Skip to content 114: The Queering of the American Child | James Lindsay & Garry Ingraham Sep 17 · 1 hr 36 min ...more
114: The Queering of the American Child | James Lindsay & Garry Ingraham
September 17, 2025 · 1 hr 36 min
Garry Ingraham sits down with author James Lindsey, co-author of the groundbreaking book "The Queering of the American Child."
Series Love & Truth Network - Audio Edition September 17, 2025 · 1 hr 36 min · Love & Truth Network - Audio Edition
Garry Ingraham sits down with author James Lindsey, co-author of the groundbreaking book "The Queering of the American Child." ...more Show the full description Show less Garry Ingraham sits down with author James Lindsey, co-author of the groundbreaking book "The Queering of the American Child."
Series Love & Truth Network - Audio Edition Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Support this leader
Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Give
Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
49.1K followers
Love & Truth Network equips pastors and local churches to restore relational & sexual wholeness and biblical identity. We accomplish this through our resources,
49.1K followers
Comments No comments yet. Start the conversation.
The Queering of the American Child: A Call to Awareness 0:01 What was the impetus, for him, for you to, to do this book?0:05 The story with him was that Logan's a young dad. Several years ago, he and his wife were deciding to have children. So he'd gotten married, they were talking about having kids. He was like, well, what's the what's0:17 the state of the world? He noticed the the queer theory stuff in the schools, the gender unicorn, the so called gender bred person. Yep. The gender ideology overall.0:28 I just want everyone who's watching, listening to this to understand that, hey, go out and get this book because it is not it's not like a top shelf volume that's gonna be difficult to understand. All these books0:39 out there about this issue, and I don't mean to leave people out, are great, but there's nothing that does the hard deep dive into the ideological origins that ties it directly to the practice that we see.0:49 The American Psychological Association, for example, will say something, and then that's followed up by another another professional organization jumping on board. And yet now, they're jumping on the same bandwagon and1:01 we're supposed to expect that that this is settled science or something.1:05 That led us to do all the rest of the most famous of the treatment studies papers was about dog dog sex. I know that's a weird thing to say on a podcast or anywhere, but we said that you can understand rape culture by1:15 watching how people react when dogs at the dog park get naughty with each other. Got an award for excellence in scholarship in the field of feminist geography, so it was lauded. Essence of chapter 12 of Mein1:27 Kampf and fed it into a feminist social work journal that accepted it and published it. And so that's a problem. So, I mean, Rush Limbaugh can laugh because feminazis became true, But,1:38 everybody else should be horrified. But I went to my wife and I said, we're done with these papers. They're like, this isn't funny anymore. I think this ends in the unraveling of civilization and maybe a lot of people1:48 dying. I said the most sane thing possible. I said, can I quit my job and dedicate my life to studying and exposing this full time because I'm a little bit ahead of other people and everybody in the world needs to know?2:21 Hey, everybody. Thanks again for tuning in for another episode of the Love and Truth Network podcast. We're so glad that you're here whether you're tuning in through LTN or through Transforming Congregations. Again, we2:31 appreciate you jumping into this episode. I'm really, excited and and in a way, I I hesitate on using the word excited because some of the things we're gonna be talking about today are anything but exciting. They're2:43 they're challenging. They're, they're really difficult things to kind of handle and wrap our minds around, but they're so important for us to be talking about these issues. I'm just really grateful for James Lindsay2:54 who's here to to share with us out of, the book that he coauthored, called The Queering of the American Child. It's such an important topic that we need to lean into, and so we're gonna dive right into3:06 that. James, thanks so much for being here.3:09 Yeah. It's my pleasure.3:10 Thank you. Yeah. Absolutely. So I was mentioning before we jumped on the recording here that I first heard you saw you at, an event, America Fest, Charlie Kirk, TP USA event3:22 probably several years ago. I think you might have been there. Maybe it's 2 years ago, but you were doing a panel discussion. You were leading that discussion with, someone who I consider a friend, Chloe Cole. We've3:32 we've spoken together on, at a church in California a couple of years ago. Of course, she has an amazing story, and she's probably 1 of the most prominent national figures, as someone who has once believed that3:44 she was a boy, went down that route, double mastectomy, cross sex hormones, I think even puberty blockers, and then realized, I think at the age of 16 even, what what kind of a horrible mistake have I