Skip to content 25: Sexual abuse in the Protestant Church | Garry Ingraham & Dale Ingraham Aug 25 · 41 min ...more
25: Sexual abuse in the Protestant Church | Garry Ingraham & Dale Ingraham
August 25, 2025 · 41 min
Similar to other denominations, sexual abuse and domestic violence in Protestant churches often go unreported, leaving victims to suffer in silence.
Series Love & Truth Network Podcast - Video Edition Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Support this leader
Liking this video? Support this ministry.
Give
Support this leader Liking this video? Support this ministry.
49.1K followers
Love & Truth Network equips pastors and local churches to restore relational & sexual wholeness and biblical identity. We accomplish this through our resources,
49.1K followers
Comments No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Confronting Abuse and the Church's Role 0:01 Initially, we were focused primarily on the childhood sexual abuse because that's my wife's story. She was abused from age 9 to 18, raped and molested by her father0:13 who was a pastor at the time.0:16 You know, within the Protestant church with so many different denominations, I feel like we are so quick to point the finger at the Catholic church, and we should be pointing out the the junk of the garbage. But there's0:26 so little consideration for the unbelievable amount of of sexual abuse of children, abuse of of vulnerable people, wives, women, and others within the within the0:38 non Catholic church.0:40 Churches and people wind up having to make a choice. Either I'm gonna support the offender and rally around the offender, or I'm gonna rally0:52 around the abuse victim and take take a stand at what the offender has done, and and that puts them in a very uncomfortable position. And what often happens is the church rallies1:04 around the offender. We need to talk about sex abuse of children and domestic violence from the pulpit so that people in the pews feel like1:16 if this is going on, I can say something to pastor about it. I can talk to some people about it. It's that silence1:34 comfortable or feel like it's safe to share their story.1:59 Well, hey, everybody. Thank you again for and welcome to another podcast for Love and Truth Network. You're gonna notice right out of the bat that we are not in the same location where I usually do my podcast from. We're2:10 having a great time here at the American Association of Christian Counselors Conference and really excited actually to be joined by my brother Dale. He is 5 years older than me, and he's the 1,2:21 whatever, if you've heard me speak in the past or talk about, my my siblings, he's the 1 sibling that did not not give my parents much of a run for their money. He was always the good kid and, has been a pastor for many2:32 years, and it's just exciting to be able to be here with him. He and his wife, I'll I'll let them share about let him share about what they're here for and what they're exhibiting here at the American Association of2:44 Christian Counselors Conference. Yeah. So I just thought it would be fun to do several different podcasts here from the conference, and we'll see how that all that goes. So, Dale, thank you so much for being here with us2:55 Thank you.2:56 And just being a part of this podcast.2:58 Thank you. It's cool to be doing a podcast with my little brother.3:01 Yeah. There you go. There you go. So what brings you in faith, here to this conference? What are you guys doing with your ministry?3:10 So our ministry is Speaking Truth Love Ministries, and it deals primarily with childhood sexual abuse as well as domestic violence. Mhmm. And I've been a pastor since 19 83, so 40 years3:22 now. But we started our ministry dealing with abuse back in, in 2007 is when we were talking about it. Same time you guys were starting your ministry. We did our first3:34 conference in February of 2008. Initially, we were focused primarily on the childhood sexual abuse because that's my wife's story. She was abused from age3:46 9 to 18, raped and molested Mhmm. By her father who was a pastor at the time.3:53 Yes.3:53 And so our emphasis was on the sexual abuse of children. Since then, we do a lot with domestic violence because the both issues are so intertwined that we often find the4:05 same settings where you have sexual abuse, you have a lot of domestic violence. So all of that kind of plays together, and it even intertwines with your ministry and kinda what you do.4:15 Right. Yep. It's so needed. And, you know, oftentimes, it seems as difficult as our ministry can be in dealing with sexual brokenness. And Yes. More importantly, not4:27 just dealing with sexual brokenness, but restoring sexual wholeness, when it comes to pornography addiction, when it comes to sex before marriage, when it comes to adultery and other even even emotional affairs4:39 and just getting wrapped up in really relationally idolatrous relationships that oftentimes then, move beyond the emotional and into, the sexual, the physical.4:51 And, you know, those are tough topics. The church doesn't has historically not dealt with them well.4:56 