspiring to say, look at the work of God. That's just the work of God in creation. How much more the work of20:39 God in redemption? It ought to inspire worship. It ought to inspire great praise. That's the picture of God's people. They are20:51 overwhelmed with awe at the victory and the deliverance that God has given to them. This work of victory and liberation calls forth the praise of God's people. I mean, why was21:03 it that Moses wrote a song after being delivered? Right? He writes his song after they brought through the Red Sea. Here's why. Because great grace calls for great praise.21:16 Great deliverance demands great doxology. The great works of God calls forth great worship of God. And that is what his people are doing. They are21:27 completely delivered, completely victorious, completely safe and secure, and they're just standing before his throne, giving them him the worship that he is due. I love this picture because God's judgment is about to21:38 come. Chapter 16, we're gonna turn the page just in a minute. God's gonna pour out judgment. And here's the picture of God's people waiting, waiting for judgment. But they are not worryful21:51 while they wait. They are worshipful while they wait. And I think this models for us how to wait well. I don't know what you're waiting on, but I know all of us are waiting for the day of the22:03 Lord. We expect Jesus to come back at some point. But what we shouldn't be doing while we wait, we shouldn't be worrying. Right? Even when you read Revelation 16, this should not cause22:15 worry in you. It ought to cause worship. Notice how God centered this song is. I mean, this is22:27 just so wrapped up in the character of God. They don't worry because they know something of God. Great and awe inspiring are your works, Lord God the Almighty. Just and true are your ways,22:38 King of the nations. Lord, who will not fear and glorify your name? For you alone are holy. All the nations will come and worship before you because your righteous acts have been revealed. Bruce22:50 Metzger says that 1 of the most striking features of this song is the absence of any mention of their own victory and their own achievement. From beginning to end, the whole song is a lyrical outburst celebrating23:02 the goodness of God. So here are the people of God, victorious, delivered, worshipful, completely secure from God's wrath. What23:14 an assuring picture. If you are a believer in the Lord Jesus Christ, you can just write your name right out in the margin. You are secure from the judgment of God. Amen? I'm reminded as I read chapter 15 of the23:26 story of God hiding Moses in the cleft of the rock. You remember that story? God's glory passes by. And God knows that if Moses were to behold the glory of God in its fullness, it would surely23:38 kill him. So what does God do? He just tucks Moses away in the cleft of the rock. There he's hidden. There he's safe. There he's secure and protected as God's glory passes by. Folks, chapter23:50 16, we're about to see the glory of God unveiled in judgment. Chapter 15 is where God just tucks us away in the rock to remind us that we are completely secure as long as we are in24:02 him. Daryl Johnston puts it this way. He says, there is no refuge from the judging God, but there is refuge in the judging God. And if you are in Christ, then you24:13 are completely secure from his wrath. Amen? Amen. Alright. Well, with the security of God's people established, John then shifts to24:25 scene number 2, which is about the severity of God's judgment. Chapter 15 verses 5 through 8 prepares us for that judgment. It gives24:37 us some of the rationale for that judgment. After this, I looked, John says, in the heavenly temple, I saw the tabernacle of testimony that was opened. The testimony, that's a reference to the law. John, as he sees God24:49 about to pour out judgment, he also sees in heaven a copy of the law, a reminder of the moral standard by which God is going to judge. And then in verse 6, out of the25:01 temple came the 7 angels with the 7 plagues, and they were dressed in pure bright linen with golden sashes wrapped around their chest. Notice how these angels that are about to pour out bowls of25:13 judgment, they are dressed in pure clothes. Their clothing reflects the clothing that Jesus wears in Revelation chapter 1. They're in pure bright linen with golden sashes. This is given to remind us that25:25 God's judgment is an outflow of his pure moral character. In other words, the judgment of God is not a defect in God's character, it is actually an outflow of the purity of God's character25:36 itself. Then verses 7 and 8, 1 of the 4 living creatures gave the 7 angels 7 golden bowls filled with the wrath of God who lives forever and ever. And the temple was filled with smoke from the glory of God and from his25:48 power. And no 1 could enter the temple until the 7 plagues of 7 angels were completed. You turn the page to chapter 16 and you see God finally pour out these bowls of judgment.26:01 Now let me just say a word about this and then we're gonna read the chapter. Chapter 16 is full of familiar features. When you read about the bowl judgments, these are roughly parallel to the26:12 trumpet judgments, which we've talked about a number of weeks ago. For instance, trumpet number 1 touches the earth. Bowl number 1 touches the earth. Trumpet number 2 touches the sea.26:24 Bowl number 2 touches the sea. Trumpet number 3 touches the rivers. Bowl number 3 touches the rivers. So these are roughly parallel accounts. They also correspond to the Egyptian26:36 plagues. When you read chapter 16, you're gonna see a lot of correspondence between the judgment God pours out in Revelation 