made? And it3:55 shifted away from that, has become such a huge proponent for protecting children, who have no capacity to make informed consent about the things that they're being asked or expected to make consent to.4:07 So anyway, really appreciate you sharing and doing the work that you did there on that panel discussion, but also, you know, the work that you've been doing in this space of of really helping us understand4:19 what is going on. This is this is radically different. What you and I will be talking about today is very different than, than the the L, the the G, and the B of the acronym. Right? The4:30 LGBTQIA plus whatever. This is very different than what has morphed into the t. I mean, I feel like the t has where it was once transgenderism, where it was once4:43 a, something that that was extremely rare and was also, like, a genuine, painful, internal wrestling with, feeling like I'm in the wrong body, gender dysphoria,4:54 etcetera, Where it was once that, it I've as I've watched it, it seems to have ballooned into something much, much bigger, rapid onset gender dysphoria, which Abigail Schreyer has written about in,5:06 Irreversible Damage. But what you're talking about here, this this, queer theory, the queering of the American child, I think really helps us understand where these things have been conflated with intention, I5:18 think, understand the difference. And and so I would love for you just to to kind of unpack, you and your coauthor, Logan Lansing, put this book together. And I think Logan5:30 did tons of the research on this and developed it. What was the what was the impetus, for him for you to to do this book?5:38 Yeah. I'll tell the story, and I'm, you know, I'm glad I'll just mention real quick since you saw me on that panel with Chloe. Honestly, you know, how young she is, it must be that your your timing is roughly right.5:49 Because the first time I met Chloe was before that, at a heritage foundation event. And I think I'm not a hundred percent certain, but I think she was still 17 when I met her. So then she was already6:01 speaking out about her new transition, but that panel was for a film. If anybody's interested in seeing more that Turning Point USA produced in conjunction with Daily Wire called Identity Crisis. And it's really an eye6:13 opener if you want to, face down this, kind of monstrous, situation that's been happening in our our country with our kids for the past 10 years. But yeah.6:25 So our motivations for the book, I'll tell you the story behind the queering of the American child. The story starts with, as you rightly identified with Logan. I was a Johnny come lately to this project.6:36 Logan had followed me and interacted with me some on social media, and had written a book previously, called The Woke Warpath that he, tried to explain his best he could,6:49 woke ideas. And he eventually reached out to me with the early manuscript of what has become the querying of the American child. It was about half the length it is now. It was a lot easier and fun to7:01 read. But it covered the the issue really, really well. The story with him was that Logan's a young dad. I'm not positive how old he is. I don't think7:12 he's a super young man. He's, you know, out of college, certainly. I'm guessing he's in his late twenties or maybe early thirties, but I might be wrong. But he's got 2 young children.7:22 Mhmm.7:23 And several years ago, he and his wife were deciding to have children. So he'd gotten married. They were talking about having kids. He's kind of a very responsible and thoughtful person as you might imagine. So he was7:34 like, well, what's the what's the state of the world? He knew that this woke stuff was happening. He was aware of it, and he wanted to know what the state of it with schools would be. And I won't say too much about him7:46 in case he doesn't want me to, but he lives in a in a state with a lot of trouble with this woke stuff. Yes. We'll leave it at that. And so as though people can't guess which 1 it is by his accent, but,7:59 just to tease him a little. But he, he, he noticed the the queer theory stuff in the schools, the gender unicorn, the so called genderbread person8:10 Yep.8:10 The gender ideology overall. And then knew because of having read my work and doing his own research into the woke stuff that it was rooted in queer theory. That he knew this was not an environment he8:22 wanted to bring his children into. And so he knew he needed to try to do something about it. And so what he did was started reading it. He started reading queer theory directly and queer8:34 education theory. He started with a lot of things that I had read, and then he quickly started to read other things that I had not read. He and I were in a little bit of communication, and he would send me some examples8:46 of very egregious things he was finding. Some of which, you know, it's hard to shock me with woke stuff at this point. But some of it really caught me off guard how, revelatory or shocking it was.8:58 And he just laid this out, wrote a 30000 word manuscript, sent it to me, said, I don't know what to do with it, but I would love if you look it over if you have the time and, give me any suggestions or9:10 corrections or whatever. And I was boarding