Right.4:57 But then when you talk about the abuse of children, I think that there's on the 1 hand, I would think that churches would would have wide open arms to your message and your5:09 ministry. And yet in some ways, I know I I think from our conversations that you've experienced a lot of churches being walled off to what you're offering and what you're doing to really support children5:21 and to help help even the church deal with these really difficult issues.5:25 It is they are interesting dynamics because clearly what you do and what we do, they are very complex. They're very difficult. The 1 thing that I noticed, like, over the years, you would hear5:37 references to the same sex attraction and other things, maybe not good teaching on it, but references to5:45 it. Yep.5:46 The the childhood sexual abuse and even domestic violence, the thought of a of a husband who beats his wife or even rapes his wife5:55 Yes.5:56 It it's it's so foreign to even talking about. And we spoke in a church here in Tennessee last Sunday, and you could tell by the reaction of folks that it had never6:08 been talked about in church before, but we had a wonderful reception. The pastor welcomed us there. The folks welcomed us. I think people are hungry in a lot of ways to hear about it. I think it's6:20 scary for church leadership.6:21 Yes.6:23 And I think there's a couple of reasons for that. Unfortunately, there's there's a lot of abusers within the church. And then in Faye Stadt's case, he was a pastor. Yep.6:35 So6:36 Wasn't he also, like, a chaplain of the hospital fire? I mean, did did he he extended quite a ways out beyond the church.6:43 He did. He was a chaplain on the local fire department. He was in hospitals frequently. So there's I think sometimes church leadership, because it hits close to home, they don't wanna deal with it.6:55 I think a big reason they don't wanna deal with it, they they know it could open a can of worms. So whether it's a Christian college, maybe they may have a, you know, a7:07 mega donor that that might be involved in this stuff. Churches may have people that that give a a great deal of money to them. And so there's a real7:19 reluctance sometimes to really call offenders out and and be there for the victims. And what happens is churches and7:30 people wind up having to make a choice. Either I'm gonna support the offender and rally around the offender7:39 Yep.7:40 Or I'm gonna rally around the abuse victim and take a stand at what defender has done, and and that puts them in a very uncomfortable position. And what often happens is the7:52 church rallies around the offender. When we go to court with a victim to just be there to support them Mhmm. We we're just in Virginia a few weeks ago, a a beautiful 10 year old girl8:04 sexually abused by her grandfather. He was high up in the church, and the church has rejected this little girl and her parents because they've they're holding him accountable.8:16 And, they expect that there'll be a large group from the church there to support the offender, and we're gonna do the best we can to be there for the victim.8:26 Yes. Yeah. It's just shocking to me when that happens. And I know it it's shocking, and yet I know the stories all too often that it seems like that happens more often than not. And then and then in8:37 the, so there's several questions that come to my mind. Let me just ask 1 to start with. I think 1 of the issues that the church is confused about a lot and does8:49 it really communicate as well as it could, to be sure, is on the topic of forgiveness.8:55 Yes.8:56 And then and and the way that forgiveness is oftentimes confused with restoration9:00 Yes.9:01 But but even if even if a church understands the difference between forgiveness and like, those are 2 separate things.9:07 Right.9:07 And sometimes we can forgive somebody and not be restored to them because they're not safe9:12 to be9:12 restored to. Right? That's correct. But but even if restoration isn't a part of it, I think sometimes on the topic, especially of abuse, forgiveness is communicated in9:24 ways that are not helpful. What what are your thoughts about that that topic of forgiveness?9:28 Yeah. The the forgiveness in that in that topic when it comes to sexual abuse, it's a bit like wading into the quicksand, and you can get you can really get mired in it. We need to forgive.9:40 Yep.9:42 1 of the things that I that I try to do to help make it clear is I go back to David. Okay? So David rapes Bathsheba.9:51 Yep.9:52 He has her husband killed, and God lets him go for almost a year because the child that he has with Bathsheba is born. So it's almost a year before Nathan the10:03 prophet confronts him. And, yeah, I've I've loved the way Nathan confronts him. He tells him a story. He draws David into it. David is outraged,10:15 at the story. And and when Nathan gets done telling it, David said that guy is gonna die, and he's gonna pay fourfold for what he did. And then Nathan says, you're the guy. And in that10:27 moment of time, for the first time, I think David saw the wickedness of what he had done. He says, I've sinned. And Nathan