16 with the plagues that God brought to Egypt in the Exodus. So like darkness26:48 coming on the earth and rivers turning into blood, those have clear parallels with the plagues of Egypt. So you ought to be thinking about an Exodus kind of judgment here. And then these judgments also27:00 parallel the creation story. In Genesis chapter 1, God creates earth, sea, sun, rivers, and so forth. Here in chapter 16, every piece of creation is being affected, almost like27:12 a de creation. It's like the elements of creation itself are dismantling because of God's judgment. So a lot of familiarity, familiar features in chapter 16. But there are some things that make this judgment unique.27:24 So here's what I want to do as we close this morning. I want to read the chapter, and then I just want to highlight for you 3 things that are uniquely pointed out about the judgment of God in this chapter. And I'm going27:35 to show you why that matters for your life. All right? Look at chapter 16 beginning in verse 1. Then I heard a loud voice from the temple saying to the 7 angels, go and pour out the 7 bowls of God's wrath on the earth.27:46 And the 1st angel went and poured out his bowl on the earth and severely painful sores broke out on the people who had the mark of the beast and who worshiped its image. And the 2nd angel poured out his bowl into the27:58 sea, and it turned to blood like that of a dead person. And all life in the sea died. The 3rd poured out his bowl into the rivers and the springs of water, and they became blood. And I heard the angel of28:10 the waters say, you are just, the holy 1 who is and who was, because you have passed judgment on these things. Because they poured out the blood of the saints and the prophets, you28:22 have given them blood to drink. They deserve it. And I heard the altar say, yes, Lord God the Almighty. True and just are your judgments. The 4th angel poured out his bowl on the sun,28:34 and it was allowed to scorch people with fire. And people were scorched by the intense heat, so they blasphemed the name of God who has the power over these plagues, and they did not repent and give him glory.28:46 And the 5th poured out his bowl on the throne of the beast, and its kingdom was plunged into darkness. And people gnawed their tongues because of their pain, and blasphemed the God of heaven because of their pains and28:58 their sores, but they did not repent of their works. The 6th bowl the 6th angel poured out his bowl on the great river Euphrates, and its water was dried up to prepare the way for the kings from the east. And29:09 then I saw 3 unclean spirits like frogs coming from the dragon's mouth and from the beast's mouth and from the mouth of the false prophet, for they are demonic spirits performing signs and29:21 they travel to all the kings of the whole world to assemble them for the battle on the great day of God the Almighty. And then as a parenthesis, we're given the statement from Jesus. Look, I'm29:33 coming like a thief. Blessed is the 1 who's alert and remains clothed so that he may not go around naked and people see his shame. Jesus is saying, be ready. Don't be caught unexpected. Verse29:45 16. So they assembled the kings at the place called in Hebrew, Armageddon. That's bowl number 6. Now we get to the 7th bowl. And if you've been following along in this series, you know the29:57 7th seal and the 7th trumpet signals God's final judgment. It's the same here. Now we get to the 7th bowl. This is the final judgment of God. Look at it, verse 17. Then the30:09 7th angel poured out his bowl into the air and a loud voice came out of the temple from the throne saying, it is done. And there were flashes of lightning and rumblings and peals of thunder and a severe30:21 earthquake like no other since people have been on the earth, so great was the quake. You've seen that before. At the 7th seal, there's lightning and thunder and an earthquake. At the 7th trumpet, there's a lightning30:30 thunder and earthquake. Now at the 7th bowl, lightning and thunder and earthquake. This is God's final judgment. And look at the result of it. Verse 19, the great city split into 3 parts and the30:41 cities of the nations fell. Babylon the Great was remembered in God's presence, and he gave her the cup filled with the wine of his fierce anger. Babylon, this worldly city, is literally splintered30:54 apart at the judgment of God. And every island fled and the mountains disappeared. Enormous hailstones, each weighing about 100 pounds, fell from the sky on people and they blasphemed God31:05 for the plague of hail because the plague was extremely severe. I told you chapter 16 is about the severity of God's judgment. I just wanna highlight for you 3 things that31:17 we see about God's judgment from chapter 16 that are unique. That we don't see in the seals, that we don't see in the trumpets, but we do see here with the bowls. 3 things from this vantage point that are highlighted for31:29 us. Number 1, we see this judgment scene is comprehensive. It is comprehensive. In the previous 2 judgment scenes, the31:41 sealed judgments and the trumpet judgments, God's judgment is pictured as being partial rather than total. In the seal judgments, for instance, only a quarter of the31:52 earth is affected. In the trumpet judgments, a 3rd of the earth is affected. You get to chapter 16, all the earth is affected. What John wants you to see in your mind'sShow more In this video 0:00 Structure of Revelation's Judgments5:00 Security of God's Victorious People15:00 Severity of the Bowl Judgments32:00 Justice in God's Comprehensive WrathComments No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Comments
Keep it kind. Comments are public.