a flight. I forget. I'm always boarding a flight. I was boarding a flight somewhere, and it was far, but I don't remember where I was going. So I9:21 had a lot of time. It was definitely that I was going to the West Coast somewhere, or thereabouts. Possibly, I was going to Phoenix for a turning point thing that's actually very likely. And, I got on this9:33 plane and I was flying and I thought, you know what? The heck with it. I'll read it. And I opened up the file he sent me. I wasn't gonna touch it. And I opened up I was like, really? You're gonna saddle me with this? And9:44 I opened up the file and I started to read it and I was like, my gosh. This is wonderful. And then I'm reading as, you know, and I don't know, probably 10 pages in, I was thinking, my gosh, if I9:56 were to write a book about this subject, this is the book I would write, but somebody else wrote it. Holy holy cow, you know, so I started to get very excited. I consumed it extremely rapidly, as fast10:08 as I could read it. I think I'd read most of it before I got to wherever I was flying. And, I sent him a message and asked him what his intentions were, and he said he didn't know. He'd probably self publish it or10:17 whatever. And I said, well, I don't wanna encroach on you, but I would actually love to publish this through new discourses, and I would actually also love to do it with you. I would like to join the project if you're10:29 amenable. And he was. He was excited about it. And so we went into a collaboration from there. And I took the re the manuscript and sat with it for several weeks10:41 and wrote every suggestion I could think of that was appropriate. That wouldn't, you know, go too far afield, sent it off to him. He thought, oh my gosh. Include 1 of my suggestions was that you need a whole extra10:51 chapter to explain, the child psychology aspect of this. Yes. And so he went and had to do some reading for that, and he came back to me, and then we just hammered out the manuscript. I added to it, he added to it, and11:03 ended up he sent me 30000. We published it at almost I think it's, like, within a hundred words of 60000. Like, it's really close to exactly 60000 words. And, so we doubled the length of it.11:15 And my motivation was that I've been studying this for a long time. I would have loved to have written a book about it. This is not the book that I would have written quite specifically, but more importantly, I cannot11:25 write the way that Logan writes. So the writing style in the book, if you read through it and you read the afterword, which was just me, you will tell there's a sharp difference in writing style between them. And that's11:36 because Logan made the entire book except the afterword readable. And I wrote the afterword and good luck. It's a little heavier. It's a little higher brow and hard. His goal was he has a he has a dad like11:48 everybody. He wanted his dad who didn't go to college, works a blue collar job. He wanted his dad to be able to read every paragraph of the book and understand it. And he just kept retooling it and retooling it until he11:58 got it. So the motivations are there. He wanted to protect his kids, to make a dent in this issue, to get the information out that he had been learning reading this because not that many people who disagree with it ever12:09 bother to read it. And I have the same motivations. I don't have my kids aren't skin in the game, but I had the concern about getting the information out, that I've read this, that it's Yes. Horrible, and that12:21 we need this, you know, all of the books, Abigail Shrier's is great, Lisa Lippman is great. You know, all these books out there about this issue, and I don't mean to leave people out, are great, but there's nothing that12:32 does the hard deep dive into the ideological origins that ties it directly to the practice that we see.12:38 No. No. I I so agree, completely. I I loved Abigail's book. And, of course, really Abigail's book is kind of built, I think, quite a bit on on the work that Lisa Littman did. Right? I mean, so much of that.12:50 And, so and and by the way, I wasn't even aware that Lisa what is Lisa Littman's book? Do you recall that off the top of your12:56 head? You know, I actually don't know. I just know she's the 1 responsible for rapid onset gender dysphoria as a consequence.13:02 That, naming that.13:04 Yeah. Abigail did a great job reporting on that. I've met Lisa actually and listened to her talk a couple of times. She's actually phenomenal. Yeah. But I don't know actually if she has a book. There's another book13:16 that is Miriam Grossman that I think I was thinking of that's Yes. Lost in transnation.13:20 Got13:20 it. Yes. Also fantastic.13:22 Yeah. Miriam Grossman is amazing. I was listening to somebody a couple of years ago just as a sidebar rabbit trail. I'm always going off on those who I was sitting in on this presentation, and and the guy act actually,13:34 put Miriam Grossman in the same league as as the, you know, extreme leftist or queer theory people. And I'm like, wait a minute. What are you talking about? She doesn't belong there. She's with us. I mean, she's she's13:45 writing phenomenal stuff on this. I read her book years ago called You're Teaching My Child What? You know, talking