says, God's10:39 forgiven you, but because of what you've done, the sword will never depart from your house.10:44 Yes.10:44 And I think there's a distinction between we can forgive, and and it's important to forgive, but forgiveness is gonna be a process. What often happens is the church tries to force10:56 victims to forgive and shut up.10:58 Yes.10:59 And that is not what forgiveness is. And the other thing is and we hear this a lot. You need to forgive and never speak about this again. Yeah. Again, that's not biblical. It's untrue.11:11 Forgiveness is a letting go and, putting the offender in God's hands. That does not mean that there's not gonna be consequences and shouldn't be consequences for the11:23 offender.11:24 Right.11:24 So pursuing justice, you can pursue justice and forgive at the same time.11:31 Mhmm.11:32 And sometimes that looks a little awkward. Sometimes it's kinda messy, and you figure out how does this work. Right. But true forgiveness can happen and still hold this person11:44 accountable because and I think this is the biggest mistake that we make in the church is we treat the sexual abuse of a child or a vulnerable person only as a11:56 sin. It is an egregious sin, but is also a very violent crime, and great harm has been done. And God gives us a mandate in Revelation chapter 13, the first 5 verses,12:08 that government is there to punish those who do evil. And twice in that passage, god calls government his minister to execute vengeance on those who practice evil.12:19 So I think we make a mistake when we make forgiveness mean more than it does by trying to tuck in their restoration like you12:31 just talked about. Because in most cases where there's been childhood sexual abuse, it's not safe to reconcile with their offender. Mhmm. And yet oftentimes, the church tries to do that.12:40 Yes. Yeah. And I think also, as you're talking, I'm also reminded of the fact that simply so called, quote, unquote, supporting,12:52 somebody who has been the offender is actually not loving them well either.12:57 Yeah.12:57 Right? So can you speak to that, this sloppy we often talk about sloppy love, sloppy grace in context of our ministry of, not really calling people to genuine repentance for the sake of13:09 their own soul, for the sake of their, of their betterment and their walk with Christ. How how what do you think about the offender, a sexual offender, or an abuser Yes.13:21 Being what does it mean to love them well?13:24 So that is an excellent question. And what I do with that is I go back to Faith's dad and his story and Faith's story and my story.13:33 Mhmm.13:34 So Faith and I met in bible college. Just before we engaged, Faith was able to tell me that her dad had sexually abused her. My first reaction was I don't want anything to do with13:46 him. And Faith said, well, we have to love and forgive. So that conversation, I think that's an exact quote that happened between the 2 of us. So we're trying to okay. What does that look like?13:58 Yep.13:58 So up until 2006, if you would ask me about her father, I would say that we had chosen to love and forgive him.14:08 Mhmm.14:08 What I tell people now is what we did was nothing, and there's a big difference. Yes. So I never confronted him14:16 It's a great way of describing it.14:17 With what he had done to faith and give him a chance to repent, give him a chance to realize he's in big trouble unless he gets things right with god.14:30 So we really did nothing, but we called it love and forgiveness. It may have felt like love and forgiveness because, at that point, we weren't, I it14:42 never once crossed my mind to turn him into the authorities, and we actually could have for about a year with the statute of limitations in New York.14:49 Yep.14:50 Never crossed my mind because we had no teaching on it. But in 2006, in November, Face dad abused 1 of his son's foster daughters.15:00 Mhmm.15:00 I went with 2 of Face brothers to confront him for the first time, and I sat down with Faith before that meeting. And I said, I'm gonna confront dad with what he did to you so15:12 long ago. I need to know a little bit more. And that's when I found out he had raped and molested her from the time she was 9 until 18. And so I confronted him with it that night.15:25 And he was you know, blamed everybody else. Yep. It wasn't his fault. When we walked in the room, face dad sat there on the couch with his15:37 his left hand on an open bible, And before we could say anything, he started talking about everything God was teaching him, and he was learning all this stuff. And the message he was15:49 trying to give us that, hey, I've already got everything right with God. We don't, you know, we don't need to get in with anything. So what would have been loving the most loving to dad16:01 is what I did that night. And I told him, I said, we forgave you. And I said, I've always called you dad, and I will still call you dad. I do to this day. He died a few years ago.16:13 I'm convinced he's in hell today, not in heaven. Even though he was a pastor, he could share the gospel message. The pattern of his whole life was 1 of