about sex education in in the public school and etcetera. But, I so I wanna back up for just a minute13:56 here. Well, first of all, say, I completely agree with you in terms of how Logan wrote this. And I I appreciate understanding that he wanted his dad to be able to read it and fully understand it because,14:08 that with that in mind, I just want everyone who's watching, listening to this to understand that, hey, go out and get this book because it is not it's not like a top shelf volume that's gonna be difficult to14:20 understand. It's it's written in everyday language and, and and it has all of the the facts, the data, the research right there that you can look at. You're you're simply when you say this also in the end that in the14:31 conclusion that you're basically the the book is just full of quoting, thoughts and ideas that some of these people who, really were the ones responsible for founding or developing what is now queer14:43 theory, what they wrote. I mean, it's just kind of exposing. It's kind of like, Libs at TikTok, you know, just just going ahead and putting out there what somebody else has said over and over again. No. The book14:53 is mostly a mirror. Right? The idea is mostly a mirror. Yeah. So, I was working also with Moms for Liberty a lot. I was working with a lot of pastors and a lot of churches, and so a lot of everyday people. Yes. So I15:05 was very excited. You know, moms are busy. They've got kids. They've got all the responsibilities. A lot of them have jobs. Plus, the ones that I was working with are, you know, running or engaged in a volunteer15:16 organization or Yeah. Several of them. A lot of the same is true with people in churches. I I wanted something that could just, you know, hit for anybody. And I if I would have written this book, it wouldn't have worked.15:27 So Logan's talent here is Yeah. Is the true gift.15:31 That's great. Well, also, let's back up for a second, and you mentioned it in some of what you're saying, but you were the, I think, founder and president of New Discourse. Is that right? Talk a little bit about what15:41 that is.15:42 So New Discourse is basically a platform for if I I've read so much, read so much Maoism, I almost said it the way the Maoists would. In China, it's a traditional that15:54 whoever the leader is that you, you describe the general philosophy that way. So right now Xi Jinping is the leader. And so the philosophy of the People's Republic of China is called Xi Jinping thought. And before that,16:06 it was, you know, whoever, and it was Deng Xiaoping Thought is a big 1 when Deng Xiaoping was in power. And, but the big 1 during Mao's reign was Mao Zedong Thought. So I was basically about to say that, New Discourses16:17 is a platform that a couple of, colleagues and I built in 20 19, in order to promote James Lindsay thought. And so, basically, I have all these ideas about what's going on in Woke.16:29 I needed a delivery mechanism that is professional and polished and accessible. And these guys found my work that I work with to this day. I've worked with them ever since very,16:41 very, amiably, very good working relationship. Somewhat profitably depends on the on the month, I guess. But Yeah. Right. We've worked together for, you know, over 5 years now, 6 years. We16:52 started in 19. We met in February of 20 19, came up with the idea throughout, 20 19, but the idea boiled down to that, they wanted to17:04 build a platform for the things I was saying about woke in a place that would have prominence that I could launch those ideas as fast as I could make them. So whether it's, you know, try to write articles or podcasts or17:16 whatever, have a centrally located place where people would know this is where I publish my stuff. And I maybe publish stuff from other people I think are worth seeing. So that's what it was. That was the objective. We17:27 tried to build it out to be mostly cancel proof, so there wasn't gonna be dependent on, you know, a big donor. It wasn't gonna get hooked into some corporate or, you know, think tank or nonprofit structure. It17:39 was gonna all be crowdfunded and so on, which would diversify the the donation base to make me very difficult to to put out a business Yes. Should the left come after me. Yeah.17:52 We didn't quite bank on later that the right might come after us, but we're weathering the storm okay, at the moment. But the fact of the matter is that, new discourses is just18:04 a platform for me to express basically the history and evolution of communism and other totalitarian ideologies as I research it. It's how I share my research with the world, as fast as I can can make18:16 it really. Yes. And it's been pretty successful. The podcast is now I just looked yesterday. I never do this, but I had to do it for something a hundred and 63 episodes deep.18:28 If you count the short form podcast that I've added in, I think there's over 300, almost 400 of them now.18:34 Yeah.18:34 And so it totals up close to 8 or 900 hours of podcast material, millions of words of text. We've published, gosh, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 books, I think.18:47 So maybe it's 4. I might have counted too quick in my head. So at any rate, it's been pretty successful and, a great way to get information out, about what I see as the problem of woke.18:59 Yep. Well, and I I after reading the book, I looked up, your podcast and saved that as a favorites and and keep going back there over and over again and just going back through. It's it really is,19:11 so incredibly helpful. I'd encourage our audience to do that as well. The thing I wanna mention are so our audience, those that have been following us for a while, are used to all of our guests, starting off and sharing19:22 their story, their faith journey. And so 1 of the things I just wanna mention here is that, the way that you would describe and correct me in any way you want to, but kind of describe where you're at is not as a19:32 Christian or, but really an agnostic, but who is incredibly faith friendly. I know you've been your book is endorsed by a number of pastors, you know, the the, career theory, the, careering of the American19:43 child is endorsed by a number of pastors. You've been at a number of churches, I believe, as well. But I just want our audience to know, hey. You know, the reason James isn't sharing his faith journey, yeah, at this19:53 point, maybe 1 of those days that'll change. I don't know. But, we'd love to have you back on if that does change. But, that's where we're at. But the thing the reason that we're together is because, I mean, we may have20:04 different perspectives when it comes to, faith, but we're lockstep when it comes to this issue, that you're communicating in your book. Did I did I do a decent job of explaining that?20:14 Yeah. That's true. I mean, so Charlie Kirk, because he says he's working on me. He's a friend of mine and has been for years. As you you know, you said you met me at an America Fest where I had done something with20:24 Charlie. And so Charlie and I talk a lot on stage and off and, I mean, he's busy with the president right now. So I guess a little less like, thanks, Charlie.20:36 Who who you talking to? The president or something, you know? But, anyway, Charlie and I have had a great relationship, and he requires that I use the word agnostic, and he says we've moved him, because I was a part of20:47 the New Atheist Movement. So there is a faith journey. I was a part of the New Atheist Movement. I'm not there now. I've become incredibly Christian friendly. I did an event with, at a church, in Phoenix with20:59 Charlie Kirk and Eric Metaxas. We were on stage together and we were talking about, we were talking about courage actually, and I gave a discussion based off of, you know,21:11 several biblical things. Of course, faith without works is dead. That courage is the bridge between faith and works, and that's why faith without works is dead. And that's why every Christian to be truly Christian must21:21 actually be courageous, right? Courage is a is a necessary component of the Christian worldview. And so I gave this whole speech about it and Eric Metaxas is sitting there, we're on a couch on a big stage in21:33 a huge mega church with thousands of people watching this. And I give this whole layout, and Eric Metaxes just says, I think he's converted and won't admit it. And so, I I recently did a podcast also21:45 since it's about the faith journey, people will wanna hear. I did a podcast when I was in London at at the ARC convention, Jordan Peterson's arc, Alliance for Responsible Citizenship. I did a podcast with,21:57 Justin Briarley, who is pretty famous for bringing Christian apologists together with, non believers and having them discuss or debate. And he brought me together with Bethel22:09 McGrew. That's Tim McGrew's daughter, Christian philosopher, actually, 1 of my best friends at this point. I loved him. We're we're wonderful friends. 1 of the smartest and22:20 most kind and thoughtful men I know. And I sat down with those 2. And what I explained is that the position I'm in now is that I've decided that Christianity is anthropologically true. A lot of Christians will hear that22:31 as a cop out, but that means when you read the bible and it tells you, you know, how you should understand situations or relate to situations both in society and in individual life, it's right because it's at22:43 least anthropologically true. And, you know, Bethel argued, well, if it's anthropologically true, you have to ask yourself why, why is this kind of transcendent book anthropologically true? And she said to keep pulling22:52 the string, you know, but, the, so I'm not exactly, you know, Christian resistant or anything like that. And I, I do turn to scripture actually23:04 very frequently now to try to make sense of various things. So, yeah, well, it is a journey. The journey has occurred. So maybe that's a good talk later that we can have.23:13 Yeah. Yeah. That's right. And and I I just think about every single person that shared their story on our podcast. It has you know, we've all been on some form of a journey. We didn't just, you know, drop into the23:24 kingdom. So, yeah, thanks for sharing that. I appreciate, I appreciate that. 1 of the things also, I realized that I saw you earlier than I than I knew because when I was just looking up a little23:36 bit of information on who you were, I'm like, oh, I remember this. So back in what it was at? 7, 8 years ago, 20 17, 20 18, you and a female colleague and another23:48 guy, wrote I forget what it's even the grievance something. The23:51 grievance affairs affair. Yeah.23:52 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Can you I I just when that when that came out, I I was roaring, over, over what you guys were able to accomplish. And this actually does I think this is a segue24:04 into some of what we're talking about with the book in terms of just the horrendous way that things are supposedly, so well vetted, you know, scientific data and research, etcetera. So you24:16 you've got these professional, magazines and you can describe it better. But, journals and that are supposedly peer reviewed and everything is so scientifically based, and you guys did what? Can you explain24:28 some of that?24:29 So So the grievance studies affair, it was Helen Pluckrose, Peter Bogosian and I, spent the entirety of, it's hard to say it that way. We spent summer of 20 1724:41 to the fall of 20 18, writing articles for peer reviewed journals in what we would now see as woke academic fields, feminist theory, gender studies, sexuality studies, woke24:53 education or critical education and so on, critical race theory. And so we wrote all these papers. In fact, we wrote 20 of them, typical academic. So this isn't writing like an essay. Right? It's not writing your your25:04 your weekly missive for your blog or whatever. These things are career defining, projects for academics. So a good hardworking academic in these kinds of25:16 humanities fields will probably write 2 per year. Yeah. We wrote 20. And it's, it turns out we wrote for 10 months and then we decided that it was kind of too unwieldy and we would only25:28 edit ones that already existed. So in 10 months we wrote 20 papers. So it was about 1 every 2 weeks instead of 1 every 6 months. So we wrote these papers and they were absolutely crazy. The idea that we had was25:40 that they are peer reviewing, but that the peer reviewers are corrupt. They're not corrupt in the sense that they're taking money to publish things. They're or that the like, the sugar industry is telling them to do this25:51 or that.25:51 They're ideologically25:52 corrupt. That happens too. We all know that big pharma influences the medical literature very significantly, but we weren't targeting that. We were ideologically corrupt. That these people basically have left reality and26:04 they are the peers and they consider their disciplines very important and serious and they do academic work technically within that bubble universe of crazy woke ideas. But26:16 we thought if we just say crazy stuff and couch it in woke language and woke theory and make it woke, they won't know that it's crazy and they'll publish it.26:25 Give an example. What what was the title of 1 of them? I'm trying to think about it had to do with the, yep. It was like the name of the penis or something. What was the what was that 1? Just So there was26:36 a trial balloon paper we did to see if this would work before we started. So we actually did this at the end of 16 and early 17, and that was called the conceptual penis as a social construct.26:45 There you go.26:46 And the thesis of that paper was that penises are social socially constructed. They're not real. And they cause all of our problems because they make men like macho. And the especially they cause climate change26:58 because they lead men to want to rape the environment and all of this crazy stuff. And that led us to do all the rest of the most famous of the grievance studies papers was about dog sex. I know that's a weird thing to27:08 say on a podcast or anywhere, but we said that you can understand rape culture by watching how people react when dogs at the dog park get naughty with each other. And we, of course, said that the straight men were27:20 like, get her boy, you know, and they're really encouraging of it because they like dog rape. And we said that dog parks are rape rape condoning spaces was the exact phrase.27:31 And, petri dishes of canine rape culture that that bleeds over into rape culture in the men that take their dogs and other men. And so that if we train men the way we train dogs out of obedience manuals and with leashes,27:43 then we can probably maybe shot collars if we can get it, you know, approved, then we can get over rape culture and save the world.27:50 So I just wanna so pause for a second because I know people, like, listening to this and they're and, watching this, I can just see many of them with their draw, like, hitting the table or whatever. And Mhmm.28:02 But here's the point, is you were making these things so completely and utterly ridiculous28:08 Mhmm.28:09 As a test to how are you going to review these? And and and how many of your 20 papers were actually lauded and and accepted and and printed?28:21 So let me give a caveat here.28:24 Okay.28:25 It's a little complicated. The academic just like the academic writing process is slow, the academic publishing process is very slow. Okay. So from submission to through review, to acceptance can take28:37 months. And then from acceptance to publication can also take months. Got it. Okay. So we got caught by the wall street journal and busted in October of 20 18. So we were still in the28:49 middle of the process. So we wrote 20. By that 0.7 of them had been accepted. Okay. 4 of those had actually been published. 1 of them, the 1 about the dogs, got29:01 an award for excellence in scholarship in the field of feminist geography. So it was lauded. And then we had 7 more that were under peer review still. And a sociologist, so not necessarily a friend of ours, analyzed29:13 the all 20 papers or actually all 14 that were either accepted or still under peer review. And he so the 7 that were still under peer review, we looked at and he decided that either 4 or29:25 possibly 5 of them would almost definitely pass peer review and that, you know, 2 or 3 might not. And so he concluded that we would have ended up had we seen it to the end with either 11 or 12. Like29:37 for example, 1 of the papers that we cannot count as having been accepted, the journal, which was feminist theory had given us the only correction they asked for was to shorten it. They said it was too long and29:49 to clip some and make it a little bit shorter. That means they were going to accept it. And we had sent the revision back in shorter to the number the page count or the number sorry, word count they told us to have, and30:00 they just didn't get back to us yet. And then it was over. So another week and it would have been 8, because that paper was for all intents and purposes accepted. And, you know, of those 7, they were all in30:12 different that's the the furthest along, but they were all in different stages of the, pathway to possible acceptance.30:18 Yep. And and what what does that whole experience, what does that prove, basically? I mean, I think it proves very disturbing things, but what from your perspective are30:30 they?30:30 You know, at the time we had a lot of guesses about what it proves, but looking back now that we've got, you know, that was 20 18. So almost 6 and a half years of reflection or 7 years for the middle of the30:42 project, a reflection on what it what it demonstrates. I think it demonstrates that peer review, of course, is only as good as the peers. And so the30:55 peers peer review might not be the best way to verify things. Right? We've taken it as this gold standard for a lot of reasons. A lot of people don't know this before really, you know, the 19 sixties, we didn't really31:07 have peer review. I don't remember if this is correct or not, but I think Albert Einstein, 1 of his papers was gonna be sent to peer review, and he got so angry that, you know, it was this huge drama. So it wasn't always31:18 a thing. But it turns out that the corruptions, the social corruptions of groups of people who basically buy into what was called in the nineties in a similar experiment experiment, fashionable31:30 nonsense, can actually end up certifying as very, you know, useful and valuable information, stuff that's absolutely not useful and valuable information. A friend31:42 of Peter's who used to and maybe still does, I don't know, work at Harvard, called right after this all came out, and he said, my god. What you have proved is that these journals will31:54 publish, prejudice and opinion as if it is verified knowledge. And I think that that's the best statement of what we proved looking back after all these years. So peer review is only as good as the32:06 peers. And if the peers are in a bubble, you're they're gonna publish or a cult. Let's say that the peers are in a cult. Pick any I don't wanna name any people that might get offended about a cult, but you pick32:17 your favorite cult, the seekers. That was the 1 that Leon Festinger studied back in the fifties, so nobody can get mad about that 1, the UFO cult. So if the seekers had an academic journal, they're gonna publish seeker32:28 stuff. And if the, you know, a whole wing of academia got captured by the seekers, there's nothing to stop them from publishing as though it's science. Yeah. Seeker stuff, secret cult doctrine,32:40 cult literature. And I think that's exactly what we're dealing with is that a cult has taken a hold of the humanities and increasingly the social sciences for the last probably over 50 years32:51 Yep.32:52 And is completely control sectors of of academia and academic research and publishing.32:57 And when as you were writing these articles, the 3 of you were writing them, as I remember this first being exposed, I think, you know, you guys being interviewed about about some of it33:09 and and reading parts of them. I didn't I haven't sat down and read read the whole thing, or 1 of the 1 of the papers. But it it felt like to me, like, you were in and so I know you need to correct this, but it felt33:21 to me as if you guys were taking some of the most outlandish and ridiculous thoughts and ideas, but putting them in the language, into woke language, depending on what publication you were33:33 journal you were looking to put it in. But so I'm I'm sure that needs to be my thought around. You're 90 percent right. Oh, okay.33:41 That's extraordinarily close to what we did. Peter and I, you cannot imagine the whole the the laughter of us on the phone every day talking of ideas and how we're gonna change things andShow more In this video 0:00 The Queering of the American Child: A Call to Awareness
Comments
Keep it kind. Comments are public.