molesting and raping16:25 children and vulnerable adults. We've learned a lot more over the years, and I believe he's a wolf in sheep's clothing. But where he is right now, obviously,16:37 God knows. But the point is that night I said, if you'll make a full confession of what you not only did to your son's foster daughter, but now we knew about not just faith, but we knew16:49 about other victims at that point. They said, you gotta deal with that. Yep. I said, if you choose to deal with that, we will we will stay with you. If you don't do that, then we're gonna do what the17:00 bible says. We're gonna hold you accountable, and we're gonna break off all fellowship with you, which is what we did. We were at the hospital the day you died. We did not go to the bedside. We were there17:12 mainly to be with the rest of the family. Mhmm. But back to your original point about it's not loving for the offender. In the book that I wrote, tear down the swell of silence,17:24 1 of the things that I point out with Faith's dad, there are a lot of people in our church even, seniors that he did bible studies with, that were angry with us because we were holding him accountable. Right.17:37 And in the book, I point out the fact that what they're doing is holding his hand on the way to hell. They're not helping him.17:43 Yep.17:44 And you can love an offender. I mean, offenders, they're somebody's son or somebody's daughter. Yep. Oftentimes, they're, you know, husband. It17:56 could be a wife. I mean, we're hearing more and more about women's losers. We can love them. We can minister to them, but trying to protect them from the consequences of what they've done isn't gonna help them.18:07 No. Absolutely not. And when you talk about, the idea that that from your perspective, knowing knowing that you don't know ultimately, but that he could be in hell18:19 today or maybe likely is in hell today. Can you expound a little bit about that in terms of, I mean, I I believe from knowing you a little bit and you obviously, and knowing your18:30 theology a bit bit that it's it's it would be the idea that you said wolf in sheep's clothing. So not this idea that he lost his salvation, but rather that maybe he was in this religiosity or18:42 this, this cultural Christianity, and and had grown up in that or had been in it for a while, but never really came to a point of genuine surrender because there's there's fruit in keeping with genuine18:54 surrender. Right?18:56 Yes. And I think so if we go back to David for a minute, and if we draw a comparison, let's say, between David and, let's say, an abuser today, the thing with David was, clearly,19:08 he was a man after god's own heart. From the time he was a little child all the way up until he's king, he's a man after god's own heart. Near the end of his life, as he's getting older,19:21 he does, you know, some horrible things there that surrounded the issue with Bathsheba and Uriah. And the difference between David is when David's confronted, he19:33 repents. He bore the consequences of what he did. And if we take the passage in Hebrews, let me bring that into play where Hebrews talks about19:45 if you can sin habitually and not feel God's chastening hand, the Bible says that you're an illegitimate child. Mhmm. So you're not really a believer.19:57 With with Face Dad and with a lot of offenders, this behavior goes all the way back, in many cases, to childhood. And when a child20:09 is an abuser, it's almost always because they've been abused.20:14 Yes.20:14 And so they act out. As a child gets older and and they're transitioning from being a child to an adult, there comes a point where they realize what I'm doing is wrong.20:25 Yes.20:26 When they choose to continue the behavior, I think their conscience becomes more seared and more hardened. And it's very difficult for a sex offender who's taken that20:38 behavior into an adulthood, must say it's impossible. So we got a verse that says we got all things are possible.20:44 Yes.20:45 But when you carry that behavior over, it's very difficult. And I think with the Bible verse, it talks about illegitimate children, but it's this pattern in your life. Mhmm. I think that's the20:57 big difference.20:58 Okay. Yep. Do you think also that, like, growing up in in Baptist churches, in, some nondenominational churches,21:10 it seemed like I even remember when we we went to the Bible college that or Bible school that we both went to. I remember there was a time when Billy Graham, I think it was, had shaken hand21:22 with the pope on stage somewhere, and there was this big I remember something being slid under my door, these flyers of Yes. Billy Graham's no longer a Christian. I mean, I remember that.21:30 But Yes.21:31 It was kinda crazy. But my point in saying all of that, that was just sort of a a a trip down memory lane for a minute. But I think that, you know, I feel like in the Protestant church, in this wide,21:44 you know, there there's how many I mean, hundreds, maybe even thousands of denominations. Right? Whereas the Catholic church is so centralized that that when something happens there and it's exposed, it it has this kind21:56 of ripple effect throughout the denomination or it it, ricochets, you know, culturally. Whereas, you know, within the Protestant church with so many different denominations22:06 Yes.22:07 I feel like we are so quick to point the finger at the Catholic church, and we should be pointing out the the junk of the garbage. Right. But there's so little consideration for the unbelievable amount of of sexual abuse22:19 of children, abuse of of vulnerable people, wives, women, and others within the within the non Catholic church.22:26 Yes.22:26 What are your thoughts on that?22:28 So when the spotlight came out of the Catholic church, after all the abuse in the area of Boston was exposed22:34 Yes.22:35 So I was a young pastor, though. And I was like all those pastors very quick to point out is the Catholic church. It's, you know, because of this doctrine or that doctrine. Mhmm. But the reality is that abuse22:47 is across the board. It's in every denomination. It's in the church. It's outside of the church. And it's everywhere, but it's so easy to point22:59 the finger someplace else.23:00 Yep.23:01 And what needs to happen in a church so James talks about looking at a mirror and then turning around and walking away completely forgetting what man or a person we are. And that's really what's happening in a lot of23:13 our churches. We briefly look in the mirror. Maybe it maybe it's a a news story about abuse within our denomination or 1 of the mission boards that we're involved in or we support,23:26 But we tend to dismiss that as it's an isolated thing, and and we're not seeing really what's happening under our noses in our own families and in our own churches.23:35 Mhmm. Yep. Absolutely. And it seems like what's tragic, and this goes back to what you were saying earlier about this idea of holding someone's hand on their way to hell, is23:48 rather rather than enabling this kind of behavior, if if earlier on, someone were held accountable for what they were doing or as a child when somebody is24:00 experiencing abuse24:02 Yes.24:02 And I often talk about what happened to me as a kid of the early pornography exposure that happened, but also the sexual behavior of much older neighborhood boys, than me, most of them. Yes. And, and the the24:14 involvement that that they dragged me into with that and how that was so damaging. And yet the most that mom and dad and this wasn't their fault, but the most that mom and dad knew to say is, we just can't24:26 play with those boys anymore.24:27 Yeah.24:27 And and and that was the end of it. Right? Like, everything's fixed. Everything's all good.24:31 Yes.24:31 But it wasn't. It was still it was a wreck. Things were, you know, a disaster for me internally, and yet what it did is it it prompted me to shove everything down further and deeper24:41 Yes.24:41 And and not deal with, not know how to deal with any of this stuff. So so it winds up leaking out some way. It it wound up for me, it it really prompted what I know now that many, many,24:53 children growing up in church do, and that's to split off. It it so I I have this image on the 1 hand of going to church and being in the Christian family and all that kind of thing, but inwardly, I became a25:05 porn addict. I chronic masturbation was, a massive issue in my life. And and 1, on the 1 hand, hating all of that, and yet, on the other hand, feeling so compelled to live that out. So I so I bring that back though to25:18 how sad it is that when we could actually hold someone accountable Yes. And and cause kind of a, a reverberating effect throughout their whole system of, oh25:30 my goodness. What am I doing? Right. Instead, when we when we actually ignore it or support them in it or, you know, move them to some other we we cover it up for them.25:41 Right.25:41 We're actually doing this massive disservice because so often, the enabling continues25:46 for years25:46 and decades, and they're never confronted with their sin. And it becomes so entrenched that it just becomes so dark and so evil.25:53 Yes. And I Faith and I were at a conference in Chicago a number of years ago, and there was a speaker named Victor Veith who does a lot with the sexual abuse of children. And in26:05 the session that we were at, he was talking about youthful offenders. And he was saying that any kind of intervention when when an offender is a child,26:18 even if it's not the best intervention, but just intervention in general26:22 Yes.26:23 Can make all the difference in the world in that child's life to turn them away from that behavior. And yet, we have seen so many cases or heard of so many cases where, let's say, a mom finds26:35 out their son was molested and and he's 4, 5, 6 years old by another child a little bit older. Mhmm. The husband absolutely doesn't want it dealt26:47 with. He doesn't want his wife to confront Yep. The parents of the child. He doesn't want the police called. He just acts like it's no big deal, and that's exactly what you're talking about.Show more In this video 0:00 Confronting Abuse and the Church's Role
Comments
Keep it kind